Re: Notes, Sept 24 2015

Great progress, w00t! :)

Erik Lagerway | Hookflash

On Thu, Sep 24, 2015 at 8:03 AM, Harald Alvestrand <harald@alvestrand.no>
wrote:

> On 09/24/2015 12:25 PM, Harald Alvestrand wrote:
> > 1) Admin items
> >
> > Targets. What do we need to push out, and when?
> > Result:
> > - Target date for next getusermedia
> Can be pushed at any time. Should be pushed again, let's do it after the
> meeting.
> Dan volunteered to do it Friday (and check with Cullen).
> > - Target date for next webrtc-pc
> One next week and one more before TPAC.
> > Both of these may be in terms of conditions for pushing rather than a
> > specific date.
> >
> > Reflowing. Each commit, or occasionally by the editors? (the Martin
> offer)
> Let's put Martin's suggestion into practice on the mediacapture spec.
> It's relatively stable.
>
> For webrtc-pc, we're not doing changes to procedures before TPAC (but
> need a tidy!)
>
> >
> > 2) Webrtc-PC PRs
> >
> > #242 Remove SyntaxError on malformed ICE candidate (Stefan)
> > OBE if #302 is merged. Otherwise OK.
> Merged.
> >
> > #256 Fix prose on getStats() (adam-be)
> > Ready?
> Merged.
> >
> > #266 Tidy up setLocal/Remote (adam-be)
> > Needs review of the new attempt, I think
> Another review from Martin and Peter needed.
> >
> > #273 Add a bunch of fields
> > Reviewed by Jan-Ivar, updated. Needs rebase. Ready?
> Adam will take care of merging.
> >
> > #280 Add extra Icetransports read-only attributes
> > Reviewed by dom, fixes applied. Needs rebase. Ready?
> Adam will take care of merging.
> >
> > #284 Add .onicecandidateerror (dom)
> > travis was OK after re-run. Ready?
> Merged.
> >
> > #291 Add PeerConnection.connectionState
> > Discussion has taken place on list. Ready?
> Seems ready. Adam will rebase and merge.
> >
> > #293 Add RTCRtpTransceiver and PeerConnection.addMedia
> > Might want more text and examples in it. List review still needed?
> More text needed - comment added.
> >
> > #298 Add codec reordering and removal
> > Comments addressed. Adam?
> Merged.
> >
> > #300 add API to get SSRC and audio levels
> > Still waiting for time to settle. Also, needs rebase.
> Not ready. Waiting for definition of time.
> >
> > #301 fix RTCStatsReport with object and maplike instead of getter
> > Last comment is "Let me try to rewrite it", so waiting.
> >
> > #302 Removing interface use for RTCSessionDescription and RTCIceCandidate
> > I personally dislike this, but I don't seem to have support.
> Adam inspects and merges.
> >
> > #307 Fix broken RTCPeerConnection's operation array
> > To be considered together with #314
> The PRs are now very small and seem to be converging.
> Waiting for discussion to settle among the 2 parties.
> >
> > #311 Fixing syntax for required RTCCertificate arguments
> > Merge, I think.
> Merged.
> >
> > #313 Fix markup bugs spotted by tidy
> > Another argument for "tidy them all"....
> Merged.
> >
> > #314 Update the operations queue to handle promises....
> > See #307 discussion
> See 307
> >
> > #315 Reorganize travis setup to use centralized check script (dom)
> > Not yet ready for discussion, it seems.
> Not ready.
> >
> > 3) Getusermedia PRs
> >
> > #211 Allow device capabilities to be discoverable
> > I think Joe has an opinion on the right way forward, and must execute
> > before merge.
> Submitter action needed
> >
> > #235 Remove static like definitions
> > Jan-Ivar had lots of problems 19 hours ago. Needs update?
> Submitter action needed.
> >
> > #239 getUserMedia TypeError on no types
> > Merge?
> Merged.
> >
> > #240 groupId is origin-unique
> > Merge?
> Merged.
> >
> > #241 Reference WebIDL-1
> > Merge? (Does this leave us with dangling syntax bits for newer parts of
> > WebIDL, or not?)
> Merged. We trust Dom.
> >
> > #245 appllyConstraints arg optional
> > Merge? (needed because Constraints and MediaTrackConstraints can be
> empty)
> Merged.
> >
> > #247 Unused candidates in SelectSettings
> > Fix looks good to me. Merge?
> Merged.
> >
> > 4) Getusermedia issues list
> >
> > We've allowed this to grow again. Only looking at the ones without an
> > assignee.
> > We should have an assignee with the responsibility of either drafting a
> > PR or provoking a debate.
> > (chairs are good debate-provokers. Editors should be responsible for PR
> > creation.)
> >
> > (We're probably running short of time at this point.)
> >
> > #222 Clarify whether groupId is origin-unique - I think PR #240 fixes
> this
> Fixed.
> >
> > #236 API to expose the angle of view of a camera - enhancement
> We're not doing this at this time.
> >
> > #237 step 5 in clone algorithm
> Dan.
> >
> > #242 Management of track members in a stream
> Assigned to Bernard - Adam will make some comments.
> >
> > #243 Confusing typo in sources  and sinks
> Dan.
> >
> > #246 track.applyConstraints() doesn't do anything
> We're stopping here.
> >
> > #248 Conflicting information about OverconstrainedError
> >
> > #249 PING: Document tradeoff for non-HTTPS
> >
> > #250 PING: Refer to security-arch
> >
> > #251 PING: Mark fingerprintability of device enumeration
> >
> > See you on the call!
> >
> >
>
>
> --
> Surveillance is pervasive. Go Dark.
>
>
>
>