Removing reference to ISSUE-35 from current Last Call Draft before CR

Also, to move to CR we really should close two dangling references in
the spec to ISSUE-35, which we closed back in February:

See resolution for closure here:
https://www.w3.org/2012/webcrypto/track/issues/35

The two references are:

1) In Section 14, the reference to
// TBD: ISSUE-35

2) And following Editorial Note:

"ISSUE-35: The specification for wrapKey/unwrapKey does not specify how
authors that do not trust the execution environment may indicate
required attributes for keys that are unwrapped. An example is
unwrapping a key with a non-extractable key, marking the newly unwrapped
key as non extractable, and then further indicating that all keys
unwrapped with the newly unwrapped key are also non-extractable."

If folks want to keep that as an informative note, that's fine - just
remove the references to "TBD: ISSUE 35" and change text so that it
doesn't appear the issue is still open in the spec text.

These are likely to block CR transition at W3C review and cause
confusion in readers about whether wrapping/unwrapping might change, so
it would be great if an editor would fix them. My understanding is
basically, in a non-"trusted execution environment", we can't enforce
parameters.

A number of other editorial notes that seem to signal unresolved
problems (even if WG has resolved problem) were mentioned in my previous
email and Bugzilla. Can one of the editors give these a look and make
the needed edits as soon as they can?

   cheers,
      harry

Received on Friday, 21 November 2014 01:43:04 UTC