Re: "Recommended" is a bad word :)

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1



On 05/12/2014 03:56 PM, Salz, Rich wrote:
>> Do you view these comments as "formal objection"?

Formal objections need to be filed by May 20th, ideally beforehand.


> 
> When do you need an answer?
> 
> On the one hand, I don't want to be an ass.  On the other hand, you
> asked for IETF review and you got it, in the form of email from
> Kenny and colleagues.
> 
> There is no risk in incorporating the security concerns into the
> document; a weak mechanism is not going to suddenly "get better"
> it's only going to get weaker. Given that, I do not understand such
> strongly-expressed concern about putting such advice into the
> current document.  I am also puzzled that nobody else on the WG has
> expressed any real opinion (we security types are a paranoid
> bunch:). As such, I am leaning toward making this a formal
> objection, but I will need to discuss with colleagues first.  So,
> when do you need to know?
> 
> Thanks.
> 
> /r$
> 
> -- Principal Security Engineer Akamai Technologies, Cambridge, MA 
> IM: rsalz@jabber.me; Twitter: RichSalz
> 
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
Comment: Using GnuPG with Thunderbird - http://www.enigmail.net/
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=WXTv
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

Received on Monday, 12 May 2014 13:57:50 UTC