Re: [whatwg/dom] [Declarative Shadow DOM] How should we build the "opt-in" for fragment parsing of declarative Shadow DOM? (#912)

Re: Document Policy, which is available in Chromium as of M86, and is currently used for the opt-out for scroll-to-text.

In general, I'd much rather see features like this defined in terms of Document Policy than Sandbox; sandboxing has some very un-ergonomic properties. Adding this to sandbox means that it is automatically disabled by default in every sandboxed frame; it also means that a developer wanting to disable just this feature would have to use <iframe sandbox> and then specifically re-enable every other sandbox feature. (And keep that list up to date if other sandbox flags are added).

One question to ask right now is whether frames should be allowed to set this flag independently of their parent frames; sandbox does not allow that, ever -- if disabled in one frame, it is necessarily disabled in all of its subframes. Document policy allows a frame to disable a feature, without necessarily imposing the same restrictions on embedded content. (The spec does include a way to impose restrictions like that on subframes, like sandbox does, but that mode is not shipped yet.)

-- 
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/whatwg/dom/issues/912#issuecomment-722795673