Re: [w3c/charter-html] Relation with WICG (#141)

IMHO:
The experiment is still happening. This charter is taking work out of incubation for the first time Web Platform has seriously tried it. (18 months into our existence…)

A few things I want to see:

- How long does it take us to get work moved over ?

So far I would say too long - as well as the 4-week charter review mandated by Process that we have not started yet, we've been at this for about 6 weeks. If that happens again I'll be pushing for a change in how we do this.

- Is there a community in WICG that has a sense of moving stuff toward being a W3C standard, or is it just a place for big companies to do *de facto* standards without having to follow a consensus process?

Hard to say, overall. It seems that there are data to support either hypothesis at the moment. The good feature of WICG, that it is possible to do an experiment easily and fail fast, also means the data we get are hard to interpret.

- When do we need to incubate from scratch, when is something an incremental step that should be done in the WG direct?

Again, hard to say. My initial feeling is that this is hard to define by rules, and we'll end up calling it as we see it on each case, but more experience might help.

-- 
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub:
https://github.com/w3c/charter-html/issues/141#issuecomment-301756463