- From: Gregg Vanderheiden <gv@trace.wisc.edu>
- Date: Wed, 30 Nov 2005 12:54:34 -0600
- To: "'Roberto Ellero'" <rellero@webaccessibile.org>, <public-wcag-teama@w3.org>, <public-wcag-teamc@w3.org>, <public-wcag-teamb@w3c.org>
Thanks Roberto I've sorted these into the three categories. Could you add a sentence behind each that we could use in closing them? ALSO A FEW QUESTIONS... 1) I don't know what to do with this one: " There are also: (not in media-equiv_issues.php URL)" 2) 1730 and 1731 I think need to stay open since we have questions about their level - yes? 3) some #2's are not clear. When you add your sentence of rationale' it will help. Perhaps best if you format these like I did the ones for 1.4. Thanks Gregg CLOSE - COVERED BY CURRENT WORDING 1151. Scoping requirements, relation to policy 1 [wiki http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Guide_to_1.2_L1_SC1] 1625. Caption and transcripted needed in Level 1 1 1718. make what is accessible to AT clear 1 1730. Guideline 1.2 L1 SC 1b Captioning should remain at Level 1 1 1731. GL 1.2 L1/L2: Audio descriptions should remain at Level 1 1 CLOSE - NOT RELATED TO CURRENT WORDING 1152. Some video does not require description 2 (see also 1624) 1153. Radio show with interviews and songs 2 1370. GL 1.2, Example 1 - can't understand 2 1627. No universal sign language 2 1604. Guideline 1.2 shows captions for a tutorial being in all upper case 2 1624. Silent video and animation need indication that they are silent 2 CLOSE -- SUGGEST REJECTING FOR FOLLOWING REASON 1534. Example of musical soundtrack with lyrics 3 1704. Audio descriptions "undue hardship" at level 1 3 1602. Audio Descriptions should not be L1 3 - Suggest accepting Joe Clark's comment and closing 1754. Objection to captions at level 1 3 CLOSE AFTER MAKING THE FOLLOWING CHANGES 1729. Guideline 1.2 - L1 SC 1a: Text transcripts should remain Level 1 4 (also 1625 and 1732 related) My opinion is Suggest making the following change : Change 1.2.1 to "Provide captions AND provide a text transcript of all audio intermixed with a text description of what is happening visually." 1601. Captions transcripts as level 1 (see 1729 suggested change) KEEP AS OPEN ISSUE 1732. GL 1.2 Benefits comments 5 Gregg -- ------------------------------ Gregg C Vanderheiden Ph.D. Professor - Ind. Engr. & BioMed Engr. Director - Trace R & D Center University of Wisconsin-Madison -----Original Message----- From: Roberto Ellero [mailto:rellero@webaccessibile.org] Sent: Wednesday, November 30, 2005 12:33 PM To: Gregg Vanderheiden; public-wcag-teama@w3.org; public-wcag-teamc@w3.org; public-wcag-teamb@w3c.org Subject: Re: Next step Hi, I volunteered for issues for Guideline 1.2. ---------- 1 - addressed by our current edits 2 - OBE (overcome by events) (e.g. the bug no longer applies with our new wording) 3 - Suggest rejecting comment and closing (based on our discussions to date) 4 - Suggest making the following change and closing it 5 - keep item open. ---------- [http://trace.wisc.edu/bugzilla_wcag/issuereports/media-equiv_issues.php] No Pending Issues. Open Issues: 1151. Scoping requirements, relation to policy 1 [wiki http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Guide_to_1.2_L1_SC1] 1152. Some video does not require description 2 (see also 1624) 1153. Radio show with interviews and songs 2 1370. GL 1.2, Example 1 - can't understand 2 1534. Example of musical soundtrack with lyrics 3 1625. Caption and transcripted needed in Level 1 1 1627. No universal sign language 2 1704. Audio descriptions "undue hardship" at level 1 3 1718. make what is accessible to AT clear 1 1729. Guideline 1.2 - L1 SC 1a: Text transcripts should remain Level 1 4 (also 1625 and 1732 related) My opinion is Suggest making the following change : Change 1.2.1 to "Provide captions AND provide a text transcript of all audio intermixed with a text description of what is happening visually." 1730. Guideline 1.2 L1 SC 1b Captioning should remain at Level 1 1 1731. GL 1.2 L1/L2: Audio descriptions should remain at Level 1 1 1732. GL 1.2 Benefits comments 5 There are also: (not in media-equiv_issues.php URL) 1601. Captions transcripts as level 1 (see 1729 suggested change) 1604. Guideline 1.2 shows captions for a tutorial being in all upper case 2 1624. Silent video and animation need indication that they are silent 2 1602. Audio Descriptions should not be L1 3 - Suggest accepting Joe Clark's comment and closing 1754. Objection to captions at level 1 3 Best regards, Roberto Ellero ----- Original Message ----- From: "Gregg Vanderheiden" <gv@trace.wisc.edu> To: "'Roberto Ellero'" <rellero@webaccessibile.org>; <public-wcag-teama@w3.org>; <public-wcag-teamc@w3.org>; <public-wcag-teamb@w3c.org> Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2005 10:46 PM Subject: RE: Next step You have it. Gregg -- ------------------------------ Gregg C Vanderheiden Ph.D. Professor - Ind. Engr. & BioMed Engr. Director - Trace R & D Center University of Wisconsin-Madison -----Original Message----- From: public-wcag-teamb-request@w3.org [mailto:public-wcag-teamb-request@w3.org] On Behalf Of Roberto Ellero Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2005 3:03 PM To: Gregg Vanderheiden; public-wcag-teama@w3.org; public-wcag-teamc@w3.org; public-wcag-teamb@w3c.org Subject: Re: Next step Hi, I'm interested in 1.2. Best regards, Roberto Ellero ----- Original Message ----- From: "Gregg Vanderheiden" <gv@trace.wisc.edu> To: <public-wcag-teama@w3.org>; <public-wcag-teamc@w3.org>; <public-wcag-teamb@w3c.org> Sent: Tuesday, November 29, 2005 4:21 PM Subject: RE: Next step So everyone can keep track of what has been assigned I will keep a list of the assignments in the Twiki Home page http://trace.wisc.edu/wcag_wiki/index.php?title=Main_Page Currently assigned are 1.4, 2.2, 2.3, 3.1 Please check the WIKI page before volunteering for a guideline. Please volunteer for a guideline.
Received on Wednesday, 30 November 2005 18:55:35 UTC