- From: Vincent François <vfrancois@accessibiliteweb.com>
- Date: Wed, 02 Nov 2011 21:11:54 -0400
- To: public-wai-evaltf@w3.org
- Message-id: <4EB1EA5A.8070209@accessibiliteweb.com>
Hi, I do agree with a clear separation between both testing and consulting. But in real life, the important question the guy who pays for the test is "What have I to do to repair?", more than "do I pass the test?". Then we have to separate them clearly because in most cases they will be asked for, one immediately after the other. Le 11-11-02 14:40, Alistair Garrison a écrit : > Hi Kerstin, > > I agree... > > Organisations offering testing should, to my mind, be independent and impartial - free from any commercial, financial and other pressures which might influence technical judgement (being paid just for the testing they undertake). They should offer test results, without corrective consultancy. > > Precisely the same model for testing organisations is mirrored across many industries. Take for example car safety testing centres in the UK (MOT centres) - which are independent and impartial - they do testing, but don't offer car services or repair any vehicles. > > All the best > > Alistair > > On 2 Nov 2011, at 18:11, Kerstin Probiesch wrote: > >> Hi all, >> >> I suggest that we write a small chapter in our methodology about the >> difference between consulting and testing. One important point I see >> is, that in a consulting process one can recommend those techniques >> which are oder might be the best for a given web page. One can also >> recommend favorised technique/s for an SC. While testing a web page, >> it is not important which techniques are the best or wether a web >> developer has used techniques the consultant favors. The only thing >> which is important is: Is the SC met or not? Therefore it is necessary >> to keep these two "levels" strictly apart and necessary that a tester >> is testing a web page in a dispassionate and sober attitude. >> >> Thoughts? >> >> Best >> >> Kerstin >> >> >> >> >> ------------------------------------- >> Kerstin Probiesch - Freie Beraterin >> Barrierefreiheit, Social Media, Webkompetenz >> Kantstraße 10/19 | 35039 Marburg >> Tel.: 06421 167002 >> E-Mail: k.probiesch@gmail.com >> Web: http://www.barrierefreie-informationskultur.de >> >> XING: http://www.xing.com/profile/Kerstin_Probiesch >> Twitter: http://twitter.com/kprobiesch >> ------------------------------------ >> > > -- Vincent François Directeur général *Coopérative AccessibilitéWeb* 1751 rue Richardson, bureau 6111 Montréal (Qc), Canada H3K 1G6 vincent.francois@accessibiliteweb.com <mailto:vincent.francois@accessibiliteweb.com> http://www.accessibiliteweb.com <http://www.accessibiliteweb.com/> Tél. : +1 514-312-3378 Sans frais : +1 877-315-5550
Received on Thursday, 3 November 2011 01:12:28 UTC