RE: Functional versus non-functional requirements for accessibility

Thanks for your answer, Dave.

 

Sorry for that confusion. Yes, I was referring to your survey comments.

https://www.w3.org/2002/09/wbs/35532/curriculaDesignerModulesEagleReview/results#xq9

 

I have changed the examples I had under functional requirements. Some somehow clashed with WCAG, which we defined as
non-functional. Now I have

 

[[

* identify different functional requirements that relate to people with disabilities, for example:

  * a person with disabilities needs to understand how clothing looks like both through vision and through text descriptions

  * a person with disabilities needs to be able to choose their sit when buying a ticket using their assistive technology of choice

]]

https://deploy-preview-347--wai-curricula.netlify.app/curricula/designer-modules/understanding-and-involving-users/#topic-establish
ing-requirements

 

Is the difference between functional and non-functional requirements now clearer?

 

What other examples of functional requirements related to people with disabilities would you suggest?

 

Thanks.

 

Best.

 

--

 

Daniel Montalvo

 

Accessibility Education and Training Specialist

W3C/WAI

 

From: David Sloan <dsloan@tpgi.com> 
Sent: jueves, 10 de junio de 2021 11:03
To: Daniel Montalvo <dmontalvo@w3.org>
Cc: public-wai-curricula@w3.org
Subject: Re: Functional versus non-functional requirements for accessibility

 

Hi Daniel

 

Apologies for the lack of detail in the response as I need some clarity on what you're asking. I assume it's from a survey comment
I left, but I can't remember the details of what I said!

 

But in general, I'm referring to the distinction in software engineering between:

1.	functional requirements-things that define what a product should do, and
2.	non-functional requirements-constraints on the system and its development

 

Non-functional requirements would cover things like security requirements, response time, usability, and accessibility. [1]

 

For example, a system might include a functional requirement that a user can purchase a product.

 

And some associated non-functional requirements would be that the purchase process should be secure, accessible, and usable across
a set of specified platforms and environments.

 

In other words, we can say that WCAG conformance is a non-functional requirement of a web product. Each of the product's functional
requirements should be implemented in a way that ensures the functionality is accessible to users with disabilities.

 

Does that help?

 

Dave

 

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-functional_requirement

 

 

--
David Sloan (he/him)
Principal Accessibility Engineer

Strategy and Research Lead


 

TPG Interactive

 <https://www.tpgi.com/> www.tpgi.com 

 

A Vispero Company
 <https://vispero.com> https://vispero.com


--
This message is intended to be confidential and may be legally privileged. It is intended solely for the addressee. If you are not
the intended recipient, please delete this message from your system and notify us immediately.
Any disclosure, copying, distribution or action taken or omitted to be taken by an unintended recipient in reliance on this message
is prohibited and may be unlawful.

 

 

From: Daniel Montalvo <dmontalvo@w3.org <mailto:dmontalvo@w3.org> >
Date: Wednesday, 9 June 2021 at 09:59
To: David Sloan <dsloan@tpgi.com <mailto:dsloan@tpgi.com> >
Cc: public-wai-curricula@w3.org <mailto:public-wai-curricula@w3.org>  <public-wai-curricula@w3.org
<mailto:public-wai-curricula@w3.org> >
Subject: Functional versus non-functional requirements for accessibility

CAUTION: This email originated outside Vispero. Do not click links, open attachments or forward unless you recognize the sender.


Hey Dave,

As per your comment about distinguishing functional and non-functional requirements.

Currently I have capture this as follows.

[[

Topic: Establishing Requirements

Present the W3C accessibility standards. Discuss policies that apply in the students' region (if any). Explain functional and
non-functional requirements related to people with disabilities.

Learning Outcomes for Topic

Students should be able to:

* identify different non-functional accessibility requirements, for example those included in WCAG and in applicable accessibility
policies
* identify different functional requirements that relate to people with disabilities, for example:
  * appropriate contrast ratios
  * availability of content and functionality in different screen sizes and configurations
  * keyboard compatibility
  * compatibility with assistive technologies and adaptive strategies
]]

For context, see
https://deploy-preview-347--wai-curricula.netlify.app/curricula/designer-modules/understanding-and-involving-users/#topic-establish
ing-requirements

But I am a bit hesitant as to how this is going to be understood. On the one hand we could consider WCAG as non-functional (it does
not tell you how to do things) but on the other hand WCAG does have specific requirements such as contrast ratios, descriptive
labels and headings, that could be understood as functional.

Could you please expand on this a bit more? How would you better capture the difference between functional and non-functional
requirements for accessibility?

Best.

--

Daniel Montalvo

Accessibility Education and Training Specialist
W3C/WAI