RE: Prefixing requirements

Looks good, great idea. 

I believe the wording on the following requirements was corrected, introducing some duplication/contradiction:

42. The IPA Client SHOULD forward audio data and metadata (if any) to the ASR
43. The IPA Client MAY forward audio data and metadata (if any) to the ASR
44. The IPA Service MUST forward audio data and metadata (if any) to the ASR
45. The IPA Service MUST forward audio data and metadata (if any) to the ASR

I suggest deleting 45 as a duplicate. Also, we shouldn’t have both 42 and 43. I prefer deleting 42, just on the grounds that I think it’s a good idea to minimize the use of SHOULD in general, but I don’t have a strong preference.

 

 

From: dirk@switch-consulting.de <dirk@switch-consulting.de> 
Sent: Tuesday, March 28, 2023 13:42
To: public-voiceinteraction@w3.org
Subject: Prefixing requirements

 

Dear Debbie,

 

I found the numbering of requirements ambiguous and wanted to ease the identification of each requirement. Therefore, I made some updates to the document (and also corrected very few HTML errors).

 

Please, check if you find this suitable: https://w3c.github.io/voiceinteraction/voice%20interaction%20drafts/paRequirements/paRequirements.htm

 

Dirk