[voiceinteraction] Minutes July 1, 2020

https://www.w3.org/2020/07/01-voiceinteraction-minutes.html

and below as text

 

   [1]W3C

 

      [1] http://www.w3.org/

 

                               - DRAFT -

 

                   Voice Interaction Community Group

 

01 Jul 2020

 

Attendees

 

   Present

          debbie, jon

 

   Regrets

 

   Chair

          debbie

 

   Scribe

          debbie

 

Contents

 

     * [2]Topics

     * [3]Summary of Action Items

     * [4]Summary of Resolutions

     __________________________________________________________

 

   <scribe> scribe: debbie

 

   debbie: interested in talking about DNS process as it applies

   to personal assistants

 

   jon: we could talk about two topics: DNS/ICANN or architecture

   ... Jim should be on the call when we talk about DNS

 

   debbie: I think the ICANN/DNS process would be worth looking at

   ... when Jim is on the call

   ... so we can look at the architecture today

 

   jon: does this meta-architecture make a distinction between

   cloud and local?

 

   debbie: this doesn't make a distinction

 

   jon: need to have a privacy-centric architecture

 

   debbie: not just cloud vs. embedded

   ... also on-premise servers

   ... this doesn't address privacy, but we were thinking that

   privacy could be accommodated

 

   jon: how does enterprise ipa protect my data?

 

   debbie: one model would be to pattern after the web so that

   when you enter an enterprise's space it authenticates you

 

   jon: could enter an enterprise as a guest

 

   debbie: for example, Amazon lets you shop but if you want to

   buy you have to log in

 

   jon: how do you keep Target's data out of the hands of Amazon?

 

   debbie: like how do you keep you data out of the hands of

   Google

   ... use a different browser like Duck-Duck go

   ... all platforms have to provide privacy settings

   ... you just don't use Amazon

   ... two options, making it possible to enforce privacy or

   platforms actually being forced to respect privacy

   ... there is accessibility legislation, but people don't

   necessarily respect it

 

   jon: standards for enforcing privacy should be developed first

   ... the EU would be interested in ideas

   ... consumer privacy is enforced by legislation

   ... commercial privacy

   ... what stops Amazon from claiming your data

 

   debbie: some things are just another example of abuse that

   might happen on the web and some are specific to voice

   assistants

   ... we should make sure that voice data remains private

 

   jon: consumer should be able to opt out of sharing voice data

   or try to sell me stuff

 

   debbie: is there a list of privacy issues that need to be

   handled

   ... how to deal with what happens between dialog and provider

   ... some things don't work, like EULA's

 

   jon: how to connect proprietary platform to providers

 

   debbie: how about a proposal that would modify the

   architecture?

 

   jon: will talk to Jim about coming up with a proposal

 

   debbie: put proposals on the public list, you can also

   introduce yourself

 

   jon: next time we can discuss DNS and architecture

 

Summary of Action Items

 

Summary of Resolutions

 

   [End of minutes]

     __________________________________________________________