- From: Menagh, Trevor <Trevor_Menagh@Comcast.com>
- Date: Mon, 5 Mar 2012 14:12:22 +0000
- To: Peter Pinch <peter_pinch@wgbh.org>
- CC: "public-vocabs@w3.org" <public-vocabs@w3.org>
I think that adding it closedCaptioned to CreativeWork makes sense. I only introduced it it VideoObject because of the extension we created was on that object. Yours, Trevor On Mar 3, 2012, at 11:20 AM, Peter Pinch wrote: > I agree that a closedCaptioned property would be useful, but why limit it > to VideoObject? > > It would be useful on MediaObject, and possibly even on CreativeWork (if > users were looking for items that are captioned that don't have > MediaObjects available online, like a TVEpisode or a captioned DVD). > > There was some effort in the group working on education (LRMI) to have a > broad definition of accessibility, but it had to dropped in the interests > of time. I think this is an area that would benefit from a more systemic > approach. > > -- > Peter Pinch > Director of Technology > WGBH Interactive > office: 617-300-3961 > E-mail: peter_pinch@wgbh.org > > > > On 3/2/12 11:22 AM, "Menagh, Trevor" <Trevor_Menagh@Comcast.com> wrote: > >> Hello all, >> >> I am working on a team at Comcast that is using the VideoObject from >> Schema..org and would like to start a discussion on extending the schema >> to have two new properties: >> >> closedCaptioned (Boolean) Whether this video has closed captioning >> available. >> packagingFormat (Text) Packaging format used (ism, hls, move, etc). >> >> closedCaptioned is self-explanatory. >> >> packagingFormat describes the format that the video object is packaged >> in, as opposed to its encodingFormat. A video in mpeg4, for example, >> could be cut up and packaged to allow for variable bitrate transmission >> in a packaging system like Microsoft's ism, or Apple's hls format. >> >> We propose that this information would be useful for conveying >> information about a video object in the general schema. I look forward to >> your comments.. >> >> Yours, >> Trevor >> -- >> Trevor Lalish-Menagh, Sr. Web Developer >> Trevor_Menagh@Comcast.com >> (484) 868-6150 (mobile) >> cimtmenagh (AIM/Skype) >> >> >> > -- Trevor Lalish-Menagh, Sr. Web Developer Trevor_Menagh@Comcast.com (484) 868-6150 (mobile) cimtmenagh (AIM/Skype)
Received on Monday, 5 March 2012 14:25:30 UTC