- From: <Johnb@screen.subtitling.com>
- Date: Thu, 7 Aug 2003 11:44:14 +0100
- To: public-tt@w3.org
- Message-ID: <11E58A66B922D511AFB600A0244A722E09409C@NTMAIL>
Dear TT-WG, For those that don't know me - I am a software engineer for a company that produces subtitling (captioning) equipment - so all my comments should be taken in that context. I have just been reading through the F2F minutes for March on the TT-WG home page, and have two questions regarding the tentative model that seems to be appearing for TT-AF. Assuming that I wish to separate the timing in my TT-AF document from the content - by using references within the timing 'tree' a la Daisy model - and assuming that this might be possible! - would it then possible to apply style through the timing tree rather than by inline markup or attribute within the text content. I.e. - using example (crudely hatcheted from GA examples) <seq> <ref id="T27" dur="3s"/> <ref id="T28" begin="T27.end " dur="3s"/> </seq> <tt:content id="T27"> Some text with some&nl; Hard line breaks. </tt:content> <tt:content id="T28"> Some more text with some&nl; Hard line breaks. </tt:content> will it be possible to do something like this.... (in spirit if not in exactly this manner...)? <seq> <ref id="T27" dur="3s" style="text-indent:10pt"/> <ref id="T28" begin="T27.end " dur="3s" style="font-size:14pt"/> </seq> <tt:content id="T27"> Some text with some&nl; Hard line breaks. </tt:content> <tt:content id="T28"> Some more text with no Hard line breaks. </tt:content> further - might it be possible to replace the style attribute above with a reference to an element (or portion of a style sheet) that defines the style (to avoid multiple large style attribute definitions)? E.g. <seq> <ref id="T27" dur="3s" style="S1"/> <ref id="T28" begin="T27.end " dur="3s" style="S2"/> </seq> <tt:content id="T27"> Some text with some&nl; Hard line breaks. </tt:content> <tt:content id="T28"> Some more text with no Hard line breaks. </tt:content> <StyleDef id="S1" defn="text-indent:10pt"/> <StyleDef id="S2" defn="font-size:14pt"/> A second question.... It would be desirable for TT (at least IMHO) to include mechanisms for describing the temporal breaking of content. What I am thinking of is a document that does not describe explicitly the timing for all of the content - but rather describes that X amount of content fits into a box of size Y over a time period of Z. Now if the content X is too large for box Y - how does the content get over(?)flowed in a 'temporal sense' through the box. This is a 'crux' issue in subtitling / captioning. regards John Birch The views and opinions expressed are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect the views and opinions of Screen Subtitling Systems Limited.
Received on Thursday, 7 August 2003 06:34:15 UTC