Re: CfC: ActivityPub errata on inconsistencies in the side effects of receiving a Follow activity

>  I object to removing the requirement

Hi Ben, I wanted to clarify that the requirement in Section 7.5 "Follow
activity" is not being removed; it is already present in 7.7 "Reject
activity". The text is duplicated partially in 7.5 but also incorrect due
to stating that "In the case of receiving an Accept referencing this Follow
as the object, the server *SHOULD* add the actor to the object actor's
Followers
Collection <https://www.w3.org/TR/activitypub/#followers>." This is
backwards; receiving an Accept Follow should result in you(r server)
modifying your followING collection. More to the point, though, this text
is once again present/duplicated in 7.6 "Accept activity". So the result is
that both sentences should be removed (the first as erroneous, and both as
duplicated while better belonging elsewhere). This leaves nothing in the
paragraph.

I understand that the errata text is not descriptive of the actual error,
and I agree that an error description would contextualize the correction.
Hopefully we can resubmit a CfC using the above as an error description.
I'll also comment this on the GitHub issue so that it doesn't get lost in
the process!

Received on Friday, 13 June 2025 18:14:30 UTC