- From: Christian Pietsch / Digitalcourage <christian.pietsch@digitalcourage.de>
- Date: Fri, 22 Sep 2023 14:15:49 +0200
- To: public-swicg@w3.org
- Message-ID: <ZQ2FdaisXZ7SQ+Ir@localhost>
+1 to everything Lisa wrote. As this is my first post to this group, a short introduction is in order: My name is Christian Pietsch, and I joined SWICG a week ago signing IPR & CLA. I run Fediverse services for Digitalcourage, a digital rights NGO founded 1987 in Germany (Chaos family and EDRi member). See my sig for links. Christian On Wed, Sep 20, 2023 at 10:53:41PM -0700, Lisa Rein wrote: > Hello Everyone, > > Lisa Rein, Co-founder of Creative Commons and Aaron Swartz Day here. > > I have strong concerns about moving any open social web work out of the CG > process and into a WG because it means less folks will be able to > participate. > > The whole point of creating a Decentralized Web is to have a more level > playing field where independent groups can interoperate and flourish, > which requires the process for creating Decentralized Web standards to be > as transparent and inclusive as possible. > > To that end, I think it would be a tragedy to move any decentralized > social web standard activity from the current open, consensus-based > process to any closed, member-only process. > > Decentralized Web standards deserve to be developed in a truly open and > inclusive manner - rather than a top-down approach where all concerned > voices cannot possibly be heard, simply because they don’t actually have > access to the process. > > Only a transparent process, that is truly inclusive, will have any hope of > being able to address the concerns of the numerous, diverse and often > marginalized communities that will be depending on these very important > Decentralized Web standards. > > Thanks, > > lisa > > > Lisa Rein > > Co-Founder, Creative Commons > Co-Founder, Aaron Swartz Day > > Chelsea Manning's Archivist > Digital Librarian, Dr. Timothy Leary Futique Trust -- Christian Pietsch | Digitalcourage e.V.: https://digitalcourage.de Mastodon: https://digitalcourage.social Pixelfed: https://digitalcourage.photo PeerTube: https://digitalcourage.video BigBrotherAwards Germany: https://bigbrotherawards.de/
Attachments
- application/pgp-keys attachment: PGP Key 0x194C7A8EBE44C523.
Received on Friday, 22 September 2023 12:16:27 UTC