Re: mailto: semantics, batting averages, and semantic interoperability

Le mardi, 23 sep 2003, à 19:05 America/Montreal, Dan Connolly a écrit :
>   Does mailto:foo@example identify an Internet mailbox?

What's an internet mailbox?
	- an individual user? 	-> aminata@example.org
	- a generic user?		-> webmaster@example.org
	- Aminata's pager?		-> aminata+pager@example.org
	- a mailing list?		-> public-sw-meaning@example.org

Does all of them qualify in the same way?

> But consider this argument:
>
>   1. { ?X.log:uri str:startsWith "mailto:" } => { ?X a :Mailbox }.
>   2. <mailto:foo@example> log:uri "mailto:foo@example".
>   3. "mailto:foo@example" str:startsWith "mailto:"
>   4. <mailto:foo@example> a :Mailbox.

/me still tries to understand in plain english if not plain french. :))

> Either way, the w3.org access control machine is going to
> accept the above proof that yes, <mailto:foo@example> a :Mailbox.

Depending on the circumstances I guess.


--
Karl Dubost - http://www.w3.org/People/karl/
W3C Conformance Manager
*** Be Strict To Be Cool ***

Received on Tuesday, 23 September 2003 20:00:41 UTC