- From: Scott Henninger <scotthenninger@gmail.com>
- Date: Tue, 14 Sep 2021 00:24:45 -0500
- To: public-shacl@w3.org
- Message-ID: <CAJ-KvVpoZca8+yaco3QK4WFoFs0GHN_z_4j6zZBx=Q2xByqdRw@mail.gmail.com>
I have a couple of scenarios that involve restrictions on classes. Most of them I can get working, but a couple I'm finding a bit difficult to figure out. To make it simple, I'll start with the parent type restriction I'm trying to express. The following would be a valid shape as it targets ex:Cls1, specifies a parent with ex:parent, and the parent has one of the types ex:P_cls{1, 2, 3}. (In all of these cases the targetClass is ex:Cls1). ex:Child1 a ex:Cls1 ; ex:parent ex:Parent1 ; .. ex:Parent1 a ex:Pcls1 ; .. This would be an invalid shape because ex:Pcls{1,2,3} types must be defined for the parent: ex:Child1 a ex:Cls1 ; ex:parent ex:Parent1 ; .. ex:Parent1 a ex:P_clsInvalid_a ; .. This one is valid because it includes one of ex:Pcls{1,2,3}: ex:Child1 a ex:Cls1 ; ex:parent ex:Parent1 ; . ex:Parent1 a ex:P_cls2, ex:P_clsInvalid_a ; . The fourth is invalid because only one of ex:Pcls{1, 2, 3} is allowed: ex:Child1 a ex:Cls1 ; ex:parent ex:Parent1 ; .. ex:Parent1 a ex:P_cls1, ex:P_cls2; .. If I could live with a list of disallowed types (for the sake of maintenance I'd rather say allow only ex:P_cls{1, 2, 3}) then the following seems to work: my_sh:ParentTypeRestriction a sh:NodeShape ; sh:targetClass ex:Cls1 ; sh:property[ s h:path ex:parent ; sh:or ( [ sh:class ex:P_cls1 ] [ sh:class ex:P_cls2 ] [ sh:class ex:P_cls3 ] [ sh:not [ sh:class ex:P_clsInvalid_a ] ] ) ; sh:message "parent type for ex:Cls1 is not in x:P_cls{1, 2, 3}" ; ] ; .. ...where I include an exhaustive list for sh:not. As stated before, this isn't the best when the model changes and I need to find all the places where it needs to be excluded. So any ideas on how to 1) improve this shape, or 2) future-proof it for future additions to the rsf:type list? Thanks a bunch for taking a look. -- Scott Scott Henninger scotthenninger@gmail.com
Received on Tuesday, 14 September 2021 18:14:38 UTC