- From: Robin Berjon <robin@berjon.com>
- Date: Wed, 2 Dec 2015 10:51:20 -0500
- To: Ivan Herman <ivan@w3.org>
- Cc: Johannes Wilm <johanneswilm@vivliostyle.com>, Florian Rivoal <florian@rivoal.net>, W3C Scholarly HTML CG <public-scholarlyhtml@w3.org>
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- Hash: SHA512 On 02/12/2015 10:34 , Ivan Herman wrote: > There may be a middle way for this specific aspect, though. Using > RDFa is based on a specific RDF vocabulary (schema.org + some > things). It is perfectly possible to embed RDF into the HTML using > JSON-LD and the script tag. Ie, the author can choose to use that > instead of RDFa, and the result is identical. Schema.org (afaik) > understands both approaches and many RDFa processors (e.g., > Python's RDFLib) has parsers both for RDFa and the embedded > JSON-LD. Yes, we've considered that option and in fact we use for some things: http://scholarly.vernacular.io/#data-rich. One interesting application of that is as a manifest for a larger research bundle. The problems are: • For the specific issue of encoding authorship (or for that matter citations) the JSON-LD is not necessarily that much clearer than the RDFa :) Especially with roles. • In general I think it is a good guiding principle that things that should be shown to humans should actually be in the HTML. This rules out JSON-LD islands for authors and citations (but completely keeps it in for other things). - -- • Robin Berjon - http://berjon.com/ - @robinberjon • http://science.ai/ — intelligent science publishing • -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- Version: GnuPG/MacGPG2 v2 Comment: GPGTools - https://gpgtools.org iQIcBAEBCgAGBQJWXxN4AAoJECyUfoUUVwDbU0MP/1FV+wzd9m4PIXDc+1UVtz6V KSPI0eP3Yd2zBHJ+2QLfWfYOOUdD9qvqGm6eBhp3npDTMlRp/6s5yAuzX863Z+xk s2LN6zNDiTHtkB/JOTEWSgfkUZi6bZapQWoWT6sPT65MVcPIyFU9Lk6gs6cICms3 OjOQ+1g5bkzOn7FqvmMd57cIFalFt7mZ+pBqTMY/Vf9P8eCE2xGUzs7S5AjLeQzT phoSmEG/WRjUoW7Z+KFqHSWnSb7EDTGb9HBrCIZuMz3ucI8ZkVLlHIoqIX3bqWCy OHBTFBQcR+TY3XPyxNZkDBFaXo1jevFqxqavbbnMz/NwwFTSstXOStzMnrHde8Ut assNVBzaqfhAJci5o9Mk4H88pZnJbhnvhLQcjLlWM2HAAjw22fr6rVJryHPFa9dT pQtCexhSovPadL80SUn9q7EKopvwUA6rNFmgPbNx5vxnQrZTVtCLJuKfpj/EL6gc cJUrwcEU+gyPyZDsle/hvpkgclgbsXeT+ASAu1FSYD3gTCTbJttl4iZxBYcmcPM0 h3u19KovezSvwTVRKIcOFzdYvoC2n9ZjQjG+B+p8UZXUGft+KJP+XudUi9xk7pKI n1OMLISBVyHp51X/HHjf1N+oIeIvlC4id48HfQpa/xZmk2n/DZ/mT4P2oMS6bMCK iMwkvDfPEafpinFvolw/ =xN1f -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----
Received on Wednesday, 2 December 2015 15:51:47 UTC