Fwd: Draft explanatory report for the ISO/IEC TS 30135 EPUB3 revision

---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Yong-Sang Cho <zzosang@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, Jun 11, 2017 at 6:44 PM
Subject: Re: Draft explanatory report for the ISO/IEC TS 30135 EPUB3
revision
To: Bill McCoy <bmccoy@w3.org>
Cc: Toshiko Kimura <kimura@itscj.ipsj.or.jp>, Bill McCoy <whmccoy@gmail.com>,
??? <samoh21@gmail.com>


Dear Bill McCoy

I would like to finalize preparation works for ISO/IEC TS EPUB3 revision
this week. Attached document is very short rationale document for the
revision, and I will post joint working group on EPUB3 soon. Would you
confirm whether can I make draft text (just make pdf from IDPF's web site
with ISO cover page)?

Due to my many preparation on both SC34 and SC36 plenary meetings, if you
send me confirm sign ASAP then it will be very helpful for me.

Best regards

Yong-Sang

--------------------------------------
  한국교육학술정보원
  Korea Education & Research Information Service (KERIS)
--------------------------------------
  조용상  Yong-Sang Cho, Ph.D.
  연구위원  Research Fellow
  Tel +82-53-714-0447 <+82%2053-714-0447>  Fax +82-53-714-0196
<+82%2053-714-0196>
  http://www.keris.or.kr  zzosang@keris.or.kr
  Facebook: zzosang <http://www.facebook.com/zzosang> / Twitter: @zzosang
<http://www.twitter.com/zzosang>
--------------------------------------

2017-05-24 15:55 GMT+09:00 Yong-Sang Cho <zzosang@gmail.com>:

> Dear Bill McCoy and Kimura-san
>
> I just revised Explanatory Report as a introductory meaning for JWG7 as
> attached. Please review the report whether can I post JWG7 document
> registry for recording history of the ISO/IEC TS 30135.
>
> Murata-san
> I think Japanese expert can make comments on PDTS ballot and we can
> discuss whether we forward the comments to Publishing@W3C or defer to
> next version, like a previous manner.
>
> Thanks for your cooperation again.
>
> Best regards
>
> Yong-Sang
>
> --------------------------------------
>   한국교육학술정보원
>   Korea Education & Research Information Service (KERIS)
> --------------------------------------
>   조용상  Yong-Sang Cho, Ph.D.
>   연구위원  Research Fellow
>   Tel +82-53-714-0447 <+82%2053-714-0447>  Fax +82-53-714-0196
> <+82%2053-714-0196>
>   http://www.keris.or.kr  zzosang@keris.or.kr
>   Facebook: zzosang <http://www.facebook.com/zzosang> / Twitter: @zzosang
> <http://www.twitter.com/zzosang>
> --------------------------------------
>
> 2017-05-23 18:19 GMT+09:00 MURATA Makoto <eb2m-mrt@asahi-net.or.jp>:
>
>> I argued for TS for 3.0.1 in Seoul.  But I recently learned that Japanese
>> publishers (e.g., Kadokawa) are concerned about 3.0.1.  This is because
>> some vocabulary prefixes reserved by 3.0.1 are not recognized by some
>> implementations (most notably Apple).  I have to speak with such Japanese
>> publishers, but please forgive me if Japan has to argue against a revised
>> TS
>> for 3.0.1.
>>
>> Regards,
>> Makoto
>>
>> 2017-05-23 16:45 GMT+09:00 Toshiko Kimura <kimura@itscj.ipsj.or.jp>:
>>
>>> Dear Bill,
>>> (I have added Murata-san in cc)
>>>
>>> This is my answer to your two questions.
>>>
>>> - Only one ballot (PDTS) is needed for revision of TS .  It used be two
>>> ballots (PDTS and DTS), but the procedures have changed.
>>>
>>> - The scope of the revision projects approved by SC 34 and JTC 1 is to
>>> align the current TS 30135 to EPUB 3.0.1.Please see below Resolution 9 the
>>> last SC 34 plenary.  Other comments may submitted by ISO/IEC members during
>>> the PDTS ballots, but they can be rejected.
>>>
>>> Resolution 9: Revision of ISO/IEC TS 30135: 2014, Information technology
>>> -- Digital
>>> publishing -- EPUB3 (all parts)
>>>
>>> SC 34 creates sub-projects for a revision of TS 30135 (all parts) and
>>> assigns them to JWG 7
>>> for development. The revision is to address the latest EPUB3 revision
>>> (3.0.1), in which parts 2
>>> and 7 are merged. SC 34 instructs its Secretariat to take the necessary
>>> action to obtain JTC 1
>>> endorsement in accordance with JTC 1 Supplement 2.1.5.4.
>>> Unanimously approved
>>>
>>> Best regards
>>>
>>> Toshiko Kimura
>>>
>>>
>>> On Mon, 22 May 2017 08:14:29 -0700
>>> Bill McCoy <whmccoy@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> Dear Dr. Yong-Sang Cho, Dr. Sam Oh, and Kimura-san,
>>>
>>> Thank you for the email. And, conthe?gratulations and thanks for Korea
>>> adoption of EPUB 3.0.1 as Korean National Standard!?
>>>
>>> Recently the W3C Team and the new W3C EPUB 3 Community Group,
>>> responsible for ongoing development of EPUB 3 under the oversight of W3C
>>> Publishing Business Group, have started discussing about future ISO
>>> standardization. However, the discussion so far has been focused on EPUB
>>> 3.1 not EPUB 3.0.1. So I need to go back to the Team, CG, and BG and
>>> discuss about the EPUB 3.0.1 question. How soon do you need an official
>>> response?
>>>
>>> A few additional questions:
>>>
>>> - we were advised via Makoto Murata that the fast-track procedure has
>>> been eliminated and is no longer available. Assuming this is correct, is
>>> the plan that the proposed EPUB 3.0.1 compatible revision to TS 30135 would
>>> follow the standard procedure (in my understanding this requires two votes,
>>> not one vote)?
>>>
>>> - if we proceed to do revision to ?TS 30135 would the effort for (now
>>> W3C) be similar to the effort by IDPF for doing original TS 30135? In my
>>> understanding this required a) ensuring that ISO/IEC member submitted
>>> defect reports were added to the EPUB github issues, b) ?analysis and
>>> response on these defect reports, c) commitment to address certain defects
>>> in next EPUB revision, and d) attendance at ballot resolution meeting.? As
>>> far as addressing the defects, that was in my understanding fully
>>> accomplished in EPUB 3.0.1 for the original process results. But in this
>>> case we have already an EPUB 3.1 so if there are defect reports submitted
>>> against EPUB 3.0.1 they clearly cannot be addressed in the next revision,
>>> but could potentially be addressed in next-next revision (most likely an
>>> EPUB 3.11 although conceivably an EPUB 3.2 or even a parallel-developed
>>> EPUB 3.0.2).
>>>
>>> If it would be more efficient to have a short conference call to discuss
>>> about these things that would be fine with me.
>>>
>>> Best Regards,
>>>
>>> Bill McCoy
>>> W3C Publishing Champion
>>> bmccoy@idpf.org
>>> +1 206 353 0233 <(206)%20353-0233>
>>>
>>>
>>> On Mon, May 22, 2017 at 12:43 AM, Yong-Sang Cho <zzosang@gmail.com>
>>> wrote:
>>>
>>>> Dear Bill McCoy and Sam Oh
>>>>
>>>> Finally Korea adopt EPUB 3.0.1 as its national standard this month.
>>>> Following same process with current ISO/IEC TS 30135, Korea would like to
>>>> support revision of ISO/IEC TS 30135 to EPUB 3.0.1 in terms of technical
>>>> equivalence with IDPF's specification.?
>>>>
>>>> Due to merge with W3C and IDPF, I made some notes for this situation in
>>>> the explanatory report. JWG7 for EPUB has considered how we take EPUB 3.0.1
>>>> for last two years, and JWG7 invited again Korea to take a role for the
>>>> submission.?
>>>>
>>>> Bill.?
>>>> Please let us know whether we proceed ISO EPUB3 revision with attached
>>>> explanatory report. We are welcome for your any comments or update of
>>>> Publishing@W3C.?
>>>>
>>>> FYI, this document also will be reviewed in JWG7 meeting this week and
>>>> next month.?
>>>>
>>>> Best regards
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Yong-Sang
>>>>
>>>> --------------------------------------
>>>> ? ?????????
>>>> ? Korea Education & Research Information Service (KERIS)
>>>> --------------------------------------
>>>> ? ??? ?Yong-Sang Cho, Ph.D.?
>>>> ? ???? ?Research Fellow
>>>> ? Tel +82-53-714-0447 <+82%2053-714-0447> ?Fax +82-53-714-0196
>>>> <+82%2053-714-0196>?
>>>> ? http://www.keris.or.kr? zzosang@keris.or.kr
>>>> ? Facebook: zzosang <http://www.facebook.com/zzosang> / Twitter:
>>>> @zzosang <http://www.twitter.com/zzosang>
>>>> --------------------------------------
>>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> =========================
>>> 木村 敏子
>>> 一般社団法人 情報処理学会
>>> 情報規格調査会
>>>
>>> 〒105-0011
>>> 東京都港区芝公園3-5-8
>>> 機械振興会館308-3
>>> Tel: 03-3431-2808
>>> Fax: 03-3431-6493
>>> E-mail: kimura@itscj.ipsj.or.jp
>>> =========================
>>>
>>
>>
>>
>> --
>>
>> Praying for the victims of the Japan Tohoku earthquake
>>
>> Makoto
>>
>
>