Showing two rounds/steps of evaluation in the Evaluator page

Hi Ben - and all,

based on today's discussion I've created POE Github Issue 266
(https://github.com/w3c/poe/issues/267) to harmonize how to evaluate a Duty
with consequences.

 

While writing that I concluded we should explicitly tell that some
evaluations need more than 1 step or round:

*	Duty: 
Round 1: the Duty is evaluated without including consequences
IF the state of this evaluation is Not-Fulfilled (because the action was not
exercised) then .
. Round 2: the evaluator checks if the action has been exercised AND the
consequences have been fulfilled. Only then the final state of the Duty is
Fulfilled.
The essential issue is: a round-2-evaluation must know about that as else
having an exercised action is sufficient to set the state to Fulfilled, only
in this 2nd-round case the consequences must be evaluated too.
*	Prohibition: 
Round 1: the Prohibition is evaluated without including remedies
Then the prohibited action has been exercised .
Round 2: The remedies of the Prohibition have to be evaluated and they
should be Fulfilled.

 

I think it would be of great help for the Evaluator page to explicitly show
these steps/rounds:

*	Example 21
The second column, currently without a head, could be headed as "1st
evaluation" and the 5th column with "2nd evaluation"
*	Example 23
Second column heading: "1st duty-evaluation", 4th column: "2nd
duty-evaluation"
*	Example 24: 2nd column heading: "2nd evaluation" or "remedy
evaluation"

 

Thanks for considering that,

Michael