[poe] Issue: revising vocabulary definitions marked as To Be Closed

riannella has just labeled an issue for https://github.com/w3c/poe as "To Be Closed":

== revising vocabulary definitions  ==
The majority of the definitions provided in the current ED of the vocabulary are either inconsistent, unclear or both.

For example: 

| Definition | Comment |
| ------------ | ------------- | 
| <blockquote> 4.1.1 Policy </br>Definition: An entity to capture the statements of the policy</blockquote>| statements == rules? | 
| <blockquote> 4.1.3 Profile</br> Definition: The identifier of an ODRL Profile that this Policy conforms to. </blockquote>|<ul><li>which policy?</li><li>why is Profile prepended with _ODRL_ but Policy isn't?</li><li>**p**olicy (4.1.1) vs. **P**olicy (4.1.3)</li></ul> |
| <blockquote> 4.4.1 Conflict Preference </br> Definition: Is used to resolve conflicts arising from the merging of policies, specifically when there are conflicting Actions in the Permissions and Prohibitions</blockquote>|<ul><li>who has a preference for conflicts at all?</li><li>it doesn't resolve any conflicts at all, but defines the conflict resolution strategy to be used</li><li>>1 conflicting actions in permissions?</li></ul> |
| <blockquote> Comment: Instances of ConflictTerm describe policies for resolving conflicts.</blockquote>| policies as in ODRL policies? -> semantics? | 
| <blockquote> Instances: invalid, perm, prohibit</blockquote>| prohibit is missing | 

etc.


See https://github.com/w3c/poe/issues/74

Received on Friday, 7 July 2017 03:17:05 UTC