Re: [poe] Vocab terms "to an audience"

As I recall the Action vocabulary discussion for ODRL 2.1 the 
intention of Present was to define at a generic level: this action is 
targeting an audience beyond the assignees = the assignee is the party
 presenting the asset to a wider/public/b2c audience. All the other 
sub-terms of "use" are actions in the context of the assignee only. 
And the "real" actions of presenting the asset are the sub-terms of 
Present.
Therefore it is no surprise that taking away the "to a (public) 
audience" leaves a term with small semantics.

The suggested suffix above is unclear and limiting: is playing a MP3 
file covered by "visual or static form", and what exactly is rending 
an asset in static form?
And this raises a basic issue (again): the current ODRL specs do not 
explicitly define that an Asset MUST be digital. (... can ODRL be used
 to grant the display of an artwork from a museum?)

Note on the use of the Recipient constraint. The current language may 
surprise a reader: a _constraint_ should be used to _widen_ the group 
of people using the asset - that's a contradiction at first sight and 
hard to understand. The most bullet proof variant is to claim for 
Present and all its sub-terms that the Recipient (the Assignee or more
 people) must be defined by a constraint.

-- 
GitHub Notification of comment by nitmws
Please view or discuss this issue at 
https://github.com/w3c/poe/issues/101#issuecomment-281037034 using 
your GitHub account

Received on Monday, 20 February 2017 10:05:22 UTC