Re: [meetings] Agenda Request - Review Working Group Charter Changes (#52)

Re: FRAND - The input data must be available to all implementers under the same terms with the same user consent. i.e. browser vendors could not rely on consent captured at installation of the browser for the use of the input data in any specification developed by the group. Developing these details concerning consent is an important next step in the iteration of the charter prior to adoption. By enshrining this in the charter we can ensure all the work of the group meets an agreed requirement just like any other requirement. The fact others find this objectionable is concerning to me. The fact that the charter includes specific proposals to be worked on but no this basic policy principle is equally concerning to me.

Re: Non-technical - I wish to establish the best solutions for the 5bn+ users of the web. Establishing a group that consumes the limited resources of the W3C and our collective energies that explicitly excludes professions other than engineering is limiting. Why should engineers and technology monopolise the solutions? We know from regulators other professions have a role.

Re: Parties - The charter and debate adopts the direction advocated elsewhere concerning parties. For example; only the browser vendor can process the input data, or the cross-site limitations. There are even issues concerning this here. Therefore the parties issue is present throughout the document. Please see the extensive note I posted after yesterday's meeting for details on why this is problematic.

Re: 'Privacy Principles' - Thank you for recognising the state of the document, there should be no issue amending the document o state that the group is not bound by the position of any documents or work that are not explicitly listed in the charter or the W3C Process. Do we agree?

-- 
GitHub Notification of comment by jwrosewell
Please view or discuss this issue at https://github.com/patcg/meetings/issues/52#issuecomment-1162806238 using your GitHub account


-- 
Sent via github-notify-ml as configured in https://github.com/w3c/github-notify-ml-config

Received on Wednesday, 22 June 2022 08:27:46 UTC