Re: New editor's draft uploaded

In Collation section

(1)
Perhaps the marked character is repeated by mistake???

[image: Inline image 1]
(2)


Sanskrit scholars vote for Collation order with क् at beginning, as क् =
क-(minus)अ sound.

So syllables with halant (्) U094D must came before the character without
it. As syllables with U094D has lower weight.

And कँ कं कः are vowel modifiers, are used normally after maatraa.

(3)

Some syllables missed in the above sort order of Consonant 'क'

So the full sort order should be like this:

क् क का कि की कु कू कृ कॄ कॢ कॣ कॅ कॆ के कै कै कॉ कॊ को कौ

कँ काँ किँ कीँ कुँ कूँ कृँ कॄँ कॢँ कॣँ कॅँ कॆँ केँ कैँ कैँ कॉँ कॊँ कोँ कौँ

कं कां किं कीं कुं कूं कृं कॄं कॢं कॣं कॅं कॆं कें कैं कैं कॉं कॊं कों कौं

कः काः किः कीः कुः कूः कृः कॄः कॢः कॣः कॅः कॆः केः कैः कैः कॉः कॊः कोः कौः

क़ क़ा क़ि क़ी क़ु क़ू क़ृ क़ॄ क़ॢ क़ॣ क़ॅ क़ॆ क़े क़ै क़ै क़ॉ क़ॊ क़ो क़ौ

क़ँ क़ाँ क़िँ क़ीँ क़ुँ क़ूँ क़ृँ क़ॄँ क़ॢँ क़ॣँ क़ॅँ क़ॆँ क़ेँ क़ैँ क़ैँ क़ॉँ क़ॊँ क़ोँ क़ौँ

क़ं क़ां क़िं क़ीं क़ुं क़ूं क़ृं क़ॄं क़ॢं क़ॣं क़ॅं क़ॆं क़ें क़ैं क़ैं क़ॉं क़ॊं क़ों क़ौं

क़ः क़ाः क़िः क़ीः क़ुः क़ूः क़ृः क़ॄः क़ॢः क़ॣः क़ॅः क़ॆः क़ेः क़ैः क़ैः क़ॉः क़ॊः क़ोः क़ौः

(4)

As written in the draft

"The order(left to right) as given below is pertinent to sorting by a
computer program and is compliant with CLDR as laid down by Unicode."

And given in the following collation chart.

How the Nukta (़) U093C kept at beginning? Any reason for this? Whereas
characters with Nukta have higher weight.

with regards.

हरिराम
प्रगत भारत <http://hariraama.blogspot.com>

On Thu, Nov 27, 2014 at 10:28 PM, Richard Ishida <ishida@w3.org> wrote:

> A new editor's draft of Indic Layout Requirements, dated 27 November 2014,
> is available at http://www.w3.org/International/docs/indic-layout/

>
> Comments welcome.
>
> I will ask the i18n WG to review it with a view to moving to First Public
> Working Draft.
>
> ri
>
>