XForms Working Group Resolutions and Outstanding Action items

Resolutions
Description Date Created Open Action Items References
Move the events attributes to Common and remove them from individual elements 2005-01-13 Resolution 2005-01-13.1
Remove the labels "susbstantive" and "clarification" from the XForms 1.0 errata document. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.4
E61 the setindex element, change 1 to startindex 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.5
The point that rewiring occurrs needs to be specifically defined, so that dynamic UI bindings happen properly. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.6
All the events that are dispatched in revalidate must therefore (in relation to Resolution 2005-06-15.6) be moved into refresh, since they have to happen after rewiring. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.7
move XVC to be a ui notification event and reflect in the erratum wording (E70a). 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.8
A future version of XForms will include a set of events that notify the state of the model, and whose target is not a form control. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.9
Drop erratum E48. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.13
No proposals or counter proposals without near spec. ready text from proposers. 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.14
Document resolutions to be incorporated as part of the actions document 2005-06-15 Resolution 2005-06-15.15
will use old E70B text 2005-06-23 Resolution 2005-06-23.1
not accepted E29 2005-06-23 Resolution 2005-06-23.2
Include the id function from XPath 2.0 in XForms 1.1 2005-07-14 Resolution 2005-07-14.1
Replace action accepted for XForms 1.1 as is (see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2005AprJun/0012) 2005-07-14 Resolution 2005-07-14.2
XForms 1.1 make ampersand default separator in submission (see: http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2005JanMar/0192) 2005-07-14 Resolution 2005-07-14.3
Add pattern MIP and regular expression functions from XPath 2.0 (http://www.w3.org/TR/xquery-operators/#string.match) to XForms 1.1 2005-09-08 Action 2005-09-08.1 Resolution 2005-09-08.1
The default behviour is for alert to be presented to the user if its parent form control is invalid and available. 2005-09-08 Action 2005-09-08.7 Resolution 2005-09-08.2
After consideration of http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2004OctDec/0141 it was decided that there will be no model attribute on <close/> as close closes the entire user agent and the model attribute might mislead an author. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.3
Add an erratum to XForms 1.0 stating that all cases exist whether or not active. Events are not dispatched to controls in non-selected cases. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.4
Add a confirm action to XForms 1.1 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.5
Implement dialogue like functionality by introducing modal attribute and appearance="popup" on the group element in XForms 1.1 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.6
Add conditional actions to XForms 1.1 by adding the functionality decribed in http://www.exforms.org/udviddelse.html#conloop (if, while, iterate and invoke). 2005-09-08 Action 2005-09-08.13 Resolution 2005-09-08.7
XForms 1.1 Add set of simple data types to the XForms namespace that are a union of xsd: data types and empty string (allows empty values to be valid). 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.8
Take DOM approach to defining a submission spec. 2005-09-08 Action 2005-09-08.18 Resolution 2005-09-08.9
Erratum to section XForms 1.0, 11.1 to make clear that an empty nodeset on submission results in a submit-error. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.10
Accept as an erratum to XForms 1.0 the proposed wording in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2005JulSep/0000 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.11
Remove the empty bind from test 3.3.2d 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.12
create test for <bind nodeset="x"><bind calculate=".."/></bind> after erratum is published 2005-09-08 Action 2005-09-08.28 Resolution 2005-09-08.13
Remove test 3.5.1.b from test suite 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.14
rewrite test case 4.6.3.a to use two models. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.15
Fix test 6.1.3.b by building a schema to make schema valid the instance element with the xsi:nill attribute. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.16
New erratum for 6.1.4 - change "should be hidden or unavailable" to "must make hidden or unavailable" to match the table at end of the section. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.17
erratum to XForms 1.0, 10.1.2. to bring the spec. into line with the schema, which says that the default value of @bubbles is "true". 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.18
rewrite test 11.1.a to show that you can't have more than one instance of a single submission going simultaneously. 2005-09-08 Resolution 2005-09-08.19
Generate new rev. of the XForms 1.1 thin spec. to reflect changes to 1.1 agreed at the Raleigh FtF (Sept 2005). 2005-09-22 Resolution 2005-09-22.1
Remove iterate from 1.1 2005-10-20 Resolution 2005-10-20.1
Adopt John's approach to updating insert for XForms 1.1 instead of using duplicate. 2005-10-20 Resolution 2005-10-20.2
Erratum E66f remove example and immediately preceding para of 9.3.2 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.1
Do change namespace for XForms 1.1 as already agreed. 2005-11-09 Action 2005-11-09.7 Resolution 2005-11-09.2
choose() function with the 2nd and 3rd parameters being of type object. The type of object controls the type of output, and rules of comparisons in terms of downcasting 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.3
getElementById() function becomes id() again to align with XPath 2.0 and is defined to be able to return more than one node from a specified nodeset 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.4
XForms 1.1 add replace action to allow a whole document to be replaced by another (<replace ref="" origin=""/>). 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.5
replace "confirm" proposal with proposal for prompt in XForms 1.1 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.6
appearance="compact" on xforms:repeat should cause the repeat to be rendered as a table, using the labels of the first row (direct children of the repeat only) as column headers. 2005-11-09 Action 2005-11-09.20 Resolution 2005-11-09.7
Define use of method="put" when submitting to a local file store so that the instance put immediately replaces that currently in the form, unless replace="none" 2005-11-09 Action 2005-11-09.23 Resolution 2005-11-09.8
XForms 1.0 erratum to state that when cases are toggled the xforms:deselect event is fired after a case is deselected, but before the new case is selected, so that the deslected case receives the xforms:deselect event. 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.9
XForms 1.1: presentation="minimal" on a trigger is a hint to make look like text 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.10
XForms 1.1 add serialize="false" on submission. 2005-11-09 Resolution 2005-11-09.11
We remove chameleon namespaces and don't replace them with anything. 2006-01-31 Resolution 2006-01-31.1
Include XSLT document containing transform from XHTML 1.0 to XForms 1.0 in the XForms 1.0 document set. 2006-03-02 Resolution 2006-03-02.1
Add help and hint to item and choices even though they can't yet be added to itemset until the way templating constructs work has been better documented. 2006-03-02 Resolution 2006-03-02.2
use the 1.0 namespace URI as _the_ XForms namespace URI for 1.1 2006-03-02 Resolution 2006-03-02.3
Devise internal versioning mechanism within XForms 1.1 to distinguishing 1.0 and 1.1 without having to use different namespaces. 2006-03-02 Action 2006-03-02.8 Resolution 2006-03-02.4
Remove note from 7.3.3 for 1.0 2nd Edition 2006-03-02 Resolution 2006-03-02.5
XForms 1.1 - help/hint have the default behaviour of ev:propagate="stop" to prevent more than one help/hint being presented to a user at once. 2006-04-26 Action 2006-04-26.1 Resolution 2006-04-26.1
XForms 1.1 help/hint allowed as children of itemset. 2006-04-26 Action 2006-04-26.2 Resolution 2006-04-26.2
A load action defined using single node binding that does not point to a node fails silently. 2006-05-31 Resolution 2006-05-31.1
XForms 1.0, Full: The type model item property can be applied to both elements and attributes. The type model item property is not applied to instance nodes that contain child elements. The type model item property associates a datatype (bib ref to XML schema part 2) with the string value (bib ref XPath 1) of an instance node. The datatype being associated can be obtained from: a simpleType definition; the simpleContent definition of a complexType. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.1
Add generalising the context attribute as part of binding single and nodeset binding, and use of lone model [to allow the setting of context without ref] to the future requirements document. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.2
Manipulation of submission headers to be added to 1.1 submission ( http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2006Apr/0004) 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.3
Tracking submission desirable for a future version of XForms once there is implementation experience ( http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2006JanMar/0372). 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.4
XForms 1.1, event context. The event() function to return an XML document fragment containing the context for the current event. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.5
Providing the means to cancel a submission at runtime added to requirements for future versions of XForms. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.6
XForms 1.1: Don't deprecate urlencoded-post submission. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.7
XForms 1.1: include the DELETE HTTP method as part of submission. 2006-06-14 Action 2006-06-14.13 Resolution 2006-06-14.8
XForms 1.1 has two submission modes, asynchronous and synchronous. The desried mode is indicated by adding a mode attribute to submission. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.9
Asynchronous is the default submisison mode for XForms 1.1. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.10
XForms 1.1 Synchronous submission mode: the XForms processor suspends operation [provide examples] of all its form controls and XForms-submit default processing blocks until submit-done/submit-error are completed 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.11
XForms 1.1: Dynamic submission to be expressed by giving the submission element the following child elements: <resource ref/value=""/> <header name/ref/value="">or content</header> 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.12
XForms 1.1 load to support the resource and header elements defined for dynamic submission. 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.13
add optional id attribute to common attributes in XForms 1.0 schema 2006-06-14 Resolution 2006-06-14.14
Put the Read Only issue with mixed content on hold, until mixed content is solved 2006-07-19 Resolution 2006-07-19.1
Set Value with XPath to a non existing node will NO OP 2006-07-19 Resolution 2006-07-19.2
Publish XForms 1.0 Second Edition Errata on July 12th, 2006 2006-07-5 Resolution 2006-07-5.1
Publish current draft of XForms 1.1 thin spec on July 12th, 2006 2006-07-5 Resolution 2006-07-5.2
We use the XPath data model and so ancestor includes attributes. 2006-08-02 Action 2006 08 02.2 Resolution 2006 08 02.1
We should consider a global instance as part of the future requirement for cross-model communication. 2006-08-09 Resolution 2006 08 09.1
Publish http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/Sources/REC-xforms-10-2ndEdition-errata.html by copying these contents into http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/Sources/REC-xforms-10-2ndEdition-errata.html Copy the old contents to REC-xforms-20060314-errata-20060712.html or other name agreed to by John and Steven to preserve link to "previous version" of errata. 2006-09-06 Resolution 2006-09-6.1
The HTML and Forms Working Groups resolve that all versions of XHTML may be delivered using the Internet media Type text/html. 2006-09-13 http://www.w3.org/2006/09/13-xforms-minutes.html#action01 Resolution 2006-09-13.1
The Forms Working Group resolves to modularizes XForms according to XHTML Modularization 1.1, and to include in that module implicit data model support for form controls consistent with XHTML 1.1. 2006-09-13 Resolution 2006-09-13.1
The HTML Working Group resolves to publish an XHTML Modularisation 1.1 Profile that includes: the XForms M12N module mentioned in the above resolution, XML Events, RDFa, Role, and if possible the access module and enhancement for tabindex to support accessibility. 2006-09-13 Resolution 2006-09-13.1
The HTML Working Group resolves to publish this profile as the basis for the next generation of HTML, XHTML 1.2. 2006-09-13 Resolution 2006-09-13.1
Start having telecons on the week after the face-to-face meetings 2006-09-14 Resolution 2006-09-14.1
Define Simplified XForms module for XHTML 1.2 rec track. Done by Forms WG independently of XForms 1.1 for use only with XHTML. May consider merge of some features into core XForms after 1.1. 2006-09-14 Resolution 2006-09-14.2
XForms group will use shane's system for issue handling 2006-09-14 http://www.w3.org/2006/09/14-xforms-minutes.html#action07 Resolution 2006-09-14.3
Headers as children of submission or load: <header [nodeset]><name [value]><value [value]></header>*, where name and value can use content if the value attribute is not given 2006-09-14 Resolution 2006-09-14.4
Add to submission target attribute and replace="text" as described above. 2006-09-14 Resolution 2006-09-14.5
Mediatype (or its default) sets default content-type header for http-based submissions, and use of header element overrides 2006-09-15 Resolution 2006-09-15.1
Mediatype (or its default) affects the serialization. The default serialization is still given by the method attribute, but it is overridden by mediatype. 2006-09-15 Resolution 2006-09-15.2
Add attribute and child element 'verb' to submission element 2006-09-15 Resolution 2006-09-15.3
Postpone value attribute on output element to xforms 1.2 2006-09-15 Resolution 2006-09-15.4
When using xf-output, interaction between the rendered content and the containing document is undefined. 2006-09-15 Resolution 2006-09-15.5
We will not add a calculate attribute to output or other controls in XForms 1.1. 2006-10-04 Resolution 2006-10-4.1
We get rid of xforms-link-exception under 4.6.1 The xforms-submit Event. 2006-10-11 Resolution 2006-10-11.1
We remove from 1.1 the application of help/hint to item and choices. 2006-10-11 Resolution 2006-10-11.2
Make level attribute optional on message action in 1.1. 2006-10-11 Resolution 2006-10-11.3
We change hash-encode() to digest(). 2006-10-18 Resolution 2006-10-18.1
Publish http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/1.1/thinspec/index.html as next Working Draft as soon as possible. 2006-11-01 Resolution 2006-11-01.1
XForms 1.1 attribute submission on send and submit is optional and defaults to the first submission in the model associated with the in-scope context node. Dispatch to be re-written to say it is not just a shorthand. 2006-11-01 Resolution 2006-11-01.2
Have further errata for XForms 1.0 to clarify that when the model is not specify on rebuild/revalidate/recalculate/refresh, then the model is the one associated with the in-scope evaluation context node. 2006-11-01 Resolution 2006-11-01.3
We accept the change to E17 as: A binding element is "outermost" if the element has no ancestor binding elements. If the outermost binding element is contained by a model element, then the context node for the element is the top-level document element node of the default instance of the containing model. Otherwise, the context node for outermost binding elements is the top-level document element node of the default instance in the default model. The context size and position are 1. 2006-11-08 Resolution 2006-11-08.1
Consolidate valid/invalid notification marking into one bullet as is done for notification events in recalculate. Add to each notification event marking bullet a sentence which says "Only one of the two events can be marked for dispatch at any time." 2006-11-15 Resolution 2006-11-15.1
Withdraw E14 and publish new erratum saying model-construct "Performs the behavior of xforms-rebuild, xforms-recalculate, and xforms-revalidate without dispatching events." Do this at the same time as we move the bind processing into rebuild. 2006-11-15 Resolution 2006-11-15.2
We with draw E1.1 and re-issue it with "otherwise the size of the homogeneous collection if it contains fewer than startindex items." 2006-11-15 Resolution 2006-11-15.3
We remove in 7.10.6 "In either case, the time time zone is omitted, the time zone is omitted from the return result." and add an example substring(local-date(), 1,10) returns 2006-11-13. 2006-11-15 Resolution 2006-11-15.4
We remove the xforms-close event because it would be too much work to specify how to handle multiple models and we keep the discussion in mind for a future version. 2006-11-16 Resolution 2006-11-16.1
The Forms WG adopts Dave Raggett's Forms Lite Proposal as a starting point for discussions leading to the FPWD for XForms Tiny. 2006-11-16 Resolution 2006-11-16.2
Forms Tiny developed by the Forms WG will be renamed XForms Tiny. 2006-11-16 Resolution 2006-11-16.3
Dave Raggett to become to the Lead of the Development Effort of XForms Tiny within the Forms WG. 2006-11-16 Resolution 2006-11-16.4
Make nodeset optional on insert, if not specified then equal behavior to empty nodeset result. If at attribute not specified on delete, then delete whole nodeset. Do not apply first node rule to origin attribute. Insert inserts all nodes identified by origin. time box to two weeks from now to complete spec. 2006-11-16 Resolution 2006-11-16.5
When a form control goes from enabled to disabled, whether by relevance or node disappearance, we send xforms-disabled. When a form control goes from disabled to enabled, whether by relevance or node appearance (through any means including but not necessarily limited to insert, submission instance replacements, or getInstance() based scripted DOM mutation), the markup-based event handlers are hooked up and the following events are sent: xforms-enabled, xforms-value-changed, one of xforms-valid or xforms-invalid, one of xforms-readonly or xforms-readwrite, one of xforms-required or xforms-optional, one of xforms-in-range or xforms-out-of-range. 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.1
We add this to group: "All content elements (e.g. form controls, groups, switches, repeats and host language content) within a non-relevant group are handled as non-relevant. When a group becomes non-relevant, it must receive event xforms-disabled and then the XForms action handlers that are listening for events on the non-relevant group must be disabled. When a non-relevant group changes to being relevant, the XForms action handlers that listen for events on the group must become enabled and then the group must receive the event xforms-enabled." 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.2
The attribute value for the type attribute is interpreted as QName. When the name has no namespace prefix, then the default namespace URI in context is used. 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.3
We add a future requirement to allow the results of calculate be to cast according to assigned data type perhaps with cast functions that are used automatically, or use XPath 2.0. 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.4
We accept the id() function editorial note. 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.5
We do not issue a note about specically causing model/@version to fail, because it should anyway. 2006-11-17 Resolution 2006-11-17.6
We publish the XForms 1.1 full spec after moving patent policy to reflect current status (2002). 2006-11-29 Resolution 2006-11-29.1
We remove dashes from the id card and luhn example and include a note. 2006-11-29 Resolution 2006-11-29.2
We remove the erratum http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2006Nov/0088.html from XForms 1.0 SE from XForms 1.0 TE. 2006-11-29 Resolution 2006-11-29.3
In 8.3.4 and 8.3.5 we strike the "equivalent to" sentences, leaving xforms-help and xforms-hint as interaction events with default processing. 2006-12-12 Resolution 2006-12-12.1
We move forward to publish an XForms 1.0 TE PER based on the existing errata. 2007-01-17 Action 2007-01-17.1 Resolution 2007-01-17.1
The XForms Working Group congratulates Mikko Honkala on getting his PhD. 2007-01-17 Resolution 2007-01-17.2
We continue to work on multi-node insert and delete for 1.1. 2007-01-24 Resolution 2007-01-24.1
There will be a Modularization call next week; please join the #xforms IRC channel as well. 2007-02-07 Resolution 2007-02-07.1
We take our current draft of XForms 1.1 to last call, with the inclusion of a non-normative example for output and updates for dates and status. 2007-02-07 Resolution 2007-02-07.2
We resolve to provide comments on XBL 2.0 last call. 2007-02-07 Resolution 2007-02-07.3
We do not add string-compare to XForms 1.1 2007-02-14 Resolution 2007-02-14.1
We temporarily call the new thing XForms Transitional, giving it a few days thought. 2007-02-21 Resolution 2007-02-21.1
We keep XForms 2.0 and keep XForms Simplification and Transitional as the milestone for what was going to be called 1.2. 2007-02-21 Resolution 2007-02-21.2
We forward issues as they are discussed during the call to xforms-issues@mn.aptest.com and have no single captain. 2007-02-28 Resolution 2007-02-28.1
We continue to use Shane's system for keeping track of XForms 1.1 comments. 2007-03-07 Resolution 2007-03-07.1
We accept erratum on propose erratum text for for Commit value on DOMActivate (enter) on input and select1/select selection=open. 2007-03-08 Action 2007-03-08.1 Resolution 2007-03-08.1
Context information for user defined events is a future feature. 2007-03-14 Resolution 2007-03-14.1
Extend the LC period to the end of April 2007-04-04 Resolution 2007-04-04.1
We continue using the emailed minutes. 2007-04-18 Resolution 2007-04-18.1

Outstanding Action Items

Klaas Bals
Description Date Created Status References
Allan Beaufour
Description Date Created Status References
Mark Birbeck
Description Date Created Status References
MarkB to send LC comments to introduce a global attribute for versioning as an improvement [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action07] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action07
Leigh Klotz and Mark Birbeck to handleAppendix F.3 example http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2003Aug/0003.html 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.7
Mark Birbeck to suggest to www-forms-editor that submission/@validate and @relevant default to whatever @serialize is set to. 2007-02-28 open Action 2007-02-28.4
Steven Pemberton and Mark Birbeck to meet Thursday 2/15 to finish XTech calls for paper 2007-02-14 open Action 2007-02-14.1
ebruchez and MarkB to address the additional use cases, and reflect them with the current architecture, present a solution until Aug 15th 2006-06-28 open Action 2006-06-28.1
MarkB to track the task force on access control. 2006-03-02 open Action 2006-03-02.5
MarkB and TV Raman to develop submission spec. taking DOM approach. 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.18
Mark B. to post XHTML2 schema 2005-07-07 open Action 2005-07-07.1
MarkB to define E12 (refresh can go to any bound node (section 4.3.4)) goes into XForms 1.1 as new feature 2005-04-14 open Action 2005-04-14.1
MarkB to find an example of a nested bind in spec. (in the context of erratum E48a, for section 3.2.3) 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.7
Mark to write up resolutions for switch in repeat: For id inside repeat, the context is the current row inside a repeat. If you have a listener on something within a repeat, then that doesn't exhibit the dynamic behaviour of repeat, it only gets attached to the first thingie in the repeat. When you register listeners on something inside a repeat, it gets registered on every instantiation within the repeat. 2005-02-28 open Action 2005-02-28.43
markb, tv to write-up proposal: Allow more complex use-cases for messages. 2004-12-16 open http://www.w3.org/2004/12/16-xforms-irc#T15-57-06
Action Mark to try and find more material on what precedences (sp?) there are for focus changing as controls become available or hidden. 2004-12-02 open http://www.w3.org/2004/12/02-xforms-irc#T15-46-00
Action Mark strawman draft of hasFeature for 1.1 [1] 2004-12-02 open http://www.w3.org/2004/12/02-xforms-irc#T15-27-35
Mark to propose a new function for copying structures from instances in one model to an instance in another model. 2004-11-12 open Action 2004-11-12.5
Mark to write erratum that meets Steven's use case and may look something like: "The RFC 2396 requires that we explain how relative URLs are resolved in the absense of a base URL. The URL created will be processor specific, but it should be consistent." but may equally not. 2004-11-11 open Action 2004-11-11.15
Take sXBL more seriously. MarkB give intro/tutorial on sXBL 2004-11-10 open Action 2004-11-10.4
Action Raman, Steven, MarkB? : get XML handlers out the door [6] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-59-18
MarkB to write a proposal for an xforms-submit-document-received event. 2004-09-10 open Action 2004-09-10.8
MarkB Add feature request for 1.1 to remove restriction on homogenous collections and to investigate impact on insert, etc. 2004-09-10 open Action 2004-09-10.4
Mark to write up proposal for change event. 2004-08-19 open Action 2004-08-19.4
markB to create a write-up for namespaces and processors issue [4] 2004-03-05 open http://www.w3.org/2004/03/05-xforms-irc#T12-50-52
Action MB to write how webdav support could be specified [1] 2003-11-07 open http://www.w3.org/2003/11/07-xforms-irc#T16-29-09
John Boyer
Description Date Created Status References
John to alphabetise the glossary. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/25-forms-minutes.html#action02] 2007-04-25 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/25-forms-minutes.html#action02
John will start a thread on the list so as to arrive at a LC response to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2007Mar/0003.html] 2007-04-25 open http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2007Mar/0003.html
John Boyer to handle QName-but-not-NCName http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2003Aug/0002.html 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.6
John Boyer to XForms 1.1 version without diffmarks for processing post-LC comments. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.5
John Boyer to make editors-drafts available. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.4
John Boyer do propose erratum text for for Commit value on DOMActivate (enter) on input and select1/select selection=open. 2007-03-08 open Action 2007-03-08.1
John Boyer to fix both the submission/bind sentence and clarify the definitions themselves to make it clear that even if not all attributes are available they definition still applies. http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2007Feb/0004.html 2007-02-28 open Action 2007-02-28.5
John Boyer to fix typo in 29.1http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2007JanMar/0090.html 2007-02-28 open Action 2007-02-28.3
John and Steven to approach the organizer of the XML Conference in Boston about an XForms day/track. 2007-02-28 open Action 2007-02-28.1
John Boyer to write status section for XForms 1.0 TE PER based on existing errata. 2007-01-17 open Action 2007-01-17.1
John to write erratum for XForms 1.0 to change revalidate to say that only data values get revalidated (and presumably to also make clear that full schema validation is performed on submission) ( http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2006May/0156.html ) . 2006-05-31 open Action 2006-05-31.5
Erik Bruchez
Description Date Created Status References
ebruchez and MarkB to address the additional use cases, and reflect them with the current architecture, present a solution until Aug 15th 2006-06-28 open Action 2006-06-28.1
Micah Dubinko
Description Date Created Status References
Darrell Dykstra
Description Date Created Status References
XForms Spec. Editors
Description Date Created Status References
Mikko Honkala
Description Date Created Status References
Masayasu Ishikawa
Description Date Created Status References
Kevin Kelly
Description Date Created Status References
Leigh Klotz
Description Date Created Status References
Leigh Klotz to add http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2004Jan/0004.html to the futures wiki and respond to Bjoern Hoehrrmann. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.8
Leigh Klotz and Mark Birbeck to handleAppendix F.3 example http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2003Aug/0003.html 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.7
Leigh to send the existing implementation report to Kenneth and David and ask them for any updates, then republish it as XForms 1.0 Basic Implementation Report. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.1
Leigh Klotz to produce XForms 1.0 implementation report. 2007-03-07 open Action 2007-03-07.1
Leigh to respond to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2007Mar/0051.html 2007-03-28 open Action 2007-03-28.2
Leigh Klotz to forward http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2007JanMar/0124.html to www-forms-editor as XForms 1.1 last call comment. 2007-03-14 open Action 2007-03-14.5
Leigh Klotz to send Steven Pemberton F2F details. 2007-01-17 open Action 2007-01-17.2
Leigh to write draft text for note on issue http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2006JulSep/0236.html separating presentation from lexical. 2006-11-29 open Action 2006-11-29.2
Leigh to respond to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2006Aug/0102.html and implementers to respond with opinions if desired. 2006-09-06 open Action 2006-09-6.2
Leigh and Steven to publish XForms 1.0 Basic. 2006-09-06 open Action 2006-09-6.1
Leigh will focus on getting the submission stuff in 2006-06-28 open Action 2006-06-28.2
Leigh to help MarkB and Jan with XForms 1.1 schema 2006-06-14 open Action 2006-06-14.17
Leigh to add context information for DELETE method to xforms-submit-done and xforms-submit-error. 2006-06-14 open Action 2006-06-14.13
Leigh to post F2F details to W3C forms as they aren't on the page yet. 2006-01-31 open Action 2006-01-31.1
Jan Kratky
Description Date Created Status References
Jan to send a response to Bjoern on the issues raised in email http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-archive/2003Aug/0000.html] 2007-04-25 open http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-archive/2003Aug/0000.html
Jan Kratky to provide support for XForms 1.0 Basic Profile test suite feature list. 2007-03-07 open Action 2007-03-07.2
Jan Kratky to upload XForms 1.1 schema files to location indicated in the draft 2007-02-07 open Action 2007-02-07.1
Jan Kratky to update schema for XForms 1.1 thin spec changes. 2006 08 16 open Action 2006 08 16.2
Jan to review current version of chameleon schemas created by MarkB. 2006-03-02 open Action 2006-03-02.9
Jan to work to document mechanism to achieve an internal versioning mechanism for XForms 1.1 based on profile="xforms 1.1 svg 1.2" solution/hasFeature/CDF work. 2006-03-02 open Action 2006-03-02.8
Jan to create test for <bind nodeset="x"><bind calculate=".."/></bind> after erratum is published 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.28
Jan to do more research on where it is appropriate for <ev:listener> to be allowed. 2005-02-28 open Action 2005-02-28.24
Action Jan will move <message> out of actions but is not yet sure where to. 2004-12-02 open http://www.w3.org/2004/12/02-xforms-irc#T15-32-31
David Landwehr
Description Date Created Status References
David Landwehr to send mail to www-forms and public-xforms about PicoForms' experience with implementing XForms Basic. 2007-03-07 open Action 2007-03-07.3
David to propose erratum about dispatching MIPS from inheritance [ http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2006Feb/0002] 2006-07-05 open Action 2006-07-5.8
David to make proposal for an erratum to describe the connection between index and focus [ http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2006Mar/0010] it time for Aug 15th 2006 2006-07-05 open Action 2006-07-5.6
David Landwehr to send to mailing list example of issues with allowing bind() function in UI binding. 2006-01-31 open Action 2006-01-31.3
David to look at extensibility of actions/conditions to scripting. 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.15
Roland Merrick
Description Date Created Status References
Lars Oppermann
Description Date Created Status References
Lars Opperman to ask CDF representative about whether mustUnderstand is a topic that CDF is likely to take on. 2006-12-13 open Action 2006-12-13.1
Lars to check on Hamburg for Sept 2006-09-14 open http://www.w3.org/2006/09/14-xforms-minutes.html#action03
Lars/Sebastian to write proposal for expected behaviour and respond to David [8] Note: This is about interpretation of ref indication empty nodeset or non-relevant node in message, help, hint, alert and label. 2006-05-10 open Action 2006-05-10.8
XForms 1.1 - Lars to alter the spec/schema to indicate that help/hint are allowed as children of itemset. 2006-04-26 open Action 2006-04-26.2
XForms 1.1 - Lars to update spec for help/hint to say help/hint have the default behaviour of ev:propagate="stop" to prevent more than one help/hint being presented to a user at once. 2006-04-26 open Action 2006-04-26.1
Lars to document the XForms 1.0 processing model using a formal method as described at W3C Tech plenary, March 2006 2006-03-02 open Action 2006-03-02.2
Steven Pemberton
Description Date Created Status References
Action Steven: XForms 2005 open
Steven to install new FtF page [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/11-forms-minutes.html#action02] 2007-04-11 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/11-forms-minutes.html#action02
steven to ask shane to change name of working group in issue tracking system [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/11-forms-minutes.html#action01] 2007-04-11 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/11-forms-minutes.html#action01
John move PR version of XForms basic to the public space [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action06] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action06
Steven to increase slots on zakim [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action05] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action05
Steven setup phone call for XForms Basic 1.0 (including John and David) [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action04] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action04
Steven change our code to FORMS on zakim [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action02] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action02
Steven to see what should be done to add a link to 'Forms' on www.w3.org [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action01] 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2007/04/04-xforms-minutes.html#action01
Steven Update http://www.w3.org/2002/Forms/Activity.html 2007-04-04 open http://www.w3.org/2002/Forms/Activity.html
Steven Pemberton to investigate locking writes on the public wiki and limiting them to members. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.2
Steven Pemberton to ask Shane to reset http://htmlwg.mn.aptest.com/cgi-bin/xforms-issues/ issues. 2007-03-28 open Action 2007-03-28.1
Steven Pemberton to confirm dates/policy for transition to public with Ian Jacobs. 2007-03-21 open Action 2007-03-21.1
Steven Pemberton to convert home page to public with news blog. 2007-03-14 open Action 2007-03-14.2
Steven Pemberton to ask Ian Jacobs about when the group becomes public and when the member signup period ends. 2007-03-14 open Action 2007-03-14.1
John and Steven to approach the organizer of the XML Conference in Boston about an XForms day/track. 2007-02-28 open Action 2007-02-28.1
Steven to discuss patent policy with Ian Jacobs. 2007-02-21 open Action 2007-02-21.2
Steven Pemberton to put XTech XForms Day plan into action (talk to the people). 2007-02-21 open Action 2007-02-21.1
Steven Pemberton and Mark Birbeck to meet Thursday 2/15 to finish XTech calls for paper 2007-02-14 open Action 2007-02-14.1
Steven Pemberton to send draft CFP for XForms Conference at XTech to the people who want to be involved. 2007-01-10 open Action 2007-01-10.1
Steven to publish errata document as described in http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2006OctDec/0252.html 2006-12-12 open Action 2006-12-12.4
Steven to send draft call for papers for XTech XForms Conference to list. 2006-12-12 open Action 2006-12-12.3
Steven to update next F2F with info from Leigh to come in email. 2006-12-12 open Action 2006-12-12.1
Steven to publish XForms Basic WD in group space. 2006-11-08 open Action 2006-11-08.1
Steven to request publication on http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/1.1/thinspec/index.html for a publication date of November 3rd. 2006-11-01 open Action 2006-11-01.2
Leigh and Steven to publish XForms 1.0 Basic. 2006-09-06 open Action 2006-09-6.1
Steven to ask for public Wiki having post limited to valid account (any w3c account). 2006-09-27 open Action 2006-09-27.4
Steven to publish http://www.w3.org/MarkUp/Forms/Group/Drafts/Sources/REC-xforms-10-2ndEdition-errata-diff.html by rename to a date-oriented name. 2006-09-20 open Action 2006-09-20.2
Steven to see about migrating Shane's issue tracking system to W3C servers and email addresses 2006-09-14 open http://www.w3.org/2006/09/14-xforms-minutes.html#action07
Steven Pemberton to suggest in response to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2006Jul/0027 that this request should be made to the XML Schema WG. 2006-08-02 open Action 2006 08 02.5
Steven to respond to David Landwehr that we use the XPath data model and so ancestor includes attributes. 2006-08-02 open Action 2006 08 02.2
Steven to reply to mixed content value message. 2006 07 26 open Action 2006 07 26.2
Steven to add Kurt Cagle links to the XForms home page and investigate http://www.xforms.org. 2006 07 26 open Action 2006 07 26.1
Steven to find who can provide an answer to http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2006Apr/0000. 2006-05-31 open Action 2006-05-31.3
Steven to repond to emails (http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2005Oct/0001.html, http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2005Oct/0001.html,about namespace change for XForms 1.1. 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.7
Steven to write up method="put" when submitting to a local file store so that the instance put immediately replaces that currently in the form, unless replace="none" 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.23
Steven to write up appearance="compact" (xforms:repeat should cause the repeat to be rendered as a table, using the labels of the first row (direct children of the repeat only) as column headers). 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.20
Steven to check the list of WG participants, especially for IBM employees. 2005-09-22 open Action 2005-09-22.1
Steven to talk to MarkB about creating an RFC for XML cookies 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.9
Steven to write up 1.0 erratum that the default behviour is for alert to be presented to the user if its parent form control is invalid and available 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.7
Steven to write up his proposal for <submission using="instance('foo')/submission"/> wher foo is id of an instance containing an XForms submission element 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.4
Steven to add pattern MIP and regular expression functions from XPath 2.0 (http://www.w3.org/TR/xquery-operators/#string.match) to XForms 1.1 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.1
Steven to link up with Micah to find out state of his Relax NG schema for XForms 2005-06-15 open Action 2005-06-15.4
Steven to raise getting label, hint and help from XForms, and removing label from XHTML2. 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.18
Steven: the URL for future requests document needs to be changed when ready. 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.16
Steven to respond to Bjoern's e-mail ( http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2004Nov/0050.html). 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.14
Steven: Check to see if Bjoern was told that we had fixed ( http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2003Aug/0003.html) 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.12
Steven and Kenneth to collect use cases for CSS and send to CSS WG (repeat, styling QNames, styling values, styling data types) 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.1
Steven to check then implementations list and propose removal of clear scams 2005-02-10 open Action 2005-02-10.8
Steven to talk to Dean about using the action tracking system used by CDF WG 2005-01-27 open Action 2005-01-27.1
Steven invite Brian Modra of Vodafone to talk to us (about Java bindings, see http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2004OctDec/0105.html) 2004-10-28 open Action 2004-10-28.1
Action Raman, Steven, MarkB? : get XML handlers out the door [6] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-59-18
Action Raman, Steven, Investigate the issue of binding events from CSS [5] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-58-28
Action Steven talk to HCG about a common submission document [3] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-24-12
Steven to answer XQuery request [12] 2004-01-22 open http://www.w3.org/2004/01/22-xforms-irc#T15-49-27
Rafael Benito Ruiz de Villa
Description Date Created Status References
Dave Raggett
Description Date Created Status References
Dave Raggett to move Forms Tiny testbed to Forms WG public pages, including possible wiki pages. 2006-11-16 open Action 2006-11-16.4
T.V. Raman
Description Date Created Status References
Raman to get Google to watch the W3C RSS feed. 2006-03-16 open Action 2006-03-16.1
MarkB and TV Raman to develop submission spec. taking DOM approach. 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.18
Implementers to document how they support custom controls. Raman to be editor. (one simple doc. linking each documentation) Mark, Kenneth, David, Mikko, Alan, John (ask Susan from Progeny). 2005-06-15 open Action 2005-06-15.3
markb, tv to write-up proposal: Allow more complex use-cases for messages. 2004-12-16 open http://www.w3.org/2004/12/16-xforms-irc#T15-57-06
Raman to answer Leigh's e-mail about the difference between ref="." and ref not being present on trigger. 2004-11-11 open Action 2004-11-11.13
Action Raman, Steven, MarkB? : get XML handlers out the door [6] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-59-18
Action Raman, Steven, Investigate the issue of binding events from CSS [5] 2004-09-30 open http://www.w3.org/2004/09/30-xforms-irc#T14-58-28
Sebastian Schnitzenbaumer
Description Date Created Status References
Sebastian Schnitzenbaumer to restyle main group public page look and feel and move stuff to the wiki. 2007-04-18 open Action 2007-04-18.3
Sebastian Schnitzenbaumer to write some introductory marketing blurb about XForms for later editing by interested parties. 2007-03-07 open Action 2007-03-07.4
Sebastian Schnitzenbaumer to contact Chiba about joining XForms WG. 2006-09-27 open Action 2006-09-27.5
schnitz to deliver new stylesheet 2006-09-14 open http://www.w3.org/2006/09/14-xforms-minutes.html#action06
Lars/Sebastian to write proposal for expected behaviour and respond to David [8] Note: This is about interpretation of ref indication empty nodeset or non-relevant node in message, help, hint, alert and label. 2006-05-10 open Action 2006-05-10.8
schnitz try to get David back in as representative of other company. 2006-01-26 open Action 2006-01-26.4
schnitz Tracking issues deadline one week before TP. 2006-01-26 open Action 2006-01-26.3
Sebastian to look at harmonising XForms appearance + CSS3 appearance and an XForms default stylesheet. 2005-12-15 open Action 2005-12-15.3
Sebastian: Tracking issues [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2005/09/29-xforms-minutes.html#action06] 2005-09-29 open http://www.w3.org/2005/09/29-xforms-minutes.html#action06
Sebastian to complete the XML edit work. 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.6
Rich Schwerdtfeger
Description Date Created Status References
Mark Seaborne
Description Date Created Status References
MarkS to go through action items to see which pertain to 1.1 and haven't been done (bearing in mind that we did some actions on submission at the FtF). 2006-06-14 open Action 2006-06-14.19
Mark to raise action from resolution that the element with repeat attributes is repeated as well as its content (made in Dulles?). 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.5
Mark and Charlie look at navigating forms based on XML instance structure. 2005-10-20 open Action 2005-10-20.1
MarkS to produce strawman proposal on alert/Schematron like functionality for next ftf 2005-10-06 open Action 2005-10-06.3
Kenneth Sklander
Description Date Created Status References
Kenneth to make XForms Tiny strawman proposal to the WG to kick off e-mail discussion. 2006-07-5 open Action 2006-07-5.2
Kenneth to send use-cases and description of problems with current behaviour [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2006/07/19-xforms-minutes.html#action02] 2006-07-19 open http://www.w3.org/2006/07/19-xforms-minutes.html#action02
Kenneth to document how switch/case for actions could be implemented in XForms 1.1 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.13
Steven and Kenneth to collect use cases for CSS and send to CSS WG (repeat, styling QNames, styling values, styling data types) 2005-03-01 open Action 2005-03-01.1
kenneth to add @value to element value to xforms 1.1 2005-02-10 open Action 2005-02-10.4
Unknown
Description Date Created Status References
fix the separator in url encoded submission 2005-02-24 open Action 2005-02-24.04
Nick Van Den Bleeken
Description Date Created Status References
Nick to to look at the string-compare() proposal from John, and see whether we can bring this into line with XPath 2.0's compare() function. This should form the basis of a response to John's LC commment http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2007Mar/0004.html] 2007-04-25 open http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms-editor/2007Mar/0004.html
Nick to enter issue: label, value, hint, help, alert, message to be treated in a consistent (TBD) way. 2006 07 26 open Action 2006 07 26.3
Daniel Vogelheim
Description Date Created Status References
Daniel to basically, add "... nor that all of the script tokens refer to an exactly defined set of characters" for clarification 2005-03-17 open Action 2005-03-17.01
Daniel to add an erratum for the schema to declare bind attributes as global attributes that can be used in other vocabularies. 2005-02-17 open Action 2005-02-17.3
Daniel to alter David's erratum for 4.3.4 The xforms-refresh Event, To make clear that order of notification events is not specified, and must not be relied on by authors. 2004-10-28 open Action 2004-10-28.2
Charlie Wiecha
Description Date Created Status References
Charlie Wiecha to send info to Leigh for F2F for minutes, June 13-15, in Hawthorne, NY. 2007-03-07 open Action 2007-03-07.5
Charlie to look at activity diagram view of processing model 2006-03-02 open Action 2006-03-02.3
Mark and Charlie look at navigating forms based on XML instance structure. 2005-10-20 open Action 2005-10-20.1
Charlie, Allan and Mikko to take on Raman's custom control document. 2005-09-08 open Action 2005-09-08.16
XForms Implementers
Description Date Created Status References
All interested XForms processor builders should post any tweaks to the form that they would like to see, to Kevin's email, before the form is made live. 2006-01-19 open Action 2006-01-19.1
XForms implementers to look at the test suite and pass feedback on to Kevin. 2005-06-15 open Action 2005-06-15.7
XForms Working Group
Description Date Created Status References
Group members to go through XSLT 1.0 + 2.0, XPATH 2.0 EXSLT functions and choose which functions they would like to be added to XForms (1.1?) Send to mailing-list. 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.2
HTML + XForms WGs to look at XHTML2 + XForms to see where there would be problems in allowing everything everywhere (XForms attributes on XHTML2 elements + label on div/section 2005-11-09 open Action 2005-11-09.1
Everyone to read Mikko's proposal for XML signature support (http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Member/w3c-forms/2005JulSep/0122.html). 2005-09-22 open Action 2005-09-22.3
All. When we republish look out for conflicts between spec and schema. Everywhere an attribute is defined the spec. must say whether it is optional or required. 2004-11-12 open Action 2004-11-12.1
Unassigned
Description Date Created Status References
Mark Birbeck to reply to email http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2007Apr/0064.html] 2007-04-25 open http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/www-forms/2007Apr/0064.html
Charlie Wiecha to send F2F details to Steven Pemberton. 2007-03-14 open Action 2007-03-14.3
ShaneM to update Basic 1.1 and XHTML1.1 drafts to the resolution that all versions of XHTML may be delivered using the Internet media Type text/html. 2006-09-13 open http://www.w3.org/2006/09/13-xforms-minutes.html#action01