BP Evidence example

Dear all,

Following today's call, I wanted to have another go at reviewing a 
dataset for evidence gathering for the BPs. I looked at a dataset on the 
CIARD Ring site which is run by a group allied to the FAO. Specifically, 
I looked at

http://ring.ciard.net/chinese-crop-germplasm-information-system-cgris

My results are below

I need to write to the folks who run the portal (I know one of them at 
least) and ask some questions related to some of the later BPs but 
there's some usable data here I hope.

I also wanted to know how long this would take me as I need to follow up 
on my action-297 and write to folks to ask them to do the same. This 
took me about half an hour. I imagine if I knew the dataset better I 
could have done it more quickly, but then I know the BPs pretty well s I 
don't need to consider that content in detail. My guess is that it would 
be hard for a dataset owner/portal manager to do this is less than half 
an hour (and it could easily take an hour).

CIARD Ring is a *very* good data portal (the best I know of anywhere) 
with tons of metadata but even on this portal there are gaps in the 
metadata.

I'll provide some more examples in the coming week. I can't currently 
edit the Google doc which is one reason for sending the info in this mail.

HTH

Phil

1.  Pass
2.  Pass
3.  Pass
4.  Partial. No machine readable licence, user has to follow a link for 
more info when you find actually it's all rights reserved.
5.  Pass - publisher with good level of human readable info, although no 
PROV data as such.
6.  Fail
7.  Partial
8.  Fail
9.  Pass
10. Pass
11. Fail
12. Pass
13. Data is behind firewall but seems very likely pass.
14. Fail (only RDF is provided)
15. Pass
16. Pass - this is a reference dataset
17. Partial - you could download with SELECT *
18. Partial - you could download a subset with a query
19. Pass (Web page has embedded RDFa)
20. N/A
21. Pass
22. N/A
23. Pass
24. Pass
25. Pass
26. Pass
27. N/A
28. N/A
29. Pass
30. Fail
31. N/A
32. Fail
33. Need to ask
34. Need to ask
35. Pass

Received on Friday, 28 October 2016 15:46:00 UTC