Re: AppCache post-mortem?

On Thursday, May 9, 2013 at 7:33 PM, Marcos Caceres wrote:
> I just don't think we (WebApps participants) have the bandwidth to support developers.

This isn't about supporting developers. This is abut making sure that the features that are standardized are actually the ones developers need to build stuff upon, AND that the APIs to access these features don't suck.
> It would be great if the W3C could provide resources there (e.g., help with adding documentation for each API on the WebPlatform.org (http://WebPlatform.org) site).

Let's face it, W3C doesn't have resources for this. Members might.

While documentation is fantastic (and is best done at the same time as the spec is developed, as documenting an API usually informs really well on its inconsistencies and lack of clarity), that's only part of the picture.

We need an instance that reviews specs that come out (much like we have the Privacy IG) and provides feedback on API design (and which can be consulted early in the process so last call reviews don't immediately send back spec authors to the writing board).

--tobie

Received on Thursday, 9 May 2013 18:52:33 UTC