RE: Creator of Target

That still sounds too much like a hack just get an implementation, and regardless, no 2nd implementation is on the horizon.  I think it okay to drop Choice-Target from normative part of the Recommendation. The use case was always a little weak for Choice-Target as compared to Choice-Body and I think we were unduly influenced by a desire for symmetry.

But just my thoughts.

-Tim Cole


________________________________
From: TB Dinesh [dinesh@servelots.com]
Sent: Friday, November 11, 2016 12:29
To: Robert Sanderson
Cc: Web Annotation
Subject: Re: Creator of Target


Re choice of targets..

Is it not as simple as when we have to say the word 'azorath42' in target1 | target2 has edit annotation to be 'azaroth42' ?

User interface is a problem but this would be generated for a query.

On 11 Nov 2016 23:45, "Robert Sanderson" <azaroth42@gmail.com<mailto:azaroth42@gmail.com>> wrote:

That's a much better one, Dinesh!
In my server I could trivially do that as well -- check if the target is an Annotation, and if so, copy the creator to the target.
I don't have a user interface for replies, but there's many clients that do.

That said, it still wouldn't remove the need for a new CR (to Ivan's point) as we would also need two implementations of Choice of Target.

Lets do the implementations, to bulk out the test results, but after Choice of Body :)

Rob


On Fri, Nov 11, 2016 at 10:06 AM, TB Dinesh <dinesh@servelots.com<mailto:dinesh@servelots.com>> wrote:

If you can do that,
We can do 1 for renarration.

A replacement text comes through a renarration annotation. If someone annotates that we know the replaced text we know they annotated what was created by another annotation (creator).

Similarly for target agent,
one can annoate that a target is, say, swf and needs flash player?

On 11 Nov 2016 23:14, "Robert Sanderson" <azaroth42@gmail.com<mailto:azaroth42@gmail.com>> wrote:

In editing the model document, I had a thought ...

Would associating creator with a SpecificResource that is used in the target role be sufficient for the tests?  That's very easy, as the SpecificResource could be considered to be created by the user, not the publisher of the full resource?

For example, a user highlights a region of text to comment on and the client creates a SpecificResource for that.  The creator of the region is the user, no?

Too late? Too much of a hack?

Rob

--
Rob Sanderson
Semantic Architect
The Getty Trust
Los Angeles, CA 90049



--
Rob Sanderson
Semantic Architect
The Getty Trust
Los Angeles, CA 90049