- From: Paola Di Maio <paola.dimaio@gmail.com>
- Date: Sat, 5 Nov 2022 07:47:30 +0800
- To: W3C AIKR CG <public-aikr@w3.org>
- Message-ID: <CAMXe=SrJUXJ0ReKMX9iegViqWmX8J9Q6auZ6LN2cv1OoH-Nasg@mail.gmail.com>
Dave asks for definitions, Adeel asks why is this CG called AI KR CG Milton now wants to see KR bible I ll comment quickly and take this opportunity to create a new diagram <https://docs.google.com/document/d/1lYn8-YUvIS_k1rezgqdR0DX2BLTRYpvkJpmvYjAEpng/edit?usp=sharing> since answering these questions can serve as reorientation also for folks who joined recently 1. Dave, definitions for KR are to be found in the many textbooks and papers, some of which are linked to our pages (need to reorganise pointers to resources). KR is an established field. I cannot answer all your personal questions that relate to the field. if you study the books,(take my course?) you'll find your answers. most graduate courses do not contain answers to new research questions, this is why we become researchers You need to study the references and pick a definition that fits what you are trying to do. The example you pointed to yesterday (some ML that identifies deepfakes) uses KR, thanks for bringing it up. Why dont you dig up the code and analyze and look into how this NN uses KR to solve the deepfake problem? That would be very interesting- 2.Adeel, this CG is called AI KR because it addresses the problems caused by lack of KR in ML. It was started because some years ago, AI went mad with NN/ML without KR and I started getting nighmares of a world run by unintelligent machines (you should have seen the papers in top conferences, I was in agony) This CG pointed out that KR needs to be in the picture to make AI intelligence We have succeeded. KR is now back in the AI/ML learning picture The topics we have discussed here are being picked up by researchers (yes, plagiarized and published under their own name) Universities have started looking for PhD students in the field of KR applied to AI/ML I am glad something has been achieved. There are gaps to be filled, contributions to be made 3. Milton, the KR bible/s have been written decades ago, then forgotten We may be able to add future chapters, KR now needs to be understood and practiced in the context of these powerful new technologies coming out from labs. NN coupled with KR (hybrid) are the way forward This is what people have been working on thirty years ago already Your idea to start relating the work of this CG to knowledge representation challenges is good, maybe we can find some use cases in other CGs (I am a member of a couple of other CGs and have shared on the list a few posts where the problems they were trying to address are clearly related to KR that we could look at PDM
Received on Friday, 4 November 2022 23:49:44 UTC