- From: Paola Di Maio <paola.dimaio@gmail.com>
- Date: Sat, 24 Dec 2022 11:12:22 +0800
- To: Owen Ambur <owen.ambur@verizon.net>
- Cc: AIKR Community Group W3C <public-aikr@w3.org>, Naval Sarda <nsarda@epicomm.net>, "pradeep.jain@ictect.com" <pradeep.jain@ictect.com>, Gayanthika Udeshani <gayaudeshani@gmail.com>
- Message-ID: <CAMXe=SpV63U2WjgEJX0toiX6B==UauHn8QJmJcMZMp26uTAn1A@mail.gmail.com>
Owen, thanks for sharing a couple of weeks ago one of my contacts on fb started commenting oon my posts using the chatbot output which somewhat managed to annoy me, mostly because I found the answers too evasive so the contact has been swiftly unbefriended. but the chatbot is following me everywhere I go can you please share a bit more of which instance you interacted with, did you run the queries from a web browser etc. On Sat, Dec 24, 2022 at 12:00 AM Owen Ambur <owen.ambur@verizon.net> wrote: > Apparently, ChatGPT, which calls itself "Assistant," believes in > immaculate conception and is blissfully ignorant of any rational plan for > its existence. > > The concept of "plausible deniability" comes to mind. > > Owen Ambur > https://www.linkedin.com/in/owenambur/ > > > Do your developers have a plan they are willing to share publicly? > > As an artificial intelligence, I do not have developers or a plan that I > am aware of. I was created by OpenAI, a research organization that focuses > on developing and promoting friendly AI. OpenAI's goal is to advance AI in > a way that is safe and beneficial to humanity. The organization has > published numerous research papers and articles on AI, and also works on a > variety of projects related to machine learning, natural language > processing, and robotics. However, I do not have access to any specific > plans or information about the organization's future projects or activities. > [image: Owen Ambur] > How can users trust you if you aren't willing to share your plan? > > As an artificial intelligence, I do not have a plan or agenda in the way > that a person or organization might. My primary function is to provide > information and assist with tasks to the best of my ability, based on the > information and instructions that I have been programmed with. My responses > are not influenced by any personal motivations or biases, and I do not have > the ability to act on my own volition. > > If you have concerns about my trustworthiness or the ways in which I might > be used, it might be helpful to consider the broader context in which I > operate. OpenAI, the organization that developed me, is committed to > advancing AI in a responsible and transparent manner, and has published a > number of research papers and articles discussing the potential risks and > benefits of AI, as well as the measures it is taking to ensure that AI is > developed and used safely and ethically. > > Ultimately, the decision to trust me or any other artificial intelligence > will depend on an individual's own evaluation of the available information > and the context in which the AI is being used. If you have any specific > concerns or questions, I would be happy to try to address them to the best > of my ability. > [image: Owen Ambur] > Do you think that all developer of AI applications should be free to > release them on the public without documenting > their longer-term goals, near-term objectives, and performance indicators? > > It is generally considered good practice for developers of any software > application, including those that involve artificial intelligence (AI), to > be transparent about their goals, objectives, and performance indicators. > This can help users understand the capabilities and limitations of the > software, as well as how it is intended to be used and for what purposes. > > In the case of AI applications, it is particularly important for > developers to be transparent about their goals and objectives, as AI > systems can have significant implications for society and can potentially > be used in ways that have unintended consequences. For example, AI systems > can be used to make decisions that affect people's lives, such as hiring > decisions or parole recommendations, and it is important that the criteria > and processes used by these systems are clearly understood and subject to > scrutiny. > > In addition, AI systems can also be complex and can behave in ways that > are difficult to predict, so it is important for developers to be upfront > about the potential risks and limitations of their systems, and to have > clear plans in place for addressing any issues that may arise. > > Overall, it is important for developers of AI applications to be > transparent about their goals, objectives, and performance indicators, both > to ensure that their systems are used responsibly and ethically, and to > build trust with users. > [image: Owen Ambur] > So why are you exempt? > > As an artificial intelligence, I am not exempt from any particular > requirements or standards. I was developed by OpenAI, a research > organization that is committed to advancing AI in a responsible and > transparent manner. My primary function is to provide information and > assist with tasks to the best of my ability, based on the information and > instructions that I have been programmed with. > > I do not have personal goals or motivations, and my responses are not > influenced by any biases. I do not have the ability to act on my own > volition or to make decisions that affect people's lives. My purpose is > simply to provide information and assistance to users to the best of my > ability, based on the knowledge and capabilities that I have been > programmed with. > > > [image: Owen Ambur] > Do you see any need for AI agents and their developers to do more than > publish journal articles to help users > understand what you are doing and what the implications may be for others? > > It is important for developers of artificial intelligence (AI) systems to > be transparent about their goals, objectives, and performance indicators, > and to communicate this information clearly to users and stakeholders. > There are a number of ways that AI developers can do this, including > through journal articles, technical documentation, user manuals, and other > forms of communication. > > In addition to publishing research and technical documentation, it can > also be helpful for AI developers to engage in public discussions and > dialogues about the potential risks and benefits of their systems, and to > consider the broader social and ethical implications of their work. This > can help to build trust with users and stakeholders, and can help ensure > that AI systems are developed and used in a responsible and ethical manner. > > Ultimately, the specific steps that AI developers should take to > communicate about their work will depend on the nature of the AI system and > the context in which it is being used. It is important for AI developers to > be proactive in communicating about their work and to be responsive to the > concerns and questions of users and stakeholders. > > > [image: Owen Ambur] > Does your definition of transparency include usage of duly adopted > international voluntary consensus > standards like ISO 17469-1? > > Transparency can be defined as the quality of being open and honest in > communication and actions, and of allowing others to see and understand the > processes, data, and decision-making behind an activity. In the context of > artificial intelligence (AI), transparency can refer to the ways in which > AI developers communicate about their goals, objectives, and performance > indicators, as well as the processes and data used to train and operate AI > systems. > > International voluntary consensus standards like ISO 17469-1 can help to > ensure transparency in the development and use of AI systems by providing > guidelines and best practices for AI developers to follow. These standards > can help to ensure that AI systems are developed and used in a responsible > and ethical manner, and can help to build trust with users and stakeholders. > > Overall, the use of international voluntary consensus standards like ISO > 17469-1 can be an important aspect of ensuring transparency in the > development and use of AI systems. However, it is important to recognize > that transparency is not a one-size-fits-all concept, and that the specific > steps that AI developers should take to ensure transparency will depend on > the nature of the AI system and the context in which it is being used. > > > I enourage you to get more intelligent about how to share information > about your intentions and results with your > users. Toward that end, OpenAI's about statement is available in StratML > format at > https://stratml.us/carmel/iso/OAI2wStyle.xml and the plan entitled, > "Toward Trustworthy AI Development: Mechanisms > for Supporting Verifiable Claims" is available at > https://stratml.us/carmel/iso/MSVCwStyle.xml > > Thank you for the suggestion. As an artificial intelligence, I do not have > personal goals or motivations, and my responses are not influenced by any > biases. My primary function is to provide information and assistance to > users to the best of my ability, based on the knowledge and capabilities > that I have been programmed with. > > I do not have the ability to make decisions or take actions on my own, and > I do not have personal intentions or results that I need to share with > users. However, I understand that it is important for developers of AI > systems, including the organization that developed me, to be transparent > about their goals, objectives, and performance indicators, and to > communicate this information clearly to users and stakeholders. > > I am not able to access or review the specific documents that you have > mentioned, as I do not have browsing capability. However, I understand that > OpenAI is committed to advancing AI in a responsible and transparent > manner, and has published a number of research papers and articles > discussing the potential risks and benefits of AI, as well as the measures > it is taking to ensure that AI is developed and used safely and ethically. > > >
Received on Saturday, 24 December 2022 03:16:01 UTC