Dear All, Following your agreement on further defining criteria for assessing ICANN BOT candidates' strengths in order to speed-up the selection process, there was a clearly stated need for creating a comprehensive evaluation matrix A.S.A.P. Based on suggestions we got from Gerry during the 25 August Teleconference and Leslie by e-mail, such an evaluation tool would look as follows (I tried to help :-) ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- CRITERIA \ CANDIDATES I JFA I HS I OJ I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Knowledge of Internet matters I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Knowledge of Internet Protocols I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Understanding of traditional telecom framework I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Understanding of IP-telecom convergence I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Previous Board experience I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Vision of ICANN development I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- Understanding of financial proceedings I I I I ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- --------------------------------------------------------------------- You can then rank easily and fast each candidate on 7 September Teleconference, using a scale of 1 (unknown) to 5 (strong). Should you like to use this assessment matrix, please forward any improvements and comments, so that I can adjust and prepare it for consideration at the up-coming Teleconference (Agenda Item 2). Livia Rosu PSO-PC Secretary --------------------------------------------------------------- > PSO-Discuss mailing list > PSO-Discuss@pso.icann.org http://list.etsi.org/archives/pso-discuss.html =========================================================================