W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > www-webont-wg@w3.org > May 2003

WOWG: IMPORTANT - LC Comments List - Look for your name

From: Jim Hendler <hendler@cs.umd.edu>
Date: Thu, 29 May 2003 19:10:52 -0400
Message-Id: <p05200f4dbafc4270227b@[10.0.1.2]>
To: webont <www-webont-wg@w3.org>
Cc: w3c-archive@w3.org

WOWGers --
   I have gone through the issue tracker finding all comments that are 
not yet resolved.  We have about 20 that need to be looked at and 
assigned (many of these don't have to be from editors).  We then have 
a bunch awaiting acknolwedgement and a bunch already assigned -- 
people with current assignments are: Hendler, Schreiber, Connolly, 
Patel-Scheider, Heflin, Hayes, Mike Smith.   Please look below to see 
if there are any of yours that are already handled, if there's any on 
the needs assignment that you want to answer, etc.

  This will be an agenda item for next week - so we can get everything 
assigned, discussed or closed (before the comments on test come in)
  -JH
p.s. I have sent a copy of  this list in chronological order to 
w3c-archive@w3.org if you need help in tracking what was received when


**** NEED ASSIGNMENT

--->  OWL WD comments (Sat, Apr 19 2003) [no reply received] - this 
got missed, Guus should look at

---> Language Overview Document editorial comments (Mon, Apr 21 2003) 
- No response yet from Deb/Frank

---> Could owl:sameAs reference non-OWL resources? (Mon, Apr 28 2003) 
[no reply received] - no one has looked at this -- general design 
issue from Vatant.

---> unspecified domain,range in App. C of OWL Language Reference 31 
March 2003 (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received]  - unanswered - 
Mike Dean?

---> OWL comment - language subsets and complexity (Fri, May 09 2003) 
[no reply received] - issue discussed, but not yet assigned

---> OWL comment - owl:OntologyProperty (Fri, May 09 2003) - issue 
resolved, but comment not assigned (Jeremy?)

---> OWL Abstract Syntax and Semantics review comments (Fri, May 09 
2003) [no reply received] - Peter?

---> Comments from RDFCore on S+AS (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply 
received] - discussed, but not answered - Peter?

---> Another RDF Comment on the OWL Reference Doc (Fri, May 09 2003) 
-- Request for RDF to OWL mapping ala Sean's document - ongoing but 
needs to be assigned

---> Comments on Owl REF document (Fri, May 09 2003) - see follow up, 
Brian only asks for response to one of these - Guus?

---> Review section 4.1 of OWL AS&S (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply 
received] - Peter?

---> OWL S&AS comment - owl:Ontology mapping to/from RDF triples 
(Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] - Note - this is mistitled - 
Peter, please look at it.

---> OWL S&AS: Translation to RDF Graphs (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply 
received] - adressed by Sean's document, needs assignment.

---> daml:item (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] - design issue, 
ignored so far.

---> Semantics and Abstract Syntax (and some general OWL Lite, CR, & 
implementation) comments (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] 
several comments, mostly editorial, on contentive -- Peter?

---> Missing AllSame (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] - 
discussed, but not answered - needs assignment.

---> Missing AllDisjoint? (Sun, May 11 2003) discussed, but needs assigning

---> Fwd: Jena comment: Syntax Checker Implementation Report] (Mon, 
May 12 2003) [no reply received] - this is an S&AS comment, Peter?

---> inadequate reference in Owl REF (Thu, May 15 2003) [no reply 
received] - Guus?

****** AWAITING ACK

S&AS comments (Fri, Apr 11 2003) - pfps responded to J. Pan - no ack

Remarks on OWL Guide and question about AS&S (Fri, Apr 11 2003) - 
answered by Pfps and Mike - no ack.

Language Ref Appendix D editorial comments (Mon, May 05 2003) - Mike 
Dean answered, no ack yet

  Re: S&AS comments (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received]  (See 
April, waiting for ack)

Re: Remarks on OWL Guide and question about AS&S (Thu, May 15 2003) 
[no reply received] - part of discussion with A. Isaac - waiting for 
ack.




***** ASSIGNED TO:
HENDLER

Case for Reinstatement of Qualified Cardinality Restrictions (Wed, 
Apr 16 2003) - assigned to JAH  (WG work completed)

Re: privacy in OWL (Tue, May 06 2003) - assigned to JH

OWL and Published Subjects (Tue, May 06 2003) [no reply received] - 
needs official response, no activity needed - assigned to JH

Non-global Keys (Tue, May 06 2003) - assigned to JAH and DanC

OWL Comment: have long CR period for OWL, or move owl:oneOf, owl: 
have Value to OWL Full (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] - 
assigned to JAH

comments on OWL Last Call drafts (Sat, May 10 2003) [no reply 
received] - Assigned to Hendler


PFPS
Some comments on OWL S&AS (Sat, Apr 05 2003)  - ongoing discussion w pfps


GUUS

RDFCore Comments on OWL Reference (Fri, May 02 2003) - Guus handling, 
still open


"sameAs" error in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 (Wed, May 07 
2003) - ongoing discussion - expecting Peter to make the change based 
on Guus' email, Guus to respond

"sameIndividualAs" error in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 
(Thu, May 08 2003) - same status as above

Nothing in App. B of OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 (Thu, May 
08 2003) - Guus replied, this guy replied back, Guus' turn now

Restriction, DeprecatedClass in OWL Language Reference 31 March 2003 
(Thu, May 08 2003) -- same as above, Guus' ball again

OWL Reference comment - RDF Schema for OWL (Fri, May 09 2003) - 
ongoing discussion betw/ Guus and Dave Beckett


DANC

QA Review of owl-semantics (Wed, Apr 30 2003) [no reply received] - 
Connolly started discussion, not yet done.

Non-global Keys (Tue, May 06 2003) - assigned to JAH and DanC

MIKE S

about/base and Free to implementations (Wed, Apr 30 2003) [no reply 
received] - ongoing discussion w/Mike S.


JEFF H.

OWL S&AS comment - owl:imports (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] 
- assigned to Heflin

OWL S&AS Comment - owl:imports (Fri, May 09 2003) [no reply received] 
- assigned to Heflin

PAT HAYES

rdf:about and owl:sameIndividualAs oddities (Thu, May 01 2003) [no 
reply received] - assigned to Pat Hayes May 29.

****** CLOSED

CLOSED-   search feature (Wed, Apr 09 2003) [no reply received] - spam
CLOSED - Language Guide Comments (Mon, Apr 21 2003) - Mike S. closed in May
CLOSED - OWL Language Reference Comments (Mon, Apr 21 2003) - Mike S. closed
CLOSED (see April) RE: Language Guide Comments (Fri, May 02 2003)
CLOSED OWL Guide comment (Tue, May 06 2003) [no reply received]
CLOSED THANK YOU ALL FOR YOUR COMMENTS [closed] (Fri, May 09 2003) 
[no reply received]
CLOSED imports error in App. B of OWL Language Reference 31 March 
2003 (Sun, May 11 2003)
CLOSED  - missing RDF & OWL classes (Sun, May 18 2003)
CLOSED - Re: OWL Language Reference Comments (Wed, May 21 2003) [no 
reply received] - Lacy acknowledges his comments addressing
-- 
Professor James Hendler				  hendler@cs.umd.edu
Director, Semantic Web and Agent Technologies	  301-405-2696
Maryland Information and Network Dynamics Lab.	  301-405-6707 (Fax)
Univ of Maryland, College Park, MD 20742	  240-731-3822 (Cell)
http://www.cs.umd.edu/users/hendler
Received on Thursday, 29 May 2003 19:11:02 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Monday, 7 December 2009 10:58:00 GMT