- From: Susan Lesch <lesch@w3.org>
- Date: Sat, 11 Nov 2000 22:52:04 -0800
- To: dee3@torque.pothole.com, reagle@w3.org, dsolo@alum.mit.edu
- Cc: w3c-ietf-xmldsig@w3.org
Congratulations on your "XML-Signature Syntax and Processing"
Candidate Recommendation [1]. It is a pleasure to read. Here
are a few very minor typos that appear to have been missed.
1.3 par. 1, namespace The -> namespace. The
1.3 par. 2, XML-namespaces -> XML namespaces
2.0 par. 4, that resides within -> that reside within
4.2 par. 1, [MIME].While -> [MIME]. While
4.3.1 par. 2, that do no support -> that do not support
4.3.3.2 par. 3, is a an octet stream -> is an octet stream
4.3.3.2 par. 3, transformrequires -> transform requires (twice)
4.3.3.2 par. 4, over-ride -> override
4.3.3.4 par. 4, Some Transform -> Some Transforms (not sure there)
4.4 par. 1, XML-namespace -> XML namespace (or Namespaces in XML)
4.4.3 par. 2, to be to be -> to be
4.4.3 par. 2, canonicalized.All -> canonicalized. All
6.2.1 first example is a bit in the margin. Could be indented:
<pre class="xml-example">
<code><DigestMethod Algorithm="</code><span style=
"font-weight: normal">&dsig;</span><code>sha1"/></code>
</pre>
6.3.1 second example is also in the margin. Could be indented:
<pre class="xml-example">
<SignatureValue>kpRyejY4uxwT9I74FYv8nQ==</SignatureValue>
</pre>
6.5 par. 1, canonicalizationalgorithms -> canonicalization algorithms
6.6 par. 1, a single implicit parameters -> a single implicit parameter
6.6.2 par. 1, base 64 -> base64
6.6.3 par. 2, omitted<strong>.</strong> (I wasn't sure if the strong
markup is intentional.)
6.6.3 par. 2, Canonical XML with Comments (a subsequent -> Canonical
XML with Comments; (a subsequent
6.6.5 last par., [XSLT].We -> [XSLT]. We
6.6.5 last par., transformauthors -> transform authors
6.6.5 last par., transformafter -> transform after
6.6.5 last par., transformto -> transform to
7.0 last par., as well (if not -> as well; (if not
7.1 par. 2, well formed -> well-formed
7.2 last par., XML1.0 -> XML 1.0
7.2 last par., sytnax -> syntax
8.1.3 par. 1, that that -> that
10. in Signature, Enveloping, Object(or -> Object (or
10. in Signature, Enveloping, idenitifier -> identifier
11. LDAP-DN is an anchor (I think by accident).
11. in SAX, et. al. -> et al.
11. in UTF-8, Janaury -> January
11. in XHTML 1.0, Recommendation -> W3C Recommendation
11. in XHTML 1.0, et. al. -> et al.
11. in XLink, Language.Working Draft. -> Language. W3C Working Draft.
11. in XML, Recommendation -> W3C Recommendation
11. in XML-C14N, Candidate Recommendation -> W3C Candidate Recommendation
11. in XML-Japanese, W3C NOTE -> W3C Note
11. in XML-ns, Recommendation -> W3C Recommendation
11. XML-schema is (obviously, sorry) a W3C Candidate Recommendation.
11. in XML-schema, N. Mendelshohn -> N. Mendelsohn
11. in XPath, (XPath)Version 1.0 -> (XPath) Version 1.0
11. in XPath, Recommendation -> W3C Recommendation
11. in XPointer, Candidate Recommendation -> W3C Candidate Recommendation
11. in XSL, Working Draft -> W3C Working Draft
11. in XSLT, Recommendation -> W3C Recommendation
[1] http://www.w3.org/TR/2000/CR-xmldsig-core-20001031/
Best wishes for your project,
--
Susan Lesch - mailto:lesch@w3.org tel:+1.858.483.4819
World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) - http://www.w3.org/
Received on Sunday, 12 November 2000 01:52:25 UTC