W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-svg-print@w3.org > December 2007

Re: LastCall for SVG Print 1.2

From: Sergiu Dumitriu <sergiu@xwiki.com>
Date: Sat, 22 Dec 2007 02:12:37 +0100
Message-ID: <476C6485.1090500@xwiki.com>
To: public-svg-print@w3.org


A few comments:

- In section 3.3 of Part 1, "Master Page", the wording of "if a 
rectangle was drawn prior to..." and of "If a masterPage was specified 
after the rectangle was drawn" seems a bit wrong, as the rectangle is 
not simply drawn. How about "if a rectangle was declared prior to..." 
and "... after [displaying/printing/drawing] the rectangle on the 
background for several pages..."
- Still there, a minor typo in the next paragraph: "it is good practice 
to have the _objectsto_ be reused"
- Section 3.5 of Part 1, "Selecting a Master Page when referencing a 
page", says: ``The current Master Pages from the externally referenced 
document may be applied to the externally referenced page. In which case 
use-master-page= "external"''. The dot doesn't belong there, that's not 
proper english. The same thing for the next two phrases.
- Still there, "Alternatively" makes the default behavior look like a 
merely possible thing, not something enabled by default.
- Section 3.7 of Part 1, "noPrint", should be changed to reflect the new 
name of the attribute used in Part 2, print-display.
- The diagram in section 3.9 of Part 1 is a bit too big, maybe a smaller 
variant should be used inline, with a link to the big version. Also 
consider adding a caption.

P.S.: Just noticed the reply to my previous comments, thanks for 
considering my previous observations.

Sergiu Dumitriu

Chris Lilley wrote:
> Hello www-svg-print,
> This is a Last Call Working Draft transition announcement for SVG Print 1.2, which is in two parts:
> SVG Print 1.2, Part 1: Primer
> W3C Working Draft 21 December 2007
>     http://www.w3.org/TR/2007/WD-SVGPrintPrimer12-20071221/
> SVG Print 1.2, Part 2: Language
> W3C Working Draft 21 December 2007
>     http://www.w3.org/TR/2007/WD-SVGPrint12-20071221/
> Feedback should be sent to public-svg-print@w3.org which has a public archive at http://lists.w3.org/Archives/Public/public-svg-print/ by 8 February 2008. 
> SVG Print is aimed at software which generates formatted, paginated material for printing. The process of generating that content (eg from XSL, or from CSS, or from a wordprocessor  or charting package, or whatever other means, is at a level above SVG Print and orthogonal to it. Where SVG Print fits in is the case where the printer itself (or some print processor) understands SVG as a page description language.
> Print creation software that is talking to an SVG-aware printer can easily use standard SVG features to do multiple pages per physical page (impression); to print crop marks, registration marks, quality control swatches and job control information as well as the original content.
> SVG Print defines conformance classes for SVG Print documents, for SVG Printing Devices, and for an SVG Print Preview device.
> The SVG Print 1.2 language adds two main features to SVG - one is a set of elements for dividing content into pages and for defining master page content (eg 'draft' printed in grey under each page) and the other is improved color specification information. 
> Previous specifications from W3C (SVG 1.1, CSS, XSL) allowed ICC-based color specification but made it optional and thus, not testable. Given the crucial industry importance of color management, SVG Print makes ICC-based color management mandatory and thus, testable and reliable. In addition to the sRGB and ICC-based color specifications from SVG 1.1 (eg, for calibrated CMYK) SVG Print 1.2 adds names colors, 'device' (ie, uncalibrated) colors, and allows color interpolation to occur in the CIE LAB color space. The latter feature means that colors may be freely used which are outside the gamut of sRGB. 
> For CSS WG, SVG WG is interested to hear of anything in CSS that would be problematic to represent in SVG Print.
> For XSL FO, SVG WG is interested to hear of anything in XSL FO that would be problematic to represent in SVG Print, and also interested to explore reuse of color specification material to allow common use in XSL and SVG. Many XSL FO processors also understand SVG and it would be convenient to allow color-matched documents for that use case.
Received on Saturday, 22 December 2007 17:49:49 UTC

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Tuesday, 6 January 2015 19:41:46 UTC