W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-rif-comments@w3.org > August 2009

comments on FLD, BLD, and Core

From: Stijn Heymans <heymans@kr.tuwien.ac.at>
Date: Thu, 20 Aug 2009 10:31:21 +0200
Message-ID: <bfaccb240908200131x59b9a99ew72c09df725fdcc00@mail.gmail.com>
To: public-rif-comments@w3.org
Dear all,

An elegant and solid framework for specifying RIF dialects in FLD, a
first general logical rule dialect in BLD, and a subset of BLD and PRD
(Production rules) constitute a set of documents that can lead the
rule designed/implementor in coming up with own dialects in a clear
and concise manner. It's only a matter of spreading the word now and
convincing communities like the LP community to use it.

Some minor comments on the different documents:

on "FLD: RIF Framework for Logic Dialects".

Section 2.2: It says "However, dialects cannot redefine the semantics
of the predefined quantifiers".  Does this mean that one cannot change
the domain of quantification in a dialect? For example, in LP instead
of a closed domain assumption (with the constants of the program) and
open domain assumption as in FOL.

Section 2.4: item 4: It is not immediately clear from this explanation
what the difference (besides a syntactical) between closed lists and
open lists is. All its arguments t1, ..., tm, t are terms (both in
closed lists and open lists).

Section 2.5: Def. Schema for an external term: Why is the order of the
names of the variables important. In other words, why are (?X ?Y; bla;
loc) and (?Y ?X; bla; loc) different?

on "BLD: RIF Basic Logic Dialect"

Section 2.4: Is there a reason why in an annotation (* id phi *) phi
is a frame formula (or a conjunction thereof) and not also allowed to
be an atomic formula?

On "Core: RIF Core Dialect"

Example 1 in "Core" and "BLD" are the same (i.e., both Core). It would
be better to have in BLD an example that is BLD but not Core.

best regards,

Received on Thursday, 20 August 2009 08:32:48 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Thursday, 20 August 2009 08:32:49 GMT