W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-rdf-dawg@w3.org > July to September 2007

Re: DAWG Agenda - 28 Aug 2007 @ 14:30 UTC

From: Eric Prud'hommeaux <eric@w3.org>
Date: Tue, 28 Aug 2007 09:45:22 -0400
To: Lee Feigenbaum <lee@thefigtrees.net>
Cc: 'RDF Data Access Working Group' <public-rdf-dawg@w3.org>
Message-ID: <20070828134521.GA15311@w3.org>
* Lee Feigenbaum <lee@thefigtrees.net> [2007-08-27 15:04-0400]
> 5. Test suite and test service and implementation report
>
> We've published the test suite and will be publishing the test service 
> shortly. Where should we gather EARL results? Any progress on generating an 
> implementation report?

Quick breakdown of the features passed vs. the features *tested*.
(ARQ's report included every test.)
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| RDF API for PHP                                                             | SUM(pass) | COUNT(*) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| ASK query form                                                              |         0 |        9 |
| Basic graph pattern matching. Triple pattern constructs. Blank node scoping |        64 |      171 |
| Core bits of SPARQL. Prefixed names, variables, blank nodes, graph terms    |       316 |      845 |
| RDF datasets. Default and named graphs. GRAPH keyword                       |         0 |        7 |
| FILTER clauses and expressions                                              |        76 |      232 |
| OPTIONAL pattern matching                                                   |         5 |       19 |
| SELECT query form                                                           |        64 |      167 |
| Sorting (ORDER BY) and slicing (LIMIT, OFFSET)                              |        13 |       26 |
| UNION pattern matching                                                      |         1 |        4 |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| ARQ                                                                         | SUM(pass) | COUNT(*) |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| ASK query form                                                              |       102 |      102 |
| Basic graph pattern matching. Triple pattern constructs. Blank node scoping |       303 |      303 |
| CONSTRUCT query form                                                        |        15 |       15 |
| Core bits of SPARQL. Prefixed names, variables, blank nodes, graph terms    |      1353 |     1353 |
| RDF datasets. Default and named graphs. GRAPH keyword                       |        44 |       44 |
| FILTER clauses and expressions                                              |       545 |      545 |
| OPTIONAL pattern matching                                                   |        25 |       25 |
| SELECT query form                                                           |       236 |      236 |
| Sorting (ORDER BY) and slicing (LIMIT, OFFSET)                              |        92 |       92 |
| UNION pattern matching                                                      |        12 |       12 |
+-----------------------------------------------------------------------------+-----------+----------+

for a more tedious picture, we can look at RDF API for PHP by facet:
+-----------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| facet                                   | SUM(pass) | COUNT(*) |
+-----------------------------------------+-----------+----------+
| ASK query form                                                 |
| AskQuery                                |         0 |        3 |
| AskQuery-no                             |         0 |        3 |
| AskQuery-yes                            |         0 |        3 |
| Basic graph pattern matching. Triple pattern constructs. Blank node scoping
| BasicGraphPattern-spo                   |        24 |       58 |
| BasicGraphPattern-spoDOT                |        32 |       92 |
| BasicGraphPattern-spoo                  |         1 |        1 |
| BasicGraphPattern-spopo                 |         2 |        4 |
| BasicGraphPattern-spospo                |         5 |       15 |
| GroupGraphPattern-empty                 |         0 |        1 |
| Core bits of SPARQL. Prefixed names, variables, blank nodes, graph terms
| BaseDecl                                |         4 |        4 |
| BlankNodePropertyList                   |         0 |        2 |
| Collection-0                            |         0 |        1 |
| Collection-1                            |         2 |        2 |
| Collection-n                            |         1 |        1 |
| GraphTerm-BooleanLiteral-false          |         1 |        1 |
| GraphTerm-BooleanLiteral-true           |         1 |        1 |
| GraphTerm-minus                         |         1 |        1 |
| GraphTerm-plus                          |         0 |        1 |
| IRIref-rQ_IRI_REF                       |         2 |        3 |
| NumericLiteral-rDECIMAL                 |         0 |        4 |
| NumericLiteral-rDOUBLE                  |         0 |        2 |
| NumericLiteral-rINTEGER                 |         8 |       20 |
| PrefixDecl-default                      |        41 |      110 |
| PrefixDecl-n                            |        30 |       83 |
| PrefixDecl-nonDefault                   |        33 |       92 |
| PrefixedName-localname                  |        39 |       94 |
| PrefixedName-prefix-localname           |        10 |       35 |
| RDFLiteral-datatype                     |         1 |       10 |
| RDFLiteral-plain                        |        11 |       32 |
| RDFLiteral-rLANGTAG                     |        11 |       32 |
| String-doubleQuote                      |        12 |       27 |
| String-singleQuote                      |         0 |        2 |
| String-triple-doubleQuote               |         0 |        2 |
| String-triple-singleQuote               |         0 |        2 |
| Var-rVAR1                               |        53 |      138 |
| Var-rVAR2                               |         1 |        2 |
| Verb-a                                  |         1 |        1 |
| WhereClause-noWhere                     |        23 |       85 |
| WhereClause-where                       |        30 |       55 |
| FILTER clauses and expressions                                 |
| BuiltInCall-bound                       |         1 |        3 |
| BuiltInCall-datatype                    |         0 |        4 |
| BuiltInCall-isBlank                     |         1 |        1 |
| BuiltInCall-lang                        |         2 |        6 |
| BuiltInCall-langMatches                 |         2 |        4 |
| BuiltInCall-str                         |         2 |        5 |
| ConditionalAndExpression-n              |         0 |        1 |
| ConditionalOrExpression-n               |         0 |        6 |
| IRIrefOrFunction-iri                    |         2 |        6 |
| PrimaryExpression-IRIref                |         2 |        6 |
| PrimaryExpression-rBrackettedExpression |         0 |        1 |
| PrimaryExpression-rBuiltInCall          |         5 |       18 |
| PrimaryExpression-rNumericLiteral       |         6 |       16 |
| PrimaryExpression-rRDFLiteral           |         8 |       23 |
| PrimaryExpression-rVar                  |        26 |       71 |
| RegexExpression                         |         2 |        3 |
| RegexExpression-flags                   |         0 |        1 |
| RelationalExpression-eq                 |        12 |       33 |
| RelationalExpression-gt                 |         0 |        3 |
| RelationalExpression-le                 |         0 |        1 |
| RelationalExpression-lt                 |         1 |        4 |
| RelationalExpression-ne                 |         2 |       10 |
| UnaryExpression-NOT                     |         2 |        6 |
| OPTIONAL pattern matching                                      |
| OptionalGraphPattern                    |         5 |       19 |
| RDF datasets. Default and named graphs. GRAPH keyword          |
| GraphGraphPattern                       |         0 |        7 |
| SELECT query form                                              |
| SelectQuery-Distinct-star               |         1 |        1 |
| SelectQuery-Distinct-Var                |         0 |        5 |
| SelectQuery-noDistinct-star             |        25 |       55 |
| SelectQuery-noDistinct-Var              |        27 |       76 |
| SelectQuery-Var-n                       |        11 |       30 |
| Sorting (ORDER BY) and slicing (LIMIT, OFFSET)                 |
| OrderClause-1                           |         4 |        9 |
| OrderClause-n                           |         1 |        1 |
| OrderCondition-ASC                      |         2 |        5 |
| OrderCondition-DESC                     |         2 |        5 |
| OrderCondition-noSC                     |         2 |        3 |
| OrderCondition-rVar                     |         2 |        3 |
| UNION pattern matching                                         |
| GroupOrUnionGraphPattern-union          |         1 |        4 |
+-----------------------------------------+-----------+----------+

I'd prefer if the passed numbers were either 0 or equal to the sum
(i.e. we had some confidence that we were isolating the parts of their
code that followed the spec or not). We could do some forensics, but I
think we should wait 'till they re-run now that we have a full test
set for them.

I did $(wget)s into a tests/reports/ directory and modified the
reports to make them uniform. I separated ARQ's assertor and
subject. RDF API for PHP had 19 mislabled tests so I commented those
out. Likewise, I commented theirs that dealt with the syntax
tests. Andy nicely separated his syntax from his semantics tests.

RDF API for PHP used a structure like this to describe the earl:subject:
<http://rdfapi-php.sf.net/> doap:name "RDF API for PHP";
    doap:release [ doap:created "2007-08-13 17:09"^^<http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#date>;
        doap:name "RAP SVN-2007-08-13T17:09";
        a doap:Version ];
    a doap:Project.
so I emulated that in ARQ's report:
_:b1
      rdf:type      earl:Software ;
      doap:name     "ARQ" ;
      doap:release  [ doap:name "@version@" ] ;
      <http://purl.org/dc/terms/isPartOf>
                    [ foaf:homepage  <http://jena.sf.net/>
                    ] ;
      foaf:homepage  <http://jena.sf.net/ARQ> .
(The "@version@" had been on a dc:somethingorother arc.)

Should I check in the reports/ dir?
-- 
-eric

office: +1.617.258.5741 NE43-344, MIT, Cambridge, MA 02144 USA
mobile: +1.617.599.3509

(eric@w3.org)
Feel free to forward this message to any list for any purpose other than
email address distribution.

Received on Tuesday, 28 August 2007 13:45:34 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.3.1 : Tuesday, 26 March 2013 16:15:37 GMT