W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-owl-wg@w3.org > October 2008

Re: ACTION-232 analysis of differences between functional syntax keywords and RDF syntax URIs

From: Alan Ruttenberg <alanruttenberg@gmail.com>
Date: Sun, 26 Oct 2008 05:17:07 +0100
Message-ID: <29af5e2d0810252117g6602886dn61a41e0223bf5db3@mail.gmail.com>
To: "Peter F. Patel-Schneider" <pfps@research.bell-labs.com>
Cc: public-owl-wg@w3.org

A couple of missing ones from declarations.

DataProperty vs owl:dataTypeProperty
Also, NamedIndividual 2 and owl:NamedIndividual 2 (why do we need this at all?)



On Thu, Oct 23, 2008 at 1:15 PM, Peter F. Patel-Schneider
<pfps@research.bell-labs.com> wrote:
>
>        Divergence between Functional Syntax and RDF Syntax
>
> This mostly relates to functional syntax keywords and RDF syntax URIs.
> Keywords and URIs that don't show in OWL 1 are often tagged with "2".
>
> There is exact correspondence for some constructs (at least with respect
> to keywords).  Such cases are indicated by "exact".  Sometimes there are
> non-OWL namespaces, which is indicated by "".
>
> In the functional syntax all keywords have initial capitals.  In RDF
> classes have initial capitals but properties don't.   Such differences
> are are indicated by "cap" below.
>
> The RDF syntax has to make name distinctions for functional syntax
> constructs with optional parts.   Differences resulting from this are
> indicated with "opt".
>
> exact           all built-in classes
> exact           all built-in properties
> exact           all datatypes
> exact           all facets
>
> cap     IntersectionOf          owl:intersectionOf
> cap     UnionOf                 owl:unionOf
> cap     ComplementOf            owl:complementOf
> cap     OneOf                   owl:oneOf
> cap     AllValuesFrom           owl:allValuesFrom
> cap     SomeValuesFrom          owl:someValuesFrom
> cap     HasValue                owl:hasValue
>        ExistsSelf 2            owl:SelfRestriction 2
> cap     Cardinality             owl:cardinality
> cap     MaxCardinality          owl:maxCardinality
> cap     MinCardinality          owl:minCardinality
> opt     Cardinality             owl:qualifiedCardinality
> opt     MaxCardinality          owl:maxQualifiedCardinality
> opt     MinCardinality          owl:minQualifiedCardinality
>
> cap/nm  SubClassOf              rdfs:subClassOf
>        EquivalentClasses       owl:equivalentClass
>        DisjointClasses         owl:disjointWith
>        DisjointClasses         owl:AllDisjointClasses 2
> cap     DisjointUnionOf         owl:disjointUnionOf
>
>        ComplementOf            owl:datatypeComplementOf 2
>        DatatypeRestriction 2   owl:withRestrictions 2
>
> cap     PropertyChain 2         owl:propertyChain 2
> cap     InverseOf               owl:inverseOf
>
> cap/nm  SubPropertyOf           rdfs:subPropertyOf
>        PropertyDomain 2        rdfs:domain
>        PropertyRange 2         rdfs:range
>        EquivalentProperties    owl:equivalentProperty
>        DisjointProperties      owl:propertyDisjointWith
>        DisjointProperties      owl:AllDisjointProperties
>        InverseProperties 2     owl:inverseOf
> exact   FunctionalProperty      owl:FunctionalProperty
> exact   InverseFunctionalProperty owl:InverseFunctionalProperty
> exact   ReflexiveProperty       owl:ReflexiveProperty
> exact   IrreflexiveProperty     owl:IrreflexiveProperty
> exact   SymmetricProperty       owl:SymmetricProperty
> exact   AsymmetricProperty      owl:AsymmetricProperty
> exact   TransitiveProperty      owl:TransitiveProperty
>
> cap     HasKey 2                owl:hasKey 2
>
>        SameIndividual          owl:sameAs
>        DifferentIndividuals    owl:differentFrom
>        DifferentIndividuals    owl:AllDifferent
>        ClassAssertion 2        rdf:type
>        PropertyAssertion 2     ---
> exact   NegativePropertyAssertion 2 owl:NegativePropertyAssertion 2
>
>        Declaration 2             rdf:type
>
> exact   Annotation                owl:Annotation
> cap     Label                     rdfs:label
> cap     Comment                   rdfs:comment
> cap     Deprecated                owl:deprecated 2
>
> exact   Ontology                  owl:Ontology
>
>        Import 2                  owl:imports
>
>
Received on Sunday, 26 October 2008 04:17:42 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Sunday, 26 October 2008 04:17:44 GMT