RE: action 226

Hi. Joakim and all.

I have done for updating of three mapping tables, MediaRSS, TXFeed and Youtube.

In case of MediaRSS, the version of metadata format was up to 1.5.0. in the Sep. 2009. earlier version I reviewed was 1.1.2.

So I updated the mapping table of MediaRSS based on the last version.

 

If you have any comment or question, please let me know.

 

Best regards,

Wonsuk.

 

From: public-media-annotation-request@w3.org [mailto:public-media-annotation-request@w3.org] On Behalf Of Joakim Soderberg
Sent: Monday, March 29, 2010 12:57 AM
To: public-media-annotation@w3.org
Subject: action 226

 

Dear all,

As promised during last telcon I have checked the mapping table to see which formats are ready of LC publication. The result in short: only the MPEG7 and SMTPD tables have everything filled out (good work Werner)! Perhaps other formats are complete, but cannot be fully mapped for some reasons?

 

Q: What is the purpose of "How to do the mapping". 

Is it to give a description/comment about of the mapping?  Only Jean-Pierre and Werner has used it!

Do we want to keep this field in LC? If so we have to fill it out!

 

1) We have do designate a editor for XMP. Volunteer?

 

2) Each editor has to check his/her format and respond to my comment below.


In a not so distant future (after easter holidays) we have to vote on which formats to publish as LC, depending on their shape!

 

 

== Current status of format mappings:

XMP  (no editor designated):
 nothing defined

 

ID3 (joakim):
 datatype missing


iTunes (David):
 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

QT (David):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined

 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

Search Monkey (Tobias):
 nothing defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MediaRDF (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

LOM (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

METS (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

EXIF (Tobias):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!


CL 1.1 (Joakim):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing

CL 2.0 (Joakim)

 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined

MediaRDF (Chris):
 have definitions for most fields, but some attributes are left out!

 

MIX (Felix):
 attribute mapping is incomplete
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 no datatypes defined
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

FRBR (Victor):
 Only two attributes mapped!
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MediaRSS (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

TXFeed (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

YouTube (Wonsuk):
 no datatypes defined  
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

VRA (Veronique):
 no datatypes defined  
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

IPTC (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

TVA (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

EBUCore (Jean-Pierre):
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

EBUP (Jean-Pierre):
 no datatypes defined  
 relation (semantic mapping) missing
 old lay-out, change order of rows (see summary page)!

 

MPEG7 (Werner + Frank):
 complete!

 

SMTPD (Werner):
 complete!

 

Best Regards

/Joakim

 

 

 

JOAKIM SÖDERBERG M.Sc, Ph.D 
Multimedia Indexing, Senior Research Engineer, Chair W3C MAWG 


Ericsson Research
Multimedia Technologies
Sweden
SMS/MMS +46761263915
www.ericsson.com 



 





This Communication is Confidential. We only send and receive email on the basis of the terms set out at www.ericsson.com/email_disclaimer