Initial Feedback on Bidi Improvements in HTML

Dear Aharon and Bidi Specialists,

Our first comments relate to section 3.10. The IE example 1 actually 
appears to be the correct solution -- we prefer this over the proposed 
solution. That is, default behavior should not ‘line up’ bullets or 
numbers to all the same side, more or less the left side, of an <li> 
element. Persian and Arabic (not sure about Hebrew) books, for example, 
have references/bibliographies with RTL references (and Arabic-Indic 
numerals) mixed with LTR references (and European numerals). RTL list 
items and their numbering in these references are right aligned and LTR 
list items and their numbering are left aligned.

We have concerns about other parts of the specification and will be 
putting these in a email soon.

Thank you,


Craig Cummings, Yahoo
Roozbeh Pournader, Gnome

Received on Wednesday, 14 April 2010 19:49:50 UTC