W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > public-egov-ig@w3.org > November 2009

Re: Defining "Open" Data (was RE: no F2F3 in 2009 -- Re: Agenda, eGov IG Call, 11 Nov 2009)

From: Emmanouil Batsis (Manos) <manos@abiss.gr>
Date: Fri, 13 Nov 2009 16:47:00 +0200
Message-ID: <4AFD7164.8000801@abiss.gr>
To: Daniel Dietrich <daniel@so36.net>
CC: Brian Gryth <briangryth@gmail.com>, Jonathan Gray <jonathan.gray@okfn.org>, eGovIG IG <public-egov-ig@w3.org>, Todd Vincent <todd.vincent@xmllegal.org>, Niklas Lindström <lindstream@gmail.com>, "prof. dr. Tom M. van Engers" <vanengers@uva.nl>, peter.krantz@gmail.com, david osimo <david.osimo@gmail.com>, Jose Manuel Alonso <josema.alonso@fundacionctic.org>, washingtona@acm.org

> On 12.11.2009, at 21:04, Brian Gryth wrote:
>> From this discussion, it appears that there are three basic issues:
>>  
>> 1) Access (i.e. whether there is a cost related to getting the data)
>> 2) Rights (i.e. copyright and other legal obligations or privileges)
>> 3) Format/medium (i.e. electronic human-readable, electronic machine-readable, or paper)


Access rights, i.e. 1 and 2, should be dealt by existing technical or 
business plumbing. To break up 3 and keep the interesting parts, it 
largely makes sense (IMHO) to look at it from one of:

a) A licensing/rights perspective, as some licenses may have rules 
related to the distribution medium used. This is covered by 2 and is an 
area largely covered by other efforts.

b) Presentation/style/transformation perspective which is also covered 
by state of the art.

c) XML accessibility, design and versioning issues - lots of useful 
material on these exists already.

d) An ontology or more generic information modeling perspective.

Overall the domain of interest here draws people with diverse 
perspectives, knowledge, experiences and focus. I'm very new to this 
list but it seems like the group as a whole understands the complexity 
involved, moving with some hesitation (and individuals with excessive 
politeness), as if some principles may disturb others.

Of course the second charter just got approved and people in here 
haven't had enough interactivity to collectively reach some solid 
overlap in goals. It is encouraging to see the discussion is widely 
scoped and allows many different perspectives to blend in.

I'm certain the process will work and I'm very excited with so many 
different people here to learn from.

Cheers,

Manos

-- 
Manos Batsis, Chief Technologist
          __    _
   ____ _/ /_  (_)_________ ____ ______
  / __ `/ __ \/ / ___/ ___// __ `/ ___/
/ /_/ / /_/ / (__  |__  )/ /_/ / /
\__,_/_.___/_/____/____(_)__, /_/
                         /____/
http://www.Abiss.gr
19, Kalvou Street,
14231, Nea Ionia,
Athens, Greece

Tel: +30 211-1027-900
Fax: +30 211-1027-999
Received on Friday, 13 November 2009 14:54:13 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Friday, 13 November 2009 14:54:13 GMT