Guide to Guideline 3.1 Level 3 Success Criterion 1   (proposed)

Major sections of this page

·         Understanding Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

·         Techniques for meeting Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

·         Benefits and Examples of Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

What WCAG 2.0 requires

 

1.    A mechanism is available for determining the intended definitions of words used in an unusual or restricted way, including idioms and  jargon.

Note: This success criterion is in DRAFT form. It is presented to the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines Working Group as a formal proposal, but it has not earned the consensus of the Working Group, and it does not appear in the current Public Working Draft at http://www.w3.org/tr/wcag20. It is presented here for discussion only. It must not be cited as a normative reference.

 

 

Understanding Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

Key terms and important concepts

Text content

[WCAG definition of text goes here]

Available

Ready for use or service; usable

[Note: The baseline impact analysis for guidelines and SC recommended that the phrase “is available]” be used in this and a number of other SC as a way to describe a “functional outcome.” I am concerned that the phrase is vague and subject to intentional  misinterpretation—e.g., a mechanism is available but we didn’t implement it.” To avoid this, we may want to consider changing “mechanism is available” to something like “mechanism has been implemented” or “is available to the user.”]

Intended definition

The intended definition for any word used in an unusual or very particular way is the exact definition that users must know in order to understand the content.

 

 

 

 

Intent of this success criterion

The intent of this success criterion is to ensure that definitions are available for:

·         Idiomatic expressions (words or phrases specific to a region or language that do not mean what the dictionary definitions say. For example, the English phrase “he blew his stack” means that someone became very angry.

·         Jargon (words used in a particular way by people in a particular field. For example, the word StickyKeys is jargon from the field of assistive technology/accessibility.)

·         Words that must be understood according to a specific sense listed in the dictionary

Applicability: When does Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1 Apply?

This success criterion applies when text contains specific words that have to be understood in a specific way in order to understand the content.

Techniques for meeting Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

Technology-Independent techniques for Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

There are several ways to address this success criterion.

·         Provide any intended definitions in the text of the delivery unit.

·         Attach a list of dictionaries, glossaries, and other resources to the delivery unit (or collection of delivery units) so that users can find definitions for all words in the text.   The glossary should include any words that must be defined in a particular way in order for the user to understand the content.   Organize the list or “cascade” of dictionaries and other resources so that the definition search will find the intended definitions instead of displaying definitions from other sources in the “cascade.”  (The “cascade” lists the dictionaries and other reference materials in the order most likely to bring up the right definition. This controls the order to follow when searching for definitions.) Include a dictionary of idioms and a dictionary of jargon in the cascade.

 

 

 

Technology-Specific Techniques for Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

Advisory techniques: going beyond Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

·         Use markup and visual formatting to help users recognize words that have special meaning.

·         Provide a voice-enabled dictionary search, so that users who have difficulty typing or spelling can speak the word whose definition they need.

 

Benefits and Examples

Benefits: How Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1 Helps People with Disabilities

This success criterion helps people whose disabilities make reading difficult or impossible. These include:

·         People with learning disabilities or cognitive limitations that impair the ability to read

·         People with low vision. Screen magnification may reduce contextual cues.

·         People with memory loss

 

This success criterion helps people with disabilities that affect their ability to use context to aid understanding. This includes people with certain learning disabilities and cognitive impairments. In addition, people with low vision often lose context when screen magnifiers zoom in on a small area of the screen. This success criterion also helps people who have difficulty recognizing words (decoding) by limiting the number of dictionary entries they must read in order to find the definition that fits the context.

 

 

Examples of Guideline 3.1 L3 SC1

Example 1: Text that includes a definition for a word used in an unusual way.

Organize the list or “cascade” of dictionaries and other resources so that the definition search will find the intended definitions instead of displaying definitions from other sources in the “cascade.”  (The “cascade” lists the dictionaries and other reference materials in the order most likely to bring up the right definition. This controls the order to follow when searching for definitions.)

 

Example 2: Including definitions in the dictionary cascade.

WCAG 2.0 uses the word “text” in a specific way. If the Glossary for WCAG 2.0 appears first in the dictionary cascade, users who want a definition of “text” will get the definition as it appears in the Glossary.  Users who request definitions for words that are not defined in the Glossary will get definitions that appear in whatever dictionary appears in the cascade.

 

 

 

 

Related resources

[Note: The inclusion of a product or vendor name in the list below does not constitute an endorsement by the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines Working Group or the Web Accessibility Initiative of the World Wide Web Consortium. This list is provided simply for convenience, and to give users an idea of what resources may be available.]

·         Free bilingual dictionaries for a number of languages are available from the Freedict.org Web site. The dictionaries are of uneven quality and size, as noted on the site. For more information, see http://www.freedict.org. Retrieved 9 April 2005.

·         The Free Dictionaries and Search Engines site provides access to free online dictionaries and search engines in many languages. For more information, see http://www.stars21.com/index.html?lang=en&pname=african. Retrieved 9 April 2005.