Web Services Policy 1.5 Features and Interop Scenarios

Asir S Vedamuthu, Microsoft Corporation

February 27th, 2007

The following table enumerates features in the Framework and Attachment drafts, identifies features that are covered by interop scenarios on W3C CVS [1] & on-going interop scenario development within the WG and highlights features without any interop scenario coverage.

Legend:

· C – Covered by interop scenarios on W3C CVS

· W – Will be covered by on-going interop scenario development within the WG

· O – Open feature without any interop scenario coverage.

[1] http://dev.w3.org/cvsweb/~checkout~/2006/ws/policy/interop/

Serial	Section Number	Feature	Round 1	Round 2	Round 3	Round 4	Notes
1	P 4	Policy expression	C		C
2	P 4.1	Policy expression - normal form	C		C
3	P 4.1	Policy expression - normal form with nested policy expression	C		C
4	P 4.2	Policy identification – wsu:Id attribute		C	C
5	P 4.2	Policy identification –xml:id attribute		W			Felix – on point
6	P 4.2	Policy identification – Name attribute		C
7	P 4.3	Normalize	C		C
8	P 4.3.1	Compact form - optional policy assertions	C
9	P 4.3.2	Compact form – nested policy expression	C		C
10	P 4.3.3	Compact form – policy operator – Policy	C		C
11	P 4.3.3	Compact form – policy operator – All	C		C
12	P 4.3.3	Compact form – policy operator – ExactlyOne	C		C
13	P 4.3.3	Compact form – policy inclusion		C
14	P 4.3.5	Policy inclusion (expression identified by an ID)		C	C
15	P 4.3.5	Policy inclusion (external policy expression)		C
16	P 4.4	Ignorable policy assertions	C
17	P 4.5	Policy intersection – strict mode	C
18	P 4.5	Policy intersection – lax mode	C
19	P 4.6	Policy expression + XML Base	W				Chris – on point
20	P Appendix A	application/wspolicy+xml media type				W	Glen – on point
21	PA 3.1	Merge	C		C
	PA 3.4	External Policy Attachment
22	PA 3.4.1	URI domain expression + IRI References for WSDL 20 Components				O
23	PA 3.4.1	URI domain expression + WSDL 11 Element Identifiers				W	Ashok – on point
	PA 4	WS-Policy Attachment for WSDL 11
24	PA 4.1.1	Effective policy of a service policy subject		C
25	PA 4.1.2	Effective policy of an endpoint policy subject		C	C
26	PA 4.1.3	Effective Policy of an operation policy subject		C
27	PA 4.1.4	Effective Policy of an input message policy subject		C	C
28	PA 4.1.4	Effective Policy of an output message policy subject		C	C
29	PA 4.1.4	Effective Policy of a fault message policy subject		C
30	PA 5	WS-Policy Attachment for WSDL 20
31	PA 5.4.1	Effective policy of a service policy subject		C
32	PA 5.4.2	Effective policy of an endpoint policy subject		C	C
33	PA 5.4.3	Effective policy of an operation policy subject		C
34	PA 5.4.4	Effective policy of an input message policy subject		C	C
35	PA 5.4.5	Effective policy of an output message policy subject		C	C
36	PA 5.4.6 and PA 5.4.7	Effective policy of an input/output fault message policy subject		C
	PA 6	WS-Policy Attachment for UDDI
37	PA 6.1.1	Effective policy of a service provider policy subject				W	Prasad – on point
38	PA 6.1.2	Effective policy of a service policy subject				W	Prasad – on point
39	PA 6.1.3	Effective policy of an endpoint policy subject				W	Prasad – on point
40	PA 6.3	Referencing remote policy expressions				W	Prasad – on point
41	PA 6.3	Registering reusable policy expressions				W	Prasad – on point
42	PA 6.4	Registering policies in UDDI V3				W	Prasad – on point
43		Negative Test Cases	O	O	O	O