[MINUTES] VCWG Render Method 2026-06-30

This meeting of the VCWG Render Method group was characterized by low
attendance, which was attributed to the upcoming July 4th holiday and
potential conflicts with other conferences. Despite the small turnout, the
attendees engaged in discussions about the relationship between barcode and
render method specifications, the preparation of a threat model document,
and the utilization of existing templates for threat modeling. They also
reviewed the progress on a core use case flow document and agreed to
consolidate their efforts on the threat model document for future review.

*Topics Covered:*

   - *Relationship Between Barcode and Render Method Specs:* The group
   discussed whether the barcode specification could be considered a subset of
   the render method specification, concluding that while related, they
   address distinct concerns. They agreed that the plain barcode method could
   be viewed as a special render method.
   - *Low Attendance at Meeting:* The attendees noted the unusually low
   attendance and speculated on the reasons, including the approaching July
   4th holiday and the possibility of overlapping conferences.
   - *Preparing Threat Model Document:* Dmitri proposed a notes document to
   gather focus constraints and threat models for evaluating render method
   categories, aiming to prefill it before a group exercise.
   - *Focus Constraints and Threat Models:* The discussion shifted to the
   importance of threat modeling for driving the discussion, highlighting how
   it helps answer questions about design choices like using templates versus
   fully baked solutions and identifying privacy concerns.
   - *Using Existing Templates for Threat Modeling:* The attendees
   identified and located a previously used threat modeling template, agreeing
   to copy it into the render method space. They confirmed that a render
   method threat model document had been started but left uncategorized.
   - *Core Use Case Flow Document:* Dmitri offered to transfer the core use
   case documents into the threat model document, which was agreed upon as a
   way to consolidate information.

*Action Items:*

   - Dmitri will clean up the render method threat model document, copy the
   core use case documents into it, and send the consolidated document out to
   the list.
   - The group will reconvene next week or the week after, depending on the
   calendar schedule, to review the prepared threat model document.

HTML:
https://meet.w3c-ccg.org/archives/w3c-vcwg-render-method-2026-06-30.html

Video:
https://meet.w3c-ccg.org/archives/w3c-vcwg-render-method-2026-06-30.mp4

[image: W3C] <https://www.w3.org/>
VCWG Render Method 30 June 2026 Attendees

Present

Dave Longley, Dmitri Zagidulin, Ivan Herman, Phillip Long

Regrets

-

Chair

-

Scribe

transcriber
Contents

   1. Relationship Between Barcode and Render Method Specs <#afd1>
   2. Low Attendance at Meeting <#3829>
   3. Preparing Threat Model Document <#1e08>
   4. Focus Constraints and Threat Models <#b191>
   5. Using Existing Templates for Threat Modeling <#c7ea>
   6. Core Use Case Flow Document <#1195>

Meeting minutes

Dmitri Zagidulin: Hello.

Ivan Herman: How you doing?

Ivan Herman: Mitri, can I ask a question?

Dmitri Zagidulin: Please. Yeah.
Relationship Between Barcode and Render Method Specs

Ivan Herman: Has there ever been discussions or is it a anthema that the
barcode spec is in fact a specification of a render method? Where's she?
What? Dmitri Zagidulin:

Dmitri Zagidulin: Great question. I mean we've definitely mentioned that
they're they go in different directions. barcode is how to fit the
credential inside a barcode. Render method is how to fit barcode and other
stuff inside the credential. from what I understand, the barcode spec has
to do with…

Dmitri Zagidulin: how do we fit the payload verifiable credential into the
constrained envelope of a barcode.

Ivan Herman: It generates a barcode.

Ivan Herman: That's what it does. It renders the credential in the form of
a barcode. here is Dave. He will probably shut me down. you are muted.

Ivan Herman: You became muted somehow.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Dave will be able to answer that better,…

Dmitri Zagidulin: but the short answer to your question is yes, it's been
discussed that they're related. I don't think anybody's made an argument
that the barcode spec is a subset of render method because I think they
deal with slightly different concerns. What do you think, Dave, about the
relationship between barcode and…

Dave Longley: Yeah.

Dmitri Zagidulin: render method specs?

Dave Longley: So, I mean, while a barcode is technically a rendering, at
least one version of what happens in that spec, it is a rendering of a
verifiable credential. the spec also covers cases where it's not only a
rendering of verifiable credential.

Ivan Herman: That is perfect and…

Dave Longley: Yeah and…

Ivan Herman: true. Yeah.

Dave Longley: I think it's got a different concerns. They are certainly
related. and there is also something in the render method spec for you
providing a direct rendering that you could use to render to NFC or…

Dave Longley: to a QR code. So there's a relationship, but I wouldn't say
that they're Yeah.

Ivan Herman: So let me modify the question.

Ivan Herman: I was imprecise when I asked what I would call the plain
barcode method which is just take the credential and turn it into a
barcode. Forget about the other one which is indeed different. if I issue a
credential I might want to give say that one of my preferences to present
this bar this credential is in the form of a barcode.

Ivan Herman: This is exactly what render method has. the issuer puts
information about its preferences on how to render these things. in this
view, the simple barcode method is a special render method.

Dave Longley: plus depending on how it's done plus some potential recursion
if you're going to put the VC itself that has the render method into the
barcode that's a little bit different from providing it as a render method
some details about what you should take and put into a barcode or maybe
repeating the entire payload and saying this is a barcode ren show it as a
barcode. So there's a relationship there for sure.

Dave Longley: But I don't think that we could make the renderer method
subsume the whole barcode spec.

Ivan Herman: I did not meant to do that,…

Ivan Herman: but I should be able the render methods in a spec say
something that my preference is to Use that spec as a rendering.

Dave Longley: Yeah, I think that's related to so we had a short list of
types of render methods that we were talking about in the last meeting and…

Dave Longley: one of them I don't remember what terminology we used but it
was some kind of binary representation or do you happen to remember Demetri
we had categories of render methods?

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yes. Yes.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yes. Yeah.

Dave Longley: One of them had as an example you would use it with NFC but I
think that same type of render method you would use with a QR code. so yes
to what you're saying, Ivon, we got to figure out exactly what the shape of
that looks like. but yes to what you're saying.

Dave Longley: And if we walk through how that works, it might very well
make perfect sense for that to slot into the same type of render method
that you would use with NFC.

Ivan Herman: So it turns out that it is useful that I am working on the 1
version of the overview document…

Ivan Herman: where I have to fit all these things together and make some
sense among them. And that's when I realized that this is an issue. a
question and…

Dave Longley: Yeah, I definitely think it is something that has been on
people's minds from time to time and hasn't fully crystallized with how it
ought to be.

Ivan Herman: we have to address it somewhere at some point.

Dave Longley: Yes. Yeah.
Low Attendance at Meeting

Ivan Herman: So how come we are only the three of us?

Dave Longley: Is there a problem with the meeting invite?

Dmitri Zagidulin: Great question.

Dave Longley: That was my first thought. Are we in the wrong room from
other people?

Dmitri Zagidulin: Okay, So meeting invites says ends with GCR. The call
second is Yeah,…

Ivan Herman: I think we are at the right place.

Dmitri Zagidulin: I think we're at the right place.

Dave Longley: So, is everyone else at the wrong place?

Dmitri Zagidulin: Unclear.

Ivan Herman: Any event…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Let's ping in some channels.

Ivan Herman: which has driven people away to somewhere else.

Dave Longley: There is an ongoing conference I think a napsis conference
and…

Dmitri Zagidulin: No, I don't think so.

Dave Longley: that would definitely involve barcode people.

Dave Longley: But I don't know about render method people despite our
conversation that we just had.

Ivan Herman: No,…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Do we have speaking of…

Dmitri Zagidulin: which do we have a render methods channel on the W3C
slack? No. Okay. Absolutely.

Ivan Herman: We have never talked about it. it's possible to set it up, but
we have never set up any specific channels on Slack or for VC in general. I
believe it seems that people are uneasy to take up yet another way of
communicating.

Dmitri Zagidulin: which is fully understandable. I wish bridging worked
better.

Ivan Herman: But I'm happy to set up a new channel…

Ivan Herman: if it's I think anyone of us can do it. But it seems that this
meeting now is only the three of us.

Dmitri Zagidulin: You're right though that there's a chicken and egg thing.

Dave Longley: It is also the third everyone has off…

Dave Longley: because July 4th in the US has happened. So a lot of people
take this week off for a vacation.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, I was wondering.

Ivan Herman: What?

Dmitri Zagidulin: I was wondering about that…

Ivan Herman: That people take the whole week in this case,…

Dmitri Zagidulin: if it's early July 4th.

Dave Longley: And maybe in particular it's the 250th birthday of the United
States. So they might be super pumped.

Ivan Herman: but we got more people at the previous task force.

Dave Longley: That is true.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, I wonder I do not know.
Preparing Threat Model Document

Dmitri Zagidulin: But I thought while we're waiting for folks to show Dave
Lane says that summer on another call should be over soon. So maybe another
call is running late. the VC barcode call specific.

Ivan Herman: No, no,…

Ivan Herman: no, no, no. We were both on.

Dmitri Zagidulin: No, no, you just from there.

Ivan Herman: Yeah, we both come from there.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Okay. yeah,…

Dmitri Zagidulin: great question.

Ivan Herman: As Greg said,…

Ivan Herman: we all have a to-do list, so we can just call it a

Dmitri Zagidulin: Right, right, right, right. yes, can do in case it's
helpful to either one of Here is I dropped a link in Google chat here to a
notes document that I was proposing the group to go over with that gathers
together our focus constraints and the threat models. against which we're
going to be evaluating the for method categories, right? So just lists out
what are we trying to do which is detail view and list view. We need to be
able to render PDFs.
Focus Constraints and Threat Models

Dmitri Zagidulin: We have the spectrum of fully quote unquote baked at
issuance time versus templated. And Phil. Hey.

Phillip Long: How are you?

Dmitri Zagidulin: We're for whatever reason smaller group today. we're not
sure whether people are celebrating July 4th earlier or there's another
conference or the 4th.

Phillip Long: I suspect for the former Yeah.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah. Yeah. but welcome anyways. Dave, you have your hand
up?

Dave Longley: Yeah, I think this is useful and to get some of the use cases
in there and I see a couple of threat model notes. I can't remember in this
group, we have all these task force a bunch of them started doing some
threat modeling exercises. I can't remember if we did that here in the
render method group. but in those other task force we opened up a document
and just wrote down a bunch of threats and…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Mh And that's kind of what I was hoping to do here. Yeah.
Yes.

Dave Longley: yeah so we had a pattern for that and it works better if we
have more people because everybody can sort of jump in and…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yes. Yes.

Dave Longley: put those in there and…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yes. Right.

Dave Longley: I do think that's a good way to drive the discussion forward
so that we can get an idea of a lot of those threat model things are things
that it will answer questions like why are we doing this with a template
instead of just putting it fully baked? what or…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Right. Right.

Dave Longley: …

Dmitri Zagidulin: Right. Right.

Dave Longley: what happens if we put a link to a fully baked thing. these
are these great privacy concerns and so getting all of that down can help
us get the shape of explain sort of where some of the things came from and…

Dave Longley: help us figure out where to

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, agreed.

Dmitri Zagidulin: That's exactly the idea. that once we have more people,
I'm hoping to go through that exercise here to see anything we've missed.
but in case we want to adjourn early, I just wanted to put it out there in
case Dave you Ivonne Phil you glanced and you're like, " yeah, we forgot
this thing." Prefill it before we do the group exercise.

Dave Longley: Yes. Okay. So I have the link.

Dave Longley: And…
Using Existing Templates for Threat Modeling

Phillip Long: Didn't we have a template for this already that we've used in
multiple places?

Dave Longley: yeah. Yeah,…

Phillip Long: It might be wise.

Dave Longley: that's what I was getting at. And I was going to see if I
could find that.

Phillip Long: That's what I'm looking for right now.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah. Mhm.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Mhm. Yep. We can absolutely use a Google Doc template.

Phillip Long: Here it I've got it, I think. is that right? This may be one
that's partially filled out. let me just put the link in and I'll put it in
chat here if I can find where my there we are. Is that accessible?

Phillip Long: I don't know whether that's mine or whether that's a copy
from a public one.

Dave Longley: Yeah, that's Yeah. And now it might be…
Core Use Case Flow Document

Phillip Long: Was that an early one? I can't recall. Mhm.

Dave Longley: but we could just copy this one into a render method space.
Did we not do this in the render method task force?

Dmitri Zagidulin: No, we have not.

Dmitri Zagidulin: We did another task forces though.

Dave Longley: So, I don't want to stomp on the template, but if somebody
knows…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, we can make a copy.

Dave Longley: where to put that copy,

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, let me here's the VCOM threat model draft. but
that's one extensive. Yeah. Yeah.

Phillip Long: Yeah, that one's extensive.

Phillip Long: I was looking I thought there was one that was put out there
and this may not be the right choice, but I'll keep looking. there's also
the guide. I mean, it might be worth sending around as well that Joe Andreo
did.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Right. Yeah.

Phillip Long: I've got the link for that if you need it.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah. Yeah. Paste the link.

Phillip Long: Wait a minute.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Is that Yeah.

Phillip Long: Yeah, this template maybe this no. You've sent this around
before, haven't you? your template really…

Dmitri Zagidulin: I have not. No. No.

Phillip Long: because I just found it in my bookmarks.

Dmitri Zagidulin: the one that I just said also that's from recognized
entities threat modeling. wait a second. render method thread model.

Phillip Long: Here's the one that I just found.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Here's the render method one.

Dave Longley: Yeah, I think I just found our link.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Okay. Yep.

Dave Longley: Mhm. And this.

Dmitri Zagidulin: I got it. Excellent. Perfect. So …

Dave Longley: So, we did start this.

Dmitri Zagidulin: we did do this. That's right. Okay. Yep.

Dave Longley: it just got left as uncatategorized.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Mhm.

Phillip Long: Yeah, we started this.

Dave Longley: So if…

Dmitri Zagidulin: Right. Yeah.

Dave Longley: if the three I think you had three or four threats on that
dock you were drawing Demetri…

Dave Longley: if you just want to copy those over. Mhm.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah. Yep. Yeah.

Dmitri Zagidulin: I'll do that. The Yes.

Phillip Long: The link I put out has 15 items uncatategorized,…

Phillip Long: right? Yeah. Okay. Okay.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Yeah, I think that's the one we're all looking at.

Phillip Long: This won't Okay.

Dmitri Zagidulin: And here's the steps for the core use case flow. So I can
transfer the core use case documents there.

Phillip Long: So, why don't you clean that up and send it all out to the
list? yeah,…

Dmitri Zagidulin: And we can do that for the Sounds good.

Phillip Long: exactly. We've got a lot accomplished on this call next week.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Okay, we'll do. All right. Hey, this is great. Yeah.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Great seeing all of you. we will reconvene next week or…

Ivan Herman: Bye-bye.

Dmitri Zagidulin: the week after that whichever way the schedule the
calendar dictates.

Dave Longley: Thanks.

Dmitri Zagidulin: Thanks all. Cheers.

Phillip Long: See him. Meeting ended after 00:19:08 👋 This editable
transcript was computer generated and might contain errors. People can also
change the text after it was created.

This transcription was generated by a large language model (LLM) and might
contain errors. When in doubt, check the audio recording. This page was
formatted by scribe.perl <https://w3c.github.io/scribe2/scribedoc.html>
version 248 (Mon Oct 27 20:04:16 2025 UTC).

Received on Friday, 3 July 2026 15:46:11 UTC