See also: IRC log
Resolution: Minutes accepted
<scribe> Pending Action for Kumar - updated estimate - next week.
<scribe> Pending Action for MSM - updated estimate - next week.
Mark as resolved - invalid
Resolution: Mark as fixed - resolved
Resolution: Mark as fixed - resolved
Resolution: Mark as editorial - fix per comments 2 and 3
Resolution: Mark as editorial
<johnarwe> http://www.w3.org/TR/2008/WD-sml-20080303/#targetStar_schema_validity
<johnarwe> MSM notes that nested occurs 2x
Resolution: Mark as editorial - fix per comment 2 - note that text occurs in two places.
Resolution: Mark as resolved -
invalid
... Mark as resolved - fixed
<MSM> [Studying the draft of January and HT's note, I conclude that the 'inconsistency' he meant was that sometimes xmlns() was used and sometimes not. That has indeed been fixed.]
MSM: Prefers we use the term 'implementation-defined' rather than 'implementation-dependent'
<scribe> ACTION: MSM to open a separate bug to address this issue. [recorded in http://www.w3.org/2008/04/10-sml-minutes.html#action01]
<trackbot-ng> Created ACTION-180 - Open a separate bug to address this issue. [on Michael Sperberg-McQueen - due 2008-04-17].
<johnarwe> Updated action in db so it is self-contained. Scribes: we have found it awkward in the past to have Actions show up that are not self-describing... requires going back to the minutes for context. Please try to avoid repeating that.
Resolution: Mark as resolved - fixed
Resolution: Mark as editorial - needsReview. Define terms based on defintions in Comment 1 but not reference them.
John: Concern is that other specs would be prevented from layering on top of SML.
Kumar requested more time to consider this.
Resolution: Mark as needsAgreement
<johnarwe> MSM: xs:anyType is in fact a GTD
<johnarwe> MSM: if we make any changes based on 5636, may need to hit the text for this bug.
<johnarwe> I will try to find the discussion that Kumar and Sandy vaguely remember us having about this section, and consider that.
Resolution: Mark as needsAgreement
John: Suggests those who are interested in this bug take the discussion ofline.
Sandy: Thinks that at one point the spec was worded in reference to the Rules property and was changed. We should take a look at the CVS history.
Kumar, Sandy, and MSM will investigate this and bring findings back to the group.
Resolution: Mark as needsAgreement
Kirk posted a new revision of the proposal today.
Resolution: No change to status
John added a new comment regarding a change that needs to be addressed
Resolution: Make the change in comment 5 and review next week.
Resolution: Leaving 5541 as needs review, will pick up again next week
Resolution: Leave as needsReview. Kumar will add link to bug for note on XLink.
Last Scribe Date Member Name Regrets pending 2007-08-30 Lipton, Paul until mid-January 2008 2008-02-14 McCarthy, Julia 2008-02-21 Kumar, Pandit 2008-03-06 Boucher, Jordan 2008-03-13 Gao, Sandy 2008-04-01 Wilson, Kirk 2008-04-02 Smith, Virginia 4/24 and 5/1 2008-04-02 Eckert, Zulah 2008-04-10 Lynn, James Exempt Arwe, John Exempt Dublish, Pratul Exempt MSM Exempt PH