- From: Jori Lehtinen <lehtinenjori03@gmail.com>
- Date: Sun, 14 Jun 2026 12:36:20 +0300
- To: Amir Hameed <amsaalegal@gmail.com>
- Cc: W3C Credentials CG <public-credentials@w3.org>
- Message-ID: <CAA6zkAtkAMn_TZUT8SVBRJj4EeFXYUFxSzGCSk=_i-PsP1uDbg@mail.gmail.com>
Hi Amir. “Log” based verification methods provide migration quite cleanly. New PQ public keys are created, and the log entry is signed by the previous non-post-quantum private key and possibly witnesses. From a verifier application standpoint, they just need to support the relevant Data Integrity suites and route to the verification path using the suite the proof declares. So, as a verifier, support PQC suites and ECC suites, and then prefer a log-based approach that allows you to verify forward from a known key. This way, the migration happens whenever an issuer chooses to use PQC algorithms. Also, a dual-signature approach is a good concept, and I was wondering why this was not covered in the PQC Data Integrity draft, but I never said anything. https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/ir/2024/NIST.IR.8547.ipd.pdf NIST IR 8547 initial public draft states: “NIST will accommodate the use of a hybrid key-establishment mode and dual signatures in FIPS 140 validation when suitably combined with a NIST-approved scheme.” Here some drafts I found attempting to specify schemes: https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/html/draft-ietf-lamps-pq-composite-sigs https://www.ietf.org/archive/id/draft-ietf-openpgp-pqc-16.html But I don’t know if another Data Integrity suite is needed. There is already a W3C Recommendation for EdDSA Data Integrity, and there is an experimental draft for quantum-resistant Data Integrity cryptosuites. Maybe a hybrid suite specified based on those would be a good idea. ECC: https://www.w3.org/TR/vc-di-eddsa/ PQC: https://w3c.github.io/vc-di-quantum-resistant/ I’m not sure whether there is already a PQC Data Integrity suite on the W3C standards track. That experimental draft is what I found quickly, and perhaps a section on hybrid signatures and/or pqc migration in general could be added to it. Also, for anyone wondering, the motivation for a hybrid suite is that PQC algorithms do not yet have the same amount of real-world deployment experience as ECC. If a breaking vulnerability is found in the PQC scheme, verification would still require the ECC signature to pass. I guess that is a long way to say that I might be interested in contributing :p But for me, the requirement would be that we specify an algorithm-agnostic key management solution and an algorithm-agnostic Data Integrity suite that can handle whichever algorithms are recommended over time. In my opinion, anything less is not sustainable. su 14.6.2026 klo 9.07 ap. Amir Hameed <amsaalegal@gmail.com> kirjoitti: > Dear Community Members, > > I would like to propose a new W3C CCG work item focused on defining a > practical and interoperable post-quantum migration pattern for Verifiable > Credentials using a dual Data Integrity proof approach (Ed25519 + ML-DSA). > > The objective of this work is to document a real-world migration strategy > that enables Verifiable Credentials ecosystems to transition from classical > elliptic-curve cryptography to post-quantum cryptography in a safe and > incremental manner, without requiring changes to the existing Verifiable > Credentials Data Model or the Data Integrity framework. > > This effort is intended as an incubation-level CCG note and implementation > guide, rather than a specification introducing new cryptographic primitives > or modifying existing standards. > > Scope of the Proposed Work > > The work will focus on: > > A dual-signature credential pattern combining Ed25519 and ML-DSA > > Verification semantics, including both strict and migration-compatible > verification modes > Use of existing Data Integrity cryptosuites without modification > > A practical and interoperable migration strategy for issuers and verifiers > during transition periods > > Why This Matters > > The ecosystem is entering an early but critical transition phase toward > post-quantum cryptography. While ML-DSA and related schemes are becoming > standardized, there is currently no widely adopted, practical migration > pattern for Verifiable Credentials that allows classical and post-quantum > signatures to coexist during this transition period. > > This work aims to fill that gap by providing a clear, implementable, and > interoperable approach that can be adopted incrementally across real-world > systems. > > Seeking Participation > > I am currently seeking collaborators in the following roles: > > 1. Co-Editors > > Individuals interested in actively shaping and maintaining the work item. > Relevant expertise may include: > > Verifiable Credentials and Data Integrity specifications > > Digital signature systems (Ed25519 and post-quantum schemes such as ML-DSA) > Cryptographic protocol design and implementation experience > > Participation in standards development or interoperability work (optional > but valuable) > > 2. Contributors / Reviewers > > Participants who would like to review, provide feedback, or contribute > implementation perspectives, particularly from: > > VC wallet and issuer implementations > Verifier infrastructure and backend systems > Post-quantum cryptography migration initiatives > > Collaboration Model > > Given the global and distributed nature of the W3C CCG, collaboration will > be primarily asynchronous, using: > > GitHub issues and pull requests > Structured technical discussions and review cycles > Optional participation in CCG calls when available > > Synchronous participation is not required for meaningful contribution. > > If you are interested in contributing as a co-editor or reviewer, please > reply to this email or reach out directly. Early feedback on scope and > framing is especially welcome before formal submission as a CCG work item. > > I look forward to collaborating with the community on this important > transition effort. > > Best regards, > Aamir Hameed Mir > >
Received on Sunday, 14 June 2026 09:36:36 UTC