18:09 < cwilso> scribenick: joe
18:09 < cwilso> zakim, take up agendum 1
18:09 < Zakim> agendum 1. "review of action items" taken up [from cwilso]
18:10 < cwilso> http://www.w3.org/2011/audio/track/agenda
18:10 < cwilso> action-80
18:10  * trackbot is looking up action-80.
18:10 < trackbot> action-80 -- Chris Wilson to Remove webaudio section on example applications, photos from section on convolution, and salvage anything valuable -- due 2014-01-09 -- OPEN
18:10 < trackbot> http://www.w3.org/2011/audio/track/actions/80
18:10 < joe> cwilso: action-80 is still on my plate
18:11 < cwilso> action-90
18:11  * trackbot is looking up action-90.
18:11 < trackbot> action-90 -- Chris Wilson to Look into https://github.com/webaudio/web-audio-api/issues/15 - assess how complex the change would be (and ideally suggest pr to spec) -- due 2014-01-09 -- OPEN
18:11 < trackbot> http://www.w3.org/2011/audio/track/actions/90
18:11 < joe> cwilso: Paul can't join to discuss math osc this week
18:12 < joe> cwilso: question is whether one can redundantly call stop multiple times rather than throw exc
18:12 < joe> rtoyg: don't see an issue with that
18:12 < joe> cwilso: my off the cuff proposal was 1st stop takes effect and others are no-ops
18:13 < joe> rtoyg: actually what we want is to say that the chronologically first-scheduled stop takes effect, not the first invocation of stop()
18:15 < cwilso> joe: it would make sense to me to have the most recent (last stop() invocation) take effect.
18:15 < cwilso> joe: i.e. an overwrite of the last stop().
18:16 < joe> cwilso: I'll record this as the current proposal
18:16 < joe> cwilso: and stop() will not throw if playback has already ceased
18:18 < joe> cwilso: tabling discussion of visible data races since no one from Mozilla on call
18:19 < Zakim> agendum 3. "spec milestone review" taken up [from cwilso]
18:20 < cwilso> http://www.w3.org/2011/audio/wiki/W3C_Audio_Publications_and_Milestones#Latest_Estimates
18:22 < cwilso> agenda+ dynamics compressor
18:22  * Zakim notes agendum 5 added
18:24 < cwilso> cwilso: milestones - I think Q1 LC for Audio is unlikely, personally.  For MIDI, it's still possible.
18:25 < joe> cwilso: F2F meetings only remaining item. Unsure what Olivier wanted to say
18:26 < joe> cwilso: Suggest Santa Clara convention venue
18:27 < joe> cwilso: TPAC is a long way off and attendance is sometimes difficulty
18:28 < joe> cwilso: date for that is October 27-31
18:28 < joe> cwilso: we wouldn't be meeting for the entire 4-day window
18:28 < cwilso> joe: it's possible for me
18:28 < joe> joe: it's possible for me
18:28 < joe> Doug_Schepers: it's possible but don't want to commit
18:28  * jernoble can attend then
18:33 < joe> cwilso: proposal to remove pre-emphasis and post-emphasis features that were in the Chrome de facto implementation of DynamicCompressor
18:33 < joe> jernoble: that's OK with me
18:33 < cwilso> zakim, close agenda 5
18:33 < Zakim> agendum 5, dynamics compressor, closed
18:33 < Zakim> I see nothing remaining on the agenda