[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

PSO-PC Position on the Alternative Roots Issue



Dear Stuart,
On behalf of the Protocol Council, I'm sending you the Position of the
PSO-PC on the Alternative Roots Issue. It was agreed that each Protocol
Supporting Organization gives also its comments/statements concerning 
the Alternative Roots Issue.

The PSO Statement is:

"The Internet DNS currently operates using a Single Authoritative Root
Server System. Although, it would be technically possible to devise and
standardize a fully compliant alternative multiple root server system, 
there appears to be no technical reason for changing from the present 
working system, as this would require the development of a new set of 
protocols for use by the DNS."

Additional IETF statement:

"The Internet currently operates using a tree-structured name space 
known as the DNS.  Of necessity, such a name space must have a single, 
authoritative root. Moving to a model that would not require such a 
single, authoritative root would require replacing the present, working 
DNS with some other system. Such a replacement would require the 
development of a new naming paradigm, as well as the protocols and 
software to implement it. Developing and deploying such replacement 
protocols would take years, and would have enormous potential for 
disruption of the Internet.  IETF does not see any technical benefit 
in such an effort."

The ITU-T Study Group 2 conclusion on the Alternative Roots Issue, 
which was reached during the ITU-T Study Group 2 meeting (Geneva, 4-14 
September 2001) states:

"Study Group 2 has noted the PSO statement and has no objections to it.
However, Study Group 2 notes that there may be other issues in 
addition to technical reasons such as administrative and national 
sovereignty considerations."

ETSI supports the IETF statement and the ITU-T Study Group 2 statement.
ETSI considers that the ITU-T Study Group 2 statement  is outside the scope
of the PSO.
W3C supported IETF Statement.