W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > xml-editor@w3.org > July to September 2001

Attribute default values containing entity references

From: Rob Lugt <roblugt@elcel.com>
Date: Wed, 18 Jul 2001 13:23:20 +0100
Message-ID: <053001c10f84$6ee5faf0$0400a8c0@scott>
To: <xml-dev@lists.xml.org>
Cc: <xml-editor@w3.org>
The XML 1.0 recommendation is clear about how attribute default values
should be interpreted:-

4.4 - Parameter Entity references are not recognised
2.3 [AttValue] - General Entity references are expanded
3.3.2 - (updated by errata E9) "The declared default value must meet the
syntactic constraints of the declared attribute type"

I suspect that the motivation for not allowing parameter entities was to
allow implementations to parse the attribute default value exactly as if it
occurred in document content.  However, when parsing document content the
parser knows that all entities will have already been declared, but this is
not the case when parsing the DTD.  So, implementations using this technique
will likely complain if an attribute default value contains a reference to
an entity that has not yet been declared.

For example, do you think the following XML is valid?.

<!DOCTYPE test [
<!ELEMENT test EMPTY>
<!ATTLIST test attr CDATA "&ge;">
<!ENTITY ge "default value">
]>
<test/>

It fails in every parser that I have tried (expat, xerces, msxml3, the W3C
Validator and our XML Validator) because the general entity &ge; is
referenced before it is declared.  This seems quite reasonable to me and is
nicely consistent, but is it desirable?  Some people may find it surprising
given that elsewhere in the DTD general entities can be referenced before
they are declared.

Perhaps it would clarify the situation if the XML 1.0 recommendation made
this behaviour explicit.

Regards
~Rob

--
Rob Lugt
ElCel Technology
http://www.elcel.com/
Received on Wednesday, 18 July 2001 08:23:34 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Monday, 7 December 2009 10:59:31 GMT