Some clarification on exit criteria and CR period

After talking with my colleagues, I got the following information:

- Exit Criteria: in order to move from CR to the next step, the
   WG will have to fulfill each item of the exit criteria. That
   is, if we said that part of the exit criteria was two implementations
   of feature x, we will need to have them to move on. That's the
   first thing that we'll get asked when requesting the move.
   
- CR period: whatever is the period we ask for, it's considered
  the _minimal_ period for the CR evaluation. That is, if we ask
  for 6 months and we find all is ready in 4 months, we will have
  to wait 6 months before requesting the move.

This having been said, if you still agree with the exit criteria on
[1] and a 6 month CR period, we will go forward with them.

For the exit criteria in [1], I'm wondering if we should only require
Soap 1.2, rather than request both Soap 1.1 and Soap 1.2. Following
the same thought track, I don't know how to evaluate the importance
of the last one, the Payload Authentication and TLS bindings
criteria because I don't know if everyone has to implement those
features or if they are optional. There will have to be at least one
implementation.

[1] http://www.w3.org/2001/XKMS/rqim.html#cr-crit

Received on Friday, 30 January 2004 14:28:45 UTC