Re%3A%20scxml%20Historic%20ancestor%20entry%20states&In-Reply-To=%253CCAMZOHDMF8%2BG%3DuqwRz1U3goTPRRTVKz7hDS-B3XML7kKJ34weuA%40mail.gmail.com%253E&References=%253CCAMZOHDMF8%2BG%3DuqwRz1U3goTPRRTVKz7hDS-B3XML7kKJ34weuA%40mail.gmail.com%253E

Really the parent of the history state will be entered or not dependending
on the LCA and the if the transition is internal or not, so I think the
ancestors should be calculated with the parent of the history only (not the
grandparent):

*getProperAncestors(**s,state.parent*)

So in the example, when the transition r-->h occurs:
LCA= root (and yes, I ment scxml)
exit state r
enter state s
enter state h, so
--> enter state s22
--> properAncestors(s22,h.parent)= properAncestors(s22,s)= [s2]
-- -->enter s2


If the transition would be from a children of s to h with internal flag
then s will not be entered.

Do you agree with this?