W3C home > Mailing lists > Public > www-smil@w3.org > July to September 2001

Minor typos in PR-smil20-20010605

From: Susan Lesch <lesch@w3.org>
Date: Thu, 5 Jul 2001 15:07:05 -0700
Message-Id: <p05100307b76a938f8a8d@[]>
To: www-smil@w3.org
These are very minor typos in the SMIL 2.0 Proposed Recommendation
at http://www.w3.org/TR/2001/PR-smil20-20010605/. There are no
show stoppers here, just minor editorial suggestions.

Below, a section and paragraph number is followed by a quote and then
a suggestion.

Status par. 7
specification, these may
specification; these may

2.1 par. 3
Identical constructs eases authoring
Identical constructs ease authoring

2.1 par. 5
XML namespaces (or, Namespaces in XML)

2.1.1 par. 1
SMIL Modularization and Profiling
SMIL modularization and profiling

2.1.1 par. 4
both; "SMIL 2.0" in the example
both - "SMIL 2.0" in the example

2.1.1 par. 7
an integration set does not.
an integration set need not.

2.2.1 par. 1
In future,
In the future,

2.2.1 par. 2
DOM being supported, corresponds
DOM being supported corresponds

2.5 par. 13
attributes on the media objects, other attributes
attributes on the media objects; other attributes

3.2.1 par. ~12

3.4.1 attributeName and attributeType

4.2.2 Predefined Test Attributes

There seems to be an extra [XML-NS].

as list of XML Namespace prefixes
as a list of XML namespace prefixes

4.3.1 last par.
If the user have not
If the user has not

5.2 par. 2
Like SMIL 1.0, SMIL 2.0 BasicLayout modules includes
Like SMIL 1.0, the SMIL 2.0 BasicLayout module includes

In 5.3.1, the tables have this markup:
<TABLE width="856" border="1">
<TABLE width="852" border="1">
On the Web, the width of the viewport is usually unknown. Please remove
width attributes.

regions (twice)

5.5.1 last par.

[[SMIL 1.0]]
[SMIL 1.0]

5.7.1 par. 5
and given a method
and give a method (or be given)

5.9.1 last list item 1
z-index of "inset
z-index of "inset"

SMIL HierarchicalLayout module does not
The SMIL HierarchicalLayout module does not

5.10.2 Sub-region Positioning Attributes
element .

5.10.2 Region fit override par. 1

both language's
both languages'

6.4 accesskey
This accounts for the possibility
This allows for the possibility

6.4 example two
the two link inside
the two links inside

6.5.2 nohref

6.5.2 example 1
answering )

6.6.1 fragment
If this user clicks
If the user clicks

7.1 par. 2

7.3.1 type needs links for [RTSP], [HTTP], [FTP], and [URI].

7.4.1 valuetype and 7.10.1 second list item 1
URI ( [URI] )

7.9.1 abstract
metadata, unless you mean the module in chapter 8 (SMIL
Metainformation) and if so, this could have a link

7.10 Appendicies
7.10 Appendices

8. Title element
The SMIL 2.0 Metadata Module
The SMIL 2.0 Metainformation Module

Globally in 8, Metadata -> metadata (except in DC)

elements and attributes allowing to describe SMIL documents.
elements and attributes that allow description of SMIL documents.

8.2.2 par. 1
with a SMIL documents
with a SMIL document

8.2.3 twice
Metadata RDF Schema
metadata RDF schema

use standard Metadata schema
use standard Metadata schemas

8.3.1 name

the root element to RDF tree
the root element of the RDF tree

     The example uses the Dublin Core version 1.0 RDF Schema [DC] and
     an hypothetic SMIL Metadata RDF Schema:
becomes (five small changes)
     The example uses the Dublin Core version 1.0 RDF schema [DC] and
     a hypothetical SMIL metadata RDF schema:

9.1 par. 2
is composed out of the
is composed of the


9.3 par. 1
must be added included on all elements
must be included on all elements

9.3 par. 3
This realizes a so-called hybrid document type
This creates a so-called hybrid document type

XML namespaces

10. TOC last item in 10.3.1

10.3.1 begin and end
either a SMIL 1.0 syncbase declaration,
a semi-colon separated list of values.
either a SMIL 1.0 syncbase declaration,
or a semi-colon separated list of values.

     In addition, Id-values and Event-symbols are XML NMTOKEN values
     and as such are allowed to contain the dot '.' and hyphen '-'
     characters. The backslash character '\
It would be nice to use current Unicode names:
     In addition, Id-values and Event-symbols are XML NMTOKEN values
     and as such are allowed to contain the full stop '.' and
     hyphen-minus '-' characters. The reverse solidus character '\'
     dot separator and minus sign
     full stop and hyphen-minus
and globally
     backslash '\' escape character
     reverse solidus '\' escape character

10.3.1 clock values
Can the BNF indicate the leading zero in one-digit hours?

10.3.1 ID-Reference values
"Author" can be any gender.
     If an author wishes to simulate this behavior in this version of
     SMIL Timing and Synchronization, she can include the value
     "indefinite" in the list of values for the begin or end
     When this behavior needs to be simulated in this version of
     SMIL Timing and Synchronization, an author can include the
     value "indefinite" in the list of values for the begin or end

[[SMIL Animation]]
[SMIL Animation] (and needs a link)

Begin 3 seconds after an "focus" event on "x"
Begin 3 seconds after a "focus" event on "x"

10.3.1 endsync

the endsync="last"

media. If

See also the section The excl time container.
See also the section The excl element. (and the link can wrap the title)

10.3.1 restart

syncBehavior attribute

10.3.1 syncBehaviorDefault
behavior )

10.3.1 timeAction
This may have presentation side-effect
This may have presentation side effects

10.3.2 pauseDisplay
<span class="einst-priorityClass einst">priorityClass, but </span>
<span class="einst-priorityClass einst">priorityClass</span>, but

10.3.2 Side effects of activation
     <a href="#Timing-HyperlinkImplicationsOnSeqExcl">I</a>mplications
     of beginElement() and hyperlinking for <a
     href="smil-timing.html#edef-seq" class="noxref"><span
     class="einst-seq einst">seq</span></a> and <a
     href="smil-timing.html#edef-excl" class="noxref"><span
     class="einst-excl einst">excl</span></a> time containers.
links only to the "I". Could read:
     <a href="#Timing-HyperlinkImplicationsOnSeqExcl">Implications of
     beginElement() and hyperlinking for seq and excl time

media-marker-values are

10.3.3 Principles for building and pruning intervals
10.3.3 in general is lacking the element and attribute markup that is
present in the rest of the spec. You may want to add it. In this
subsection, words are emphasized with asterisks. They should be marked
up <em>. See "*intervals* and not *instance times*" and "*unresolved*".

straightforward (It's a word.)

I don't know what to make of "INDEFINITE" and "UNRESOLVED." Could they
be marked up as HTML <code>?

Let a be a video
Let "A" be a video
(Also, these variables could be marked up to match "Implications....")

is performed

10.3.3 Time container duration
the respective sections: The par element, The seq element, and The 
excl element.
the respective sections: the par element, the seq element, and the 
excl element.
(or change the anchors to include three words each)

"presenting a document"means
"presenting a document" means

document begin

document end


11. TOC

11.1.3 Examples
( for example
(for example

11.1.3 The speed attribute
playback speed .
playback speed.

end. (i.e.
end (i.e.

11.1.5 last list
Thus the next interval (if there is any)
Thus the next interval (if there is one)

The purpose of this document
The purpose of this section (or, chapter)
(The reader may be looking at the entire spec.)

"We" is used 9 times in just this small section. The first person
should be avoided because it is apparently hard to translate (see
A possible alternative:

     Now that a taxonomy of transition types and subtypes is defined,
     we now discuss a "style-like" shorthand syntax for transitions.
     This shorthand syntax requires specification of the following:

     1.    The class of transition to be applied. For instance, to use a
     1-second left-to-right wipe in a presentation, the wipe is defined as
     a transition class defined with the transition element.

     2.    The media elements to which this transition class is applied. In
     this shorthand syntax, the transition class is applied to the
     media element with the transIn and transOut attributes.

12.4.3 list item 2
the affect of the fill value on
the effect of the fill value on

12.4.3 list item 4
     The active duration for the media element to be transitioned to
     (the destination media) must either overlap the active duration
     or the fill state for the media element to be transitioned from
     (the background).
(This isn't perfect, but it does omit the "we"s.)

In section 12, elements, attributes, and attribute values could be
marked up as they are in the rest of the spec. (Some do match.)
Thus, in 12.4.3 Use of fill="transition"
     elements such as <par>, <seq>, and <excl>. If fill="transition"
     elements such as <a href="smil-timing.html#edef-par"
     class="noxref"><span class="einst-par einst">par</span></a>, <a
     href="smil-timing.html#edef-seq" class="noxref"><span
     class="einst-seq einst">seq</span></a>, and <a
     href="smil-timing.html#edef-excl" class="noxref"><span
     class="einst-excl einst">excl</span></a>. If <a
     href="smil-timing.html#adef-fill" class="noxref"><span
     class="ainst-fill ainst">fill</span></a>="<span

In Slideshow example with transitions, the "we"s can be cut from the
unordered list with little or no lost meaning. For example,
    At 0 seconds, we cut directly to butterfly.jpg. 
    At 0 seconds, cut(s) directly to butterfly.jpg. 

The extra tr at the end of 12.8.5 Table 5 can be omitted; the extra
hr in it isn't needed.

In 13 globally, Content Model -> content model

In 13.1, can "This document specifies the second version of the
Synchronized Multimedia Integration Language (SMIL, pronounced
"smile")." be cut? This is the purpose of the entire Recommendation,
not only the profile.

13.2 list item 3

Could four sections be moved up in numbering, to create a conformance
section under, say, 13.3? Like this:
13.3 Conformance
     13.3.1 Document Conformance (move the section "Conforming SMIL 
2.0 Documents" to here)
	13.3.2 Conforming SMIL 2.0 User Agents
13.4 Normative Definition of the SMIL 2.0 Language Profile

13.3.2 (twice)
conforming SMIL 2.0 Document
conforming SMIL 2.0 document

In 13.3.2, support for XML Base is stated about three times in a row.
Maybe try cutting the second instance:

     SMIL 2.0 deprecates base as a property value for the content
     attribute of the meta element of SMIL 1.0 in favor of the more
     general XML Base URI mechanisms [XMLBase]. XML Base is supported
     on all elements, and affects the interpretation of URIs as
     specified in the individual modules defining the URI attributes.
     Specifically.... (Continue as one paragraph.)


13.3.3 second table
class (NMTOKEN)

13.3.3 last line
elements are in parenthesis.
elements are in parentheses.

In 13.3.4 through 13.3.12, the tables could have an additional th with
rowspan="3", containing the name of the modules. (As it stands now, they
all are labelled "Elements, Attributes, Content Model."

13.3.4 Integration definitions
black color, values greater
black color; values greater

The Layout Modules defines
The Layout Modules define

13.3.6 table (twice)
backgroundColor (background-color)

area (anchor)


in the table:

sourcePlaystate(play | pause | stop) 'pause'
sourcePlaystate (play | pause | stop) 'pause'

(Schedule | MediaContent | ContentControl | Animation )*
(Schedule | MediaContent | ContentControl | Animation)*

tabbing order, inactive elements
tabbing order; inactive elements

13.3.8 Media Object Integration Requirements

     The Resource Description Framework is defined in the W3C Metadata
     Recommendation [RDFsyntax].
(There is no "W3C Metadata Recommendation" per se. You could say:)
     The Resource Description Framework is defined in the W3C RDF
     Recommendation [RDFsyntax].

13.3.11 first table (twice, and the outer parentheses in the third occurrence
could be omitted, yes?)
(Schedule | MediaContent | ContentControl | a | Animation )*
(Schedule | MediaContent | ContentControl | a | Animation)*


13.5 (normative)
     All SMIL 2.0 modules are integrated according to the guidelines
     in the "Modularization of SMIL 2.0" specification [SMIL-MOD],
(There is no "Modularization of SMIL 2.0" specification at that address.
Rather, I found "Synchronized Multimedia Modules based upon SMIL 1.0"
with the disclaimer:)
     This document is a NOTE made available by W3C for discussion
     only. This indicates no endorsement of its content, nor that W3C
     has, is, or will be allocating any resources to the issues
     addressed by the NOTE.

14.2 par. 4
extending the SMIL Basic
extending SMIL Basic (or maybe, extending the SMIL Basic profile)

allowed by the SMIL Basic
allowed by SMIL Basic (or maybe, allowed by the SMIL Basic profile)

     The browsers conforming to the SMIL 2.0 language profile will be
     automatically conforming to SMIL 2.0 Basic.
could be:
     User agents conforming to the SMIL 2.0 language profile
     automatically conform to SMIL 2.0 Basic.

14.3.1 par. 1
SMIL 2.0 Basic profile
The SMIL 2.0 Basic profile

14.3.1 par. 2
     While not strictly required, we strongly encourage languages
     based upon SMIL Basic to include the SyncbaseTiming module from
     SMIL 2.0 Timing and Synchronization using the scalable profiles
     mechanism, and for SMIL Basic User agents to support the module
     when device constraints are not prohibitive.
(removing the we, introducing "should," and rearranging the last clause:)
     While not strictly required, languages based upon SMIL Basic
     should include the SyncbaseTiming module from SMIL 2.0 Timing and
     Synchronization using the scalable profiles mechanism; SMIL Basic
     user agents should support this module when device constraints are
     not prohibitive.

14.3.1 last par.
     XML Namespace declaration using the xmlns and XML
     Internationalization xml:lang attributes are supported on all
could be:
     XML namespace declaration using the xmlns attribute and the XML
     internationalization xml:lang attribute are supported on all

"conforming" SMIL Basic Document
"conforming" SMIL Basic document

14.3.3 list items 3 and 4
conforming SMIL 2.0 Documents
conforming SMIL 2.0 documents

14.3.3 list item 5
Host Language Conformance
host language conformance

14.3.3 list item 8

14.3.3 list item 10
the XML 1.0 specification (Extensible Markup Language (XML) 1.0) [XML10]
the Extensible Markup Language (XML) 1.0 (Second Edition) [XML10]

[XMLNAMES] could link to References.

     Future work by W3C will address ways to specify conformance for
     documents involving multiple namespaces.
could be (erring in caution):
     It is expected that future work by W3C may address....

14.4.1 par. 3
XML Namespace declaration ... and XML Internationalization
XML namespace declaration ... and XML internationalization

14.4.1 list item 1
the SMIL Basic
SMIL Basic (or maybe, the SMIL Basic profile)

14.4.2 par. after examples
This provides for authors with a means
This provides authors with a means

     A conforming scalable user agent must conform to the requirements
     for SMIL Basic User Agents above.
could be (and link to smil-basic.html#BaseGuideNS-BasicUserAgent)
     A conforming scalable user agent must conform to the requirements
     for (conforming?) SMIL Basic user agents above.

In E., these references could have punctuation between the title and
author: [SMIL10], [SMIL-ANIMATION], [XML10], and [XPTR]

"Computer Graphics : Principles and Practice, Second Edition",
(two changes:)
"Computer Graphics: Principles and Practice," Second Edition,

In E., [CC/PP], [DOM1], [DOM2Events], [DOM2], [DOM2CSS], [SMIL-CSS2],
[SVG], [XHTML10], and [XSCHEMA] could have editors listed, using et al.
where applicable to save space.

E. [DOM2]
Specification". W3C

E. [HTML4] might be a normative reference. I'm not sure.

E. [IEEE-Arithmetic]
"IEEE ...  (R1990). ".
"IEEE ... (R1990)"

E. [ISO10646]
""Information Technology -- Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character
Set (UCS) -- Part 1: Architecture and Basic Multilingual Plane",
ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993...planes 1-16. "
"'Information Technology -- Universal Multiple-Octet Coded Character
Set (UCS) -- Part 1: Architecture and Basic Multilingual Plane',
ISO/IEC 10646-1:1993...planes 1-16."

E. [MathML], [XHTML11], [XLINK], [XMLBase]
MathML is now 2.0 (as I imagine you know) at http://www.w3.org/TR/MathML2/
and XHTML 1.1, XLink and XML Base are Recommendations.

E. [RDFschema]
Available at http://www.w3.org/TR/PR-rdf-schema/
Available at http://www.w3.org/TR/rdf-schema/

E. [SMIL10]
1.0" P. Hoschka.
1.0," P. Hoschka.

In E., is there a reason to list [SMIL20]?

Jacobs    .W3C
Jacobs. W3C

E. [XML10]
This is now Second Edition dated 6 October 2000, and Eve Maler is an editor.

Best wishes,
Susan Lesch - mailto:lesch@w3.org  tel:+1.858.483.4819
World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) - http://www.w3.org/
Received on Thursday, 5 July 2001 18:07:12 GMT

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.2.0+W3C-0.50 : Monday, 7 December 2009 10:53:27 GMT